Bill Evans: Live At Art D'Lugoff's Top of The Gate

By C. MICHAEL BAILEY
June 6, 2012
Sign in to view read count

Track review of "My Funny Valentine"

Bill Evans: Live At Art D'Lugoff's Top of The Gate

slideshow

Why is pianist Bill Evans so important to jazz? it is simple: every pianist to hear and perform after him was influenced by him. Art Tatum and Oscar Peterson may have been technically more brilliant and extroverted, but it took first Bud Powell and then Evans to turn the creative tables toward the muted and introverted, thereby beginning a jazz piano cultural revolution that continues to this day. Evans had an almost painfully personal style that, like late-period Art Pepper, bared naked his troubled soul in exquisite detail.

This never-before-released sides from Resonance Records, Live At Art D'Lugoff's Top of The Gate, is notable for having a couple of firsts: it's the first-ever documented Evans trio recordings of "My Funny Valentine" and "Yesterdays," while "Witchcraft" is Evans' only recording of this Cy Coleman-Carolyn Leigh song, aside from the 1959 studio version appearing on Portrait in Jazz (Riverside).

It is "My Funny Valentine," however, that shines most brightly. A ballad, always fertile territory for Evans' inward thinking, it is treated with an anathema hard swing by the normally quiet and thoughtful pianist. Evans tries to fool with an impressionistic introduction that, in time, fully dissembles into a full-fledged show tune for jazz piano trio. Bassist Eddie Gomez, perhaps Evans' greatest bass collaborator after the tragic loss of Scott LaFaro, plays his level best, guiding Evans, while drummer Marty Morell watches the tempo road signs.

It is Gomez that turns introspective (in a wordy fashion) on his solo, with Evans' bright accompaniment providing the bassist a spark of effervescence. This performance is nothing short of stunning and it may be quite proper that no one has emerged on piano to dethrone the last great muse of the 88 keys.

Track Listing: CD1: Emily; Witchcraft; Yesterdays; Round Midnight; My Funny Valentine; California Here I Come; Gone With The Wind; Alfie; Turn Out The Stars. CD2: Yesterdays; Emily; Round Midnight; In A Sentimental Mood; Autumn Leaves; Someday My Prince Will Come; Mother of Earl; Here's That Rainy Day.

Personnel: Bill Evans: piano; Eddie Gomez: bass; Marty Morell: drums.

Title: Live At Art D'Lugoff's Top Of The Gate | Year Released: 2012 | Record Label: Resonance Records

About Bill Evans

view slideshow

CD/LP/Track Review
My Singing Fingers
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: May 25, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Ain't It Grand?
by Jack Bowers
Published: May 25, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
If Not Now, When?
by Dan Bilawsky
Published: May 25, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Perfectly Unhappy
by Gareth Thompson
Published: May 25, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Sorrows & Triumphs
by Jerome Wilson
Published: May 25, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Half Light
by Karl Ackermann
Published: May 24, 2018

Read Life is Brief: The Music of Bob Dylan

CD/LP/Track Review
Life is Brief: The Music of Bob Dylan
by Mark Sullivan
Published: May 18, 2018

Read Festival International de Musique Actuelle de Victoriaville 2018, Part 1

Live Reviews
Festival International de Musique Actuelle de Victoriaville...
by Mike Chamberlain
Published: May 21, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Travelers
by John Kelman
Published: May 18, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Earth
by Chris May
Published: May 20, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Movement
by K. Shackelford
Published: May 18, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review
Cosmic Language
by Chris May
Published: May 20, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review Green Moss Black Sand
by Chris Mosey
Published: July 30, 2017

CD/LP/Track Review Drama
by Matthew Aquiline
Published: September 9, 2017

CD/LP/Track Review # 1
by Troy Dostert
Published: July 24, 2017

CD/LP/Track Review Najwa
by Chris M. Slawecki
Published: May 17, 2018

CD/LP/Track Review Of Light and Shadows
by Phillip Woolever
Published: December 9, 2017

CD/LP/Track Review Agrima
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: October 18, 2017

Showcase

Buy Now

Life Of by Steve Tibbetts
Buy Now

Seymour Reads The... by Brad Mehldau
Buy Now

Outsidethebox by Sasha Mashin
Buy Now

Dreaming Spirits by Mark Egan
Buy Now

Sebastiana by Ricardo Bacelar
Buy Now

Awase by Nik Bärtsch
Buy Now

e.s.t. live in london by Esbjorn Svensson

Story of the Day

I love jazz because it rewards careful listening. Jazz can be as deep and complicated and deep as classical music, but with a sense of modernity and FUN. It swings! My parents listened to jazz a little bit
Read more

I love jazz because it rewards careful listening. Jazz can be as deep and complicated and deep as classical music, but with a sense of modernity and FUN. It swings! My parents listened to jazz a little bit. Then in high school I got a crush on my best friend's older brother, who was a huge jazz fan. He turned me on to Miles Davis' Bitches Brew (which was also the first album I ever bought) and the rest is history. I've met many musicians. It's a joy to live in NYC where there is such a vital community and lots of interaction between players and audience. The best show I ever attended was... God, there have been so many great ones. My absolute favorite might be the John Lurie tribute concert at the Town Hall. Was it 2013 or 2014? I've been a huge Lounge Lizards fan since the '90s, and many of my favorite local musicians are graduates of that band. It was a joy to see so many of them come out and show their love for John Lurie. Even though he doesn't play sax anymore, he is still a presence. There was so much LOVE in that show. And since the Lounge Lizards don't perform anymore, it was a treat to hear their music live again. My advice to new listeners... JUST KEEP LISTENING. If you're used to repetition and easy hooks of rock or pop music, you might find it challenging at first to float along with the unpredictability of jazz. But the rewards are worth it! You will learn to listen actively, not passively, and as you tune your mind into every note, texture, and harmony, you'll begin to listen to music in a new and different way. At the best live shows, it's almost a meditative experience for me. My mind just trips out on the music. It's pure bliss, even if the music is abrasive or challenging. Also, don't be afraid to LISTEN TO ARTIST YOU'VE NEVER HEARS OF BEFORE. The greats like Miles Davis, John Coltrane, Duke Ellington, etc. are famous for a reason. Their music stands the test of time. But there are so many young artist pushing the boundaries and creating their individual style. You might not love every show or album you listen to, but you'll discover so much. Jazz is not a museum piece--it's a living, breathing art form with almost infinite possibilities. Finally, if you love the music, PARTICIPATE IN THE ECONOMY. Buy some new CDs instead of streaming everything. Go to live shows and pay the ticket price. Even if it's donation only and you can sneak in for free, remember that most of these artists have years of training and have devoted themselves to an obscure art form out of pure love. Playing music is their job. You get paid for your job, and musicians deserve to get paid too.
Show less

By Jennifer DeMeritt
Member since: 2018