Home » Jazz Articles » Reanimating Conversations Past » Woody Allen: All Stick, No Schtick

6

Woody Allen: All Stick, No Schtick

Woody Allen: All Stick, No Schtick

Courtesy Hans Kumpf

John Ephland By John Ephland

View read count
I’ve played in bands where the guys were deliberately playing crude. But for me, I’m playing to the top of my limit, the absolute top. So, in that sense, I can sometimes sound authentic.
When I look back nowadays, the timing of my interview with comedian/filmmaker Woody Allen ("All Stick, No Schtick"), now turning 91, couldn't have been worse. In fact, I felt that way from the beginning, when I pitched this story at DownBeat, published in their October, 1993, issue. But, I had been a fan of his movies for many years, and I wasn't going to let circumstances surrounding his personal life get in the way. (The controversy involving his former wife, Mia Farrow, and her child daughter had been brewing for some time.) Besides, Woody, a longtime jazz clarinetist, had a new album to promote, so there was a hook totally unrelated to any possible scandal. We could just talk music; which, I am sure, was a welcomed media respite for him.

It was a beautiful late-spring day, 1993, New York City. Ensconced in his screening room at the Manhattan Film Center in downtown Manhattan, one wall lined with jazz albums covering everyone from King Oliver to Oscar Peterson, Woody looked a tad weary. And yet, there was that bouncy Woody Allen voice, so often heard in his movies, and the attire he's worn for long it's become a kind of uniform, simple and unadorned: the starched, white long-sleeved shirt and pressed, khaki pants hanging on his truly small, wiry frame.

"I never thought I would be interviewed by DownBeat," Woody blurted out. "It was one of the fun things, you know, you'd take the subway and read it. I, in no way, connected with music, just a fan. It was fun to read."

Unlike the published feature in DownBeat, this visit is everything, the whole kit and caboodle, warts and all.

Sitting on a neighboring couch, Woody was cradling a large pillow like a teddy bear. When asked to comment on the then-new album The Bunk Project's origins, he started off in a familiar, unassuming manner, reminding me of his famous opening monologue to his Oscar-winning move Annie Hall: "I don't say this out of any sense of false modesty, but I don't consider myself even a passable musician of any sort. I think I'm a pretty terrible musician, as a matter of fact. I've only been a hobby clarinetist my whole life, playing privately." (This was coming from someone who, if he didn't get his two-hours-a-day of practice time, would be "absolutely consumed with guilt." One suspects that guilt complex holds true to this day.)

As I started writing my story, I commented on The Bunk Project (MusicMasters, 1993). "Depending on where you're sitting," I stated, "comic/moviemaker/clarinetist Woody Allen's recent first-ever jazz album is either 'a nice try, Woody, but stick to comedy,' or an interesting attempt to dust off some very early jazz.'" And so, right from the start of putting this story together, I was already casting aspersions even as I was eager to share his thoughts about jazz to the world.

After all, hadn't he lined many of his films with jazz over the years? I'm thinking of ... the list seems endless: "Tickle Toe" (Count Basie) from Stardust Memories, "You Made Me Love You" (Harry James) from Hannah And Her Sisters, "Moonglow" (Artie Shaw) from Annie Hall, "I'm Getting Sentimental Over You" (Tommy Dorsey) from Radio Days, "Body And Soul" (Benny Goodman) also from Radio Days, "Wild Man Blues" (Louis Armstrong) from Wild Man Blues. I still remember Woody panning over to the cover of Thelonious Monk's Monk's Dream album cover in Husbands And Wives. (Or was it his movie Alice?)

The Bunk Project was actually the work of the New York Jazz Ensemble, under the direction of veteran banjo player Eddy Davis, with Woody on board as a prominent sideman. Deriving its name from New Orleans trumpeter Bunk Johnson, and with all due respect to the top-notch professional musicians on hand, the album just might have prompted a few questions from your average skeptical observer: Was this yet another trad-jazz revival album with, once again, white musicians playing black music? Was it a comedy album with jazz filler? Was it a joke brought on by a self-effacing amateur clarinetist in search of respectability? And was that really Woody Allen standing with a bunch of strangers in that black & white album cover photo?

When I look back now on that early text to the story in DownBeat, I remember how I felt two things: 1) I was writing about someone who didn't have the usual bona fides that made for a feature in a music publication, a jazz publication to be specific; and 2) I was dealing with feelings of ambivalence about the whole enterprise of covering someone I wasn't so sure was the brilliant and funny guy (let alone talented musician) I admired for so long, that he might also have this dark side to him that was neither "brilliant" nor "funny." That second feeling, if that's what it was, led me to do something I had never done before: I intentionally (and unprofessionally) reported one aspect of his movie history inaccurately, not wanting to sound like a nerdy super fan who got it all right. (After the story ran, this inaccuracy prompted a reader to write a letter to the magazine with a correction, which we published, along with my response. But more on that in a bit.) In short, my personal feelings (and ego) got in the way of my journalistic standards. It wasn't the end of the world, but it did provide an important lesson: as a writer always maintain a certain distance from your subject matter, no matter how inspiring they or it may be, being sensitive to any feelings that might emerge along the way.

Were Woody's opening comments a reflection of his awareness of who the magazine's audience was, a kind of deference to the many fans and professional musicians that make up the bulk of its readership?

Essentially self-taught, Woody took up the clarinet at 15, after having studied the soprano saxophone and ukulele. A later interest in modern jazz led to his playing the vibraphone for a time. At 17, he took clarinet lessons from former Fats Waller and Conrad Janis band member Gene Sedric. In 1973, he recorded the soundtrack to his movie Sleeper with the Preservation Hall Jazz Band. As I wrote then, "to this day, he does not read music."

Early on, Woody favored traditional (i.e., very early) jazz's more rugged, languorous style over the sophisticated and more solo-oriented dixieland or Chicago styes. (Subsequent jazz styles were to remain of passing interest; I think of the Oscar Peterson album cover.) As author Eric Lax put it in his then-recent eponymously titled biography of Woody, this earlier New Orleans style of jazz was perfect for him because "[i]t hates authority; its quirky, individual style requires great discipline to play right; it is all the things that fit his own and his comic character."

During his stand-up comedy days of the 1960s, he crossed paths with veteran clarinetist Turk Murphy, who learned that he played clarinet, eventually managing to get Woody to play with him. "He coaxed me into playing with him. I said no," Woody retorted. "For weeks, he badgered me, wouldn't take no for an answer. He was so encouraging, and didn't care what I thought of myself, and he just forced me to do it." After a slight pause as he adjusted his posture, he intoned, "And after that I started to play with other people. And I started to play with guys in New York. In their living room, just for fun. I had no ambition in it. I just loved to play. And they said, after about a year playing together, 'Why don't we go play in a club in New York?' And I said, 'Fine.' I never took any money for it. I never wanted to get paid. We went into this club [Michael's Pub], and we've been playing there now for, I don't know, 25 years every Monday night [since 1971]." (Revise that number upwards into the 21st century.) The group, called the New Orleans Funeral and Ragtime Orchestra, was made up of mostly non-professionals. (He's been playing with the New Orleans Jazz Band at Carlyle Hotel café in Manhattan every Monday evening since 1997.)

"And then," Woody continued, "five years ago [think late '80s], Eddy Davis joined our group. I met Eddy many years ago in Chicago, in the '60s. I was playing Mister Kelly's on Rush Street. I used to play jazz for fun at Jan Scoby's, near Mister Kelly's. I went in and played there, and Eddy was the banjo player, and we just sat and talked a little bit, and that was it. And then, cut to just five years ago or something. He showed up, sat in, and remembered that time. Eddy is great; he gave a tremendous nuclear lift to the band the second he came in. He's probably the best traditional jazz banjo player in the world."

As for the formation of The Bunk Project, Woody stated, "Eddy had his own group, and he said, 'You be the clarinetist and let's just make some sessions just for fun.' He brought a tape recording, and we played a half-dozen sessions, and suggested that he might think of putting it out. I said, 'You can do it if you want to; if I don't hold the band back too much, fine. I don't want to be advertised or featured.' And so he did; he put the whole thing together, every bit of it." Woody mentioned that Eddy came up with the name for the Bunk Project. Recorded at New York's Harkness House over a two-year period (and released on the MusicMasters label), Woody related, "It was truly a jam session of a group of musicians, many of whom didn't even know each other. Some of the musicians in the band are terrific." Indeed, as the liner notes to the album pointed out, "The tunes were unrehearsed and called out at random by anyone present as the spirit moved them." The jam-session flavor extends to the less than state-of-the-art sound quality, with beer-hall acoustics consistent with the music itself.

Getting him to comment on his own playing, Woody confessed, "I've played in bands where the guys were deliberately playing crude. But for me, I'm playing to the top of my limit, the absolute top. So, in that sense, I can sometimes sound authentic." Eric Lax also put a positive spin on it: "[Woody] displays more feeling, more emotion, in his music than he does in any other way, at least in public. There are times in the way he loses himself in a melody when he seems almost to be caressing the notes."

On The Bunk Project, this plaintive, emotional playing—reminiscent of idols Sidney Bechet and George Lewis—can be heard clearly on slow, wistful tunes like "What A Friend We Have In Jesus" and "Burgundy Street Blues." But Woody was the first to admit that his playing, and the album in general, is "a stepping stone on to better stuff" (e.g., the music of Bechet and Lewis). Speaking of Bechet and Lewis, Woody admiringly stated, "Sidney Bechet is a totally majestic player, he's tremendously dirty in his sound, mean and aggressive and sexual and very, very florid. George Lewis is more like a miniature, you know, very very delicate, very very religious in his playing. They both have a tremendous, uncanny sense of rhythm, a hotness. But totally different voices, totally different guys, and their personalities are reflected in their playing. Sidney Bechet is like an animal." A virtuoso? "Certainly more of a virtuoso. George Lewis is a primitive genius, delicate and very beautiful."

I went on to comment about Woody's remarks about life and art, and how, as I quoted him, paraphrasing, "taking this music, making things right, somehow perfect in an imperfect world, there's an intentional effort to play in an imperfect, almost crude way that somehow resolves in how you feel." And then mentioned that in one of his movies he said that in art, things work out whereas in life things are kind of messy. I told him that these notions were something that I was picking up from The Bunk Project. Woody replied, after a sudden cough, "Well, two things: one, the chord changes in this kind of music are predictable; the few guys that play it well, like George Lewis and Sidney Bechet, they're so great that what you realize is that what counts on the horn, or any instrument, is only the feeling the person has for it. So, George Lewis could play just a scale and it would be beautiful. It's irrelevant that these are like three-chord songs, some of them, and they'll sustain them and the audience will go crazy listening to it because of ... there's some communication, you're saying something in the feel. The only thing I could say for myself is that I've always played with better musicians than I am."

As if repeating himself, he added, "I've played in bands where the guys were deliberately playing crude; but, for me, I'm playing at the absolute top of my limit. So, in that sense, I can sometimes sound authentic, because, George Lewis is playing at the top of his ability, too. Now, his ability is monumental. I'm not trying to play crude. That's the way that I sound playing at the best that I can play; so, sometimes I can get to sound authentic. But, I'm playing next to guys occasionally who are quite brilliant but are playing down a little bit. And, if you get a guy who is really good, you know sometimes you'll hear jazz musicians, modern jazz musicians, contemporary guys, classical guys who tell you that they can play this because they are such incredible musicians. But when they try and play it, they don't sound good playing it, you know, they just don't sound good."

It sounds forced? "It doesn't sound authentic. It sounds like what happens on the date when someone plays boogie-woogie. If they're playing in their own idiom, forget it. For instance, if you got someone like [John] Coltrane and asked him to play this kind of thing, I'm sure he would say to you, 'I could play that if I wanted to.' And what he's thinking of, I think, he would hold his sound down, hold his impulses back. But I'm wondering really if those guys ever would sound like that. I don't think they would. This is my experience, by sitting next to some very good studio musicians who can play brilliantly. It's hard for this kind of thing to sound really authentic." In passing, Woody also recommended another great, Albert Burbank.

"It's the same thing with watching Buster Keaton or Charlie Chaplin. The guys were great. The fact that they were doing simplistic things and silent movies and had simplistic relationships, you don't care about that. They're ten times better than lesser talents today. And George Lewis, for all his lack of training, and Burbank, they're more fun to listen to; because, in the final analysis what counts is what you're saying, and they're saying more."

The conversation eventually drifted toward the music in his movies, the soundtracks. Woody considered Duke Ellington as a possible source, but, in the final analysis found his music too hot, as in being more like jungle music, a term that was used to describe his early work in particular. And yet, as I pointed out, you want those individual, authentic voices, not some kind of generic jazz music.

"At given moments, it's great," he replied, "Bobby Short over the titles is very strong; he's singing in person in a nightclub in Hannah. What I don't want is for those guys to be singing while we're playing a scene up front in the movie, so that when you get past the scene then you get to the theme, because the theme is always gonna be better than the scene; you know the guy sings great and it's beautiful music."

Background, foreground, the music finds its place around the story. "Right," he responded. "And then at certain moments, you want to emphasize the scene over the music. For instance, that's why I use a lot of Erroll Garner; 'cause Erroll, there's a cocktail quality in his piano playing; as great as it is, he's basically a cocktail-jazz pianist. And so, I use him a lot because he can play stuff ... it doesn't feel foreground, it gives it a lift, and full of feeling and energy, but it doesn't, you know, ruin the foreground."

Woody mentioned Louis Armstrong's Hot Five and Sevens music, recorded in Chicago in the 1920s, as being influential to his early interest in jazz. I asked him about Armstrong's recording of "Potato Head Blues," since he referred to it towards the end of his movie Manhattan.

"There are a couple of tunes," he chimed in, "that are just sublime. You know the end half of 'Potato Head Blues' is trumpet playing at its ... great. It's just miraculous trumpet playing. Certainly 'Cornet Chop Suey' is absolutely fantastic. I heard that when Jack Teagarden heard that he got drunk and went out and buried the record someplace in the ground because he wanted to make sure that a copy of it would last forever. It really is what art is all about; it's so great in a way that you can't analyze ... you know it's great, and other trumpet players have tried to play the end of 'Muggles,' for example, and tried to copy Louis ... for some reason they can't get it. Cause they can imitate it, imitate it, imitate it, but, finally, when it comes down to it ... when I went down to New Orleans some time ago, there was a jazz festival, and everybody in the world was imitating George Lewis. There's the Swedish George Lewis, there's the Israeli George Lewis, New York George Lewis. It was incredible, and everyone of them, but, and they can imitate him perfectly but finally you hear it and you say that's not George Lewis. But there's somebody imitating really brilliantly, 'cause there's that final thing that they can't get down to, strip away all the layers."

Towards the end of our time together, I asked him about how he had a tendency to accompany others when they're soloing with a kind of low-register sound. I asked him how he got that kind of gurgling sound.

"That is my low register; and it's a very traditional New Orleans low register. It's called shalomar [he asked rhetorically]. There's a word for it [he spelled it out, guessing]: chalumeau. It's a certain kind of low register that is a real characteristic of New Orleans music. Every one of the piano players in New Orleans all have a very specific kind of, I don't know what you call it, a buzzing low register. And I just have one from hearing them. That's the best that I can play."

A collector of vintage clarinets, Woody's main ax was a then-77-year-old Albert system clarinet, a 12-key Rampone fellow-clarinetist Kenny Davern picked up in a pawn shop for $12. "A real junky clarinet," Woody admitted. "But it sounds good when I play it. The guy that repairs it for me all the time says, you know, 'Get rid of it.'" (Benny Goodman put him on to one of his Albert system clarinets: "The most beautiful Selmer you've ever heard.") It's bigger, more difficult to master, and tends to play only approximately in tune; another sign of authenticity and a musical goal of Woody's.

One of my last questions was about the then-young jazz clarinetist Don Byron. Along with giving Woody a then-new DownBeat t-shirt I also mentioned to him about a then-recent album about the music of Mickey Katz. Klezmer music. Is that something that Woody had ever been drawn to?

"I've heard good klezmer music. Good klezmers have mailed me their albums. It's in the ball park, kind of interesting to me; it's a real strange style."

As I reported back then (and what I have since recounted here): the other major part of Woody's musical life could be heard through his movies. From the swing-era laced Radio Days to his Gershwin tribute, Manhattan, to his paean to America's songbook, his movies have, among other things, been catalysts for viewers to seek out the music they hear in them. In fact, I added, more recent films showed the hand of Woody Allen, the music compiler, in lieu of a composer who scores for his movies.

"I've used jazz scoring for years," he said with obvious pride. "And it's great, because you have that whole library at your disposal. I have been going strictly by my record collection for years. Some of the best music you'll ever hear is in Stardust Memories; the score that is just fabulous. [Louis Armstrong and Django Reinhardt are prominently displayed.] It's a chance for people to hear some of these records they've never heard before. It's a way for people to hear music they've never heard before and they'll wanna know who is this guy. I'm always stunned when people say it. You know, simple jazz stuff. It happens with classical music, too." Jazz pianist and composer Dick Hyman, even though he didn't come up in our interview, has also played a significant role in helping to score a number of Woody's films.

"Ninety percent of the time you're being treated to an original score," Woody remarked. "There's the expense and all of that. And, you know, here, you have the whole world at your disposal ... it's such a pleasure to come in here and to walk into this office and run through records, pick out music, and see what would be nice to accompany a scene; it's really fun." (And remember, this was before the advent of the widespread Internet.)

And here's where that passive-aggressive writing that prompted the DownBeat reader's letter emerged. Simply put, instead of listing the movie as Manhattan, I consciously wrote, "At the end of Stardust Memories, perhaps his most personal and autobiographical film to date, Allen is seen laying on a couch, talking into a portable tape recorder, reflecting on the age-old question, 'Why is life worth living?'"

His answer included a variety of delights. Among them, as mentioned, Louis Armstrong's recording of "Potato Head Blues." It appeared (and appears?) the music Woody the romantic loved/loves follows him around even more than a good joke worth telling. More than Chaplin, Keaton, or Ingmar Bergman, Armstrong reminded Woody if he'd "been born with a massive talent," the life of a full-time musician would've been "the best life I can think of." Like Sigmund F might have said, I was captivated by an ego.

And, as I finished back then, I added two words: "Bunk, indeed."

John Ephland FOLLOW John Ephland and get notified whenever a new article published.
A lover of music finds the words to express it. Once in a while.



About Woody Allen

Tags


PREVIOUS / NEXT




Become a Sustaining Member

Get the Jazz Near You newsletter

Since 1995, All About Jazz has championed jazz as an art form and supported the musicians who create it. Over three decades, it has grown into one of the world's leading jazz resources, serving hundreds of thousands of readers, musicians, presenters and industry professionals each month.

Help Build the Future of All About Jazz

Your support helps us continue building All About Jazz for the next generation—expanding our editorial coverage, preserving jazz history, developing new community features and creating better ways to discover the music and the people behind it.

Become a sustaining member for as little as $20 per year and you'll immediately enjoy an ad-free experience along with access to subscriber features and future articles for a full year.

Together, we're not simply sustaining All About Jazz—we're building its future. Thank you for being part of the journey.

More

Jazz article: Woody Allen: All Stick, No Schtick
Reanimating Conversations Past
Woody Allen: All Stick, No Schtick
Jazz article: John Scofield: Meant To Be
Reanimating Conversations Past
John Scofield: Meant To Be
Jazz article: Charlie Haden: Anatomy of a Jazz Classic
Reanimating Conversations Past
Charlie Haden: Anatomy of a Jazz Classic
Jazz article: And His Name Was Max
Reanimating Conversations Past
And His Name Was Max

Popular

HIDDEN GEMS

Jazz article: The Instrument Maker: Roger Sadowsky
Jazz article: Tony Malaby: Turnpike Diaries

Get more of a good thing!

Our weekly newsletters highlight our top stories, top album reviews, website news, free songs, radio & podcast shows, news, and upcoming jazz events near you.