This article appears in the preface of Keystone Korner: Portrait of a Jazz Club
by Kathy Sloane (Indiana Univ. Press, 2011). The Keystone Legacy
I enjoy imagining jazz clubs as I listen to live recordings, and if those sessions took place at venues I've known, I find it downright difficult not to recreate (and sometimes relive) the setting. I'm thinking now of Bradley's in New York, with its long bar to the right and the portrait of Paul Desmond over his donated grand piano; when I hear recordings from Bradley'sespecially the two marvelous CDs by Kenny Barron
I'm suddenly on a bar stool. Same for the Village Vanguard: I'm subterranean, surrounded by jazz portraits along the dark walls of fame. Even Carnegie Hall and festivals at Newport bring to mind specific spaces and images. Yes, the music must always be paramount and few recordings capture the energized vitality of live performance, but the ambiance of jazz creates a still greater intimacy with the music, and that's where photographs and the written word can inspire specific memories or imagined stage settings.
Like most East Coast jazz fans of my generation, I never had the opportunity to experience Keystone Korner, and until I met Kathy Sloane, I appreciated the club exclusively for its live recordings. Some of my early LP purchases included Art Blakey's In This Korner
, McCoy Tyner's Atlantis
, and Stan Getz's The Dolphin
; later, I picked up astonishing Keystone recordings by Bill Evans
, Dexter Gordon
, Freddie Hubbard
, Rahsaan Roland Kirk
, Tete Montoliu
, Woody Shaw
, Zoot Sims
, Eddie "Cleanhead" Vinson
, Mary Lou Williams
, Denny Zeitlin
, and many others. Long before this project began, my Keystone collection swellednot out of admiration for the club but for its musicians. Todd Barkan's taste in music fed my musical desires; my life would be truly diminished had he not had the vision to create this club and the intelligence to record the lasting music by the artists who passed through.
And now, thanks to Kathy's photographs and her hardearned triumph of oral history, I experience Keystone Korner all the more intimately. Sure, it's farfetched to say that I can smell Ora's cooking when I hear the tunes, but, with ease, I can now place the sound within the psychedelic atmosphere: the tightly packed crowds awash in legal and illegal smoke, eyes focused on the musicians onstage beneath the dramatic mural. Because of the stories of witness and beautiful visuals, I listen with new ears to introductions by such favorite artists as Dexter Gordon: "On our last European tour, we happened to visit Scotland," he announced on the first of three Keystone volumes. "We saw the" and here he pauses with a typically long Dexter cadence, and in the background one can here the clink
of glasses. Suddenly, I'm wondering if it's Helen Wray, struggling with one of those weighted trays and working hard to get the drinks out before the music begins. Then Dexter hits the punch line: "Loch Ness monster." There's laughter, and someone says "All right," as in, "Okay, if you say so." And I might as well be in the first row, looking up at this tenor genius beneath a halo of mural as he adds, "He made quite an impression."
Because the sound engineers left the tapes running, we get to hear Zoot Sims and company calling out the next tune and key ("I'll Remember April" in G) during the applause. We hear the audience whooping when Eddie Cleanhead Vinson starts to sing "They Call Me Mr. Cleanhead," and later giggling and hollering like rentparty audiences as he works his way into the climax of "Back Door Blues." On Art Pepper's San Francisco Samba
, we hear an audience member over the final, fading notes to "Art Meets Mr. Beautiful" call to his hero, "Love you, Art." But now we can almost befriend the audience members. For me, at least, the Keystone doors have reopened.
Imagine, for a moment, the young bassist Marc Johnson
beneath the giant mandala, his eyes half shut, almost rolled back. Drummer Joe La Barbera
's to the right of the stage, and to Marc's left, behind the piano, sits their leader, Bill Evans. During his weeklong engagement in 1980, the trio plays several versions of "Nardis." Early in the week, he looks through the smoke and says, "We're going to conclude this set with an extended version of something that's been in our repertoire from the beginning . . . We've learned from the potential of the tune, and every once in a while a new gateway opens. It's like therapy, this tune." On September 8, his last night of the engagement, he closed with another version of "Nardis," almost twenty minutes long. "We've had a very nice engagement here," he tells the crowd. "You people in the audiences have been wonderful, and I hope we'll be back soon." On September 15, he died.
Depending on the music, the crowds could be raucous or reverentlike congregations in disparate church settings. For a gig led by pianist Tete Montoliu one can hear sporadic, gospellike shouts of encouragement during Herbie Lewis's lengthy bass solo on "I'll Remember April," a twelveanda--half minute tune that concludes with "All right! All right!" and whistles and cheers. Then Tete Montoliu, relaxes the room with a rubato performance of "You've Changed." In the background, the clinking of glasses fuse with Billy Higgins
' cymbals. But at a recording by Mary Lou Williamslook at Kathy's photos for a momentshe held the crowd the way she must have entranced her college students: "Thank you. Good evening, friends. I'd like to bring you up to date to demonstrate the history of jazz. Most Americans do not know that the greatest art in the world was created in America. First was the spirituals, ragtime, Kansas City swing; that was a great era of jazz, of the welltrained musicians. Out of that: Charlie Parker
, Dizzy Gillespie
, Thelonious Monk
the bop era. What we're trying to do is bring good jazz back to youwith the healing in it and the spiritual feelingso I'd like to start out with the spirituals."
In the liner notes for Rahsaan Roland Kirk's album Bright Moments
, Joel Dorn describes the Keystone atmosphere as a "hipness that permeates the room that can not be designed or wished into or added onto a club. It's either there or it isn't." Thanks to these oral histories, I feel that much closer to the hip environmentand all the more disappointed not to have experienced Keystone firsthand.
With Kathy's photographs, however, I can visualize the stage as I listen to these musicians speak and play, and I feel at least an approximation of the Keystone ambiance, which seems to have been an oasis in its time and now something nearly mythic. And I can feel the deep, heartfelt honesty in Rahsaan Roland Kirk's voice when he says: "You know it's good to be in a place that feels like you in your house, you know?" [The audience responds like gospel churchgoers: Yeah!
] "Now, it's a beautiful thingwe glad you people are assembled here with us on this Saturday night." [Someone says, "All right."] You know what I mean? ["Yeah
." "Yeah."] "You don't feel like Saturday night people; some Saturday night people, that's the only night they get out, and they act like it." [Laughter and clapping and some mild whoops.] "You know like, when you cage somethin' up and when it gets out they act like it. That's the way most Saturday night people act. Now, we would like to think of some very beautiful bright moments." ["Yeah."] "You know what I mean?" ["Yeahyeah
."] "Bright moments." ["Bright moments."] "Bright moments is like" [Rahsaan chuckles] "eatin' your last pork chop in London, England, because you ain't gonna get no mo'" [Laughter. "Bright moments."] "cooked from home." ["Bright moments."] "Bright moments is like bein' with your favorite love, and ya'll sharin' the same ice cream dish" [laughter] "and you get mad when she gets the last drop." [The crowd laughs, and Rahsaan laughs with them. "Bright moments!"] "And you have to take her in your arms and get it the other way." [Wooo!" "Bright moments."] "Bright moments." ["Bright moments."] "That's too heavy for most of ya'll because ya'll don't know about that kind of love. The love ya'll have been taught about is the love in those magazines, and I am fortunate that I didn't have to look in magazines." [Rahsaan laughs with the audience.] "Bright moments!" ["Bright moments."] "Bright moments is like seein' somethin' that you ain't never seen in your life and you don't have to see it but you know how it looks." [Applause. "Bright moments!" "Bright moments."] "Bright moments is like hearin' some music that ain't nobody else heard, and if they heard it they wouldn't even recognize that they heard it because they been hearin' it all their life but they nutted on it, so when you hear it and you start poppin' your feet and jumpin' up and down, they get mad because you enjoying yourself but those are bright moments that they can't share with you because they don't know even how to even go about listenin' to what you listenin' to, and when you try to tell 'em about it, they don't know a damn thing about what you talkin' about." [Screams, whoops, and charged applause.] "Is there any other bright moments before we proceed on?" ["Testify!"] "Testify!" ["Bright moments!" And then someone in the audience answers the calling: "Bright moments is sitting at the Keystone Korner"] Beautiful!" ["and listening to geniuses like Rahsaan Roland Kirk."] Beautiful. Bright moments. Bright moments. Bright moments is like havin' brothers and sisters, and sisterettes and brotherettes like ya'll here listening to us." [Wild applause.]
Man, I'm there. And you're there with me, aren't you?
Learn more about Keystone Korner: Portrait of a Jazz Club
. © 2011, Kathy Sloane