Musician? Boost Your Visibility at All About Jazz

Upgrade your AAJ musician page from standard to premium and make your presence felt!

Maximize your visibility at All About Jazz by upgrading your musician page from standard to premium. With it, you'll receive All About Jazz home page exposure, a highly stylized / ad-free musician page with bonus features and benefits, an ad, plus you control where you sell your music and so much more.
Learn More

John Coltrane: Coltrane And Crescent—Shadows And Light

Mark Werlin BY

Sign in to view read count
Some jazz musicians—too many—cast their own shadows of addiction and self-destructiveness. But often—too often—new directions and developments in jazz are shadowed not by the musicians themselves, but by their detractors.
Visual art is a play of shadow and light, and contrast makes the forms visible. In the best jazz music, there is a kind of inner light that emanates from the musicians, the light of creative impulse, the light of spontaneous artistic expression. Some jazz musicians—too many—cast their own shadows of addiction and self-destructiveness. But often—too often—new directions and developments in jazz are shadowed not by the musicians themselves, but by their detractors.

A series of Impulse albums of the John Coltrane Quartet are being released as 192kHz/24bit downloads, coinciding with the 90th anniversary of Coltrane's birth. Two of those albums, Coltrane, recorded in 1962, and Crescent, recorded in 1964, can be viewed as bookends in the career of the Quartet: Coltrane was the first studio date by the classic lineup and Crescent was one of the last Quartet sessions prior to Coltrane's departure on his late-phase musical journey. Both albums capture the ensemble at significant moments in its development, and warrant acknowledgment as major works.

Why then, have these two recordings been accorded so little attention by writers and musical authorities? In the standard biographies, even in Lewis Porter's excellent John Coltrane: His Life and Music, the subject albums receive scant description and analysis, as if they were afterthoughts or sketches rather than fully-conceived projects.

It is likely that these albums are overlooked because so much light is trained on the sessions that preceded and succeeded them: Live at the Village Vanguard and Impressions from November 1961, and A Love Supreme from December 1964. The recordings of the John Coltrane-Eric Dolphy band were considered so important that producer Michael Cuscuna gathered all the tapes made during November 1961 and issued a much-expanded 4-CD set. In 2002, the Impulse team, working with original session engineer Rudy Van Gelder, successfully located an uncompressed safety copy of A Love Supreme (the original master tape having been lost) in the EMI tape vault; a French radio broadcast master tape of a 1965 live performance; and Coltrane's own work tapes preserved by his family, in preparation for A Love Supreme (Deluxe Edition).

If those spotlights unintentionally cast deep historical shadows over Coltrane and Crescent, the earlier album was intentionally shadowed—at the time of its recording—by a campaign of uninformed music criticism and personal attacks on Coltrane and Dolphy published in prestigious American newspapers and the preeminent jazz magazine Down Beat. The hostility and incomprehension that followed Coltrane and Dolphy's appearances at the Village Vanguard and their U.S. and European tour dates bears reexamination, as it had a significant impact on the label's working relationship with Coltrane, and Trane's own artistic development.


John Coltrane's earliest recordings for Impulse were shaped by his friendship and collaboration with Eric Dolphy. The live performances on Live at the Village Vanguard and Impressions reveal the tenor player transitioning away from the dense compositional structures that reached an apogee on Giant Steps towards song forms inspired by Eric's enthusiasm for African and Indian music. The months working with Dolphy, and the accumulated conversations about jazz the two friends had enjoyed since first meeting in the mid-1950s, had the greatest impact on Coltrane's development after his 1957 tenure with Thelonious Monk. Dolphy, though he always played on the changes, was a pioneering 'outside' jazz musician; restless, innovative, obsessive. His dazzling, wide-interval alto sax solos and virtuoso bass clarinet playing opened Trane's already 'big ears' even wider.

A glance at Dolphy's studio dates prior to his recordings with Coltrane reveals that the Southern Californian was operating on the fringes of the New York jazz scene, and that his inclination was towards his fellow outsiders: Coltrane couldn't have chosen a more divisive musical partner; the East Coast critics didn't understand Eric Dolphy any better than they did Ornette Coleman. Dolphy's close association with the combative Mingus, whom he had known while growing up in Los Angeles, placed him firmly in the enemy camp. Dolphy was West Coast, but he swam far outside the cool jazz currents and the Blue Note Records hard-bop mainstream.

John and Eric took a further step beyond the boundaries of acceptable conduct for signed musicians when they befriended the Nigerian percussionist Babatunde Olatunji, who was bringing African music and pan-African cultural consciousness to New York's black community. Olatunji, an outspoken civil rights activist, traveled the American South with Dr. Martin Luther King and would participate in the 1963 March on Washington. Coltrane had spent endless hours practicing music from a European theoretical ground; now he was being exposed to music from the African continent. Dolphy's fascination with African rhythms and Indian classical music, and the possibilities opened up by playing over drone melodic patterns, led to the collaborative piece "India," which he and Coltrane performed and recorded during the November 1961 Village Vanguard run.

Catching Trane by surprise, several jazz critics attacked the direction of his new music. Over the following months, Coltrane's recording plans were shadowed by a rancorous debate in the pages of Down Beat Magazine. After hearing Coltrane and Dolphy perform, Down Beat's West Coast editor John Tynan wrote:

"I listened to a horrifying demonstration of what appears to be a growing anti-jazz trend... Melodically and harmonically their improvisation struck my ear as gobbledygook... to these ears the sum of the sounds remains musical nonsense." (John Tynan, Down Beat, November 23, 1961)

The chorus of incomprehension extended across the Atlantic to the respected English publication Melody Maker:

"Despite the most intense concentration, I had no more idea at the end of the group's hour-long programme what it was all about, than I had at the beginning. There just seems to be no logical basis to any of it." (Bob Dawbarn, Melody Maker)

Even allowing for the unfamiliarity of the new music, such misguided reviews were not a response to Coltrane and Dolphy's demonstration of "anti-jazz" but evidence of those critics' stopped-up ears and reactionary preconceptions about what was musically acceptable in the genre.

Down Beat managing editor Don DeMicheal took the unprecedented step of interviewing Coltrane and Dolphy in a lengthy column. In keeping with his generous nature, Trane made a sincere request that writers who did not understand what he and Eric were playing should meet with him in person and discuss the music face to face. To John's disappointment, none of those so quick to condemn what they clearly did not understand ever responded to his offer. Trane's knowledge of theory and harmony was not a closely-held secret: but the preeminent jazz publications in the English language published article after uninformed article by critics who failed to recognize the complex harmonic logic underlying Coltrane's music.

Dolphy stopped performing regularly with Coltrane in the Spring of 1962, but Trane wasn't finished with the music they had created together. Over the course of four sessions, the John Coltrane Quartet, now with a permanent membership of McCoy Tyner, piano, Jimmy Garrison, bass and Elvin Jones, drums, succeeded in recapturing the character, if not the overwhelming energy, of the November 1961 Village Vanguard performances.

John was not immune to the stings of critical arrows. The only track recorded on April 11, 1962—at the nadir of the Down Beat controversy—deemed good enough for the album was Frank Loesser's "The Inch Worm." Trane uses the song's simple melodic line as a springboard for an extended, probing solo on soprano sax that recalls his work on My Favorite Things. Recording didn't resume until June, when the Quartet reentered the studio for a series of sessions that completed the album.

"Out of this World"—almost unrecognizable as a Harold Arlen standard—and the Coltrane original "Tunji" most closely recapture the mood and energy of the Village Vanguard live recordings. Elvin is playing at the limits of how hard drumsticks can strike drum heads and cymbals without splintering. It must have required considerable force of will—and a certain recklessness—to achieve this level of intensity in the studio. Coltrane is straining at the limits of his own technique, honking in the low register and rising through complex ascending arpeggios to the upper register 'cry.' There is a greater emphasis on the vocal qualities of the horn, something Trane would have heard in Dolphy's playing (listen to the vocalized duet with Charles Mingus on "What Love?" from the 1960 Candid sessions). The music of Coltrane is modal jazz, but far from the cerebral music advanced by George Russell or the comparatively restrained work by the Miles Davis Sextet on Kind of Blue. In the middle section of "Tunji," after Trane has soloed at length over a single chord sustained by the piano and bass, McCoy introduces a blues chord progression with a variant turnaround for his own solo choruses. The sudden switch from drone to blues is unsettling and effective; it draws attention to the contrasting forms and catches the listener by surprise.

Mal Waldron's "Soul Eyes" provides a respite; Elvin on brushes, McCoy displaying a delicate touch, Coltrane indulging his passion for ballads. The final piece, "Miles' Mode," follows the Village Vanguard arrangement closely, but differs in ways that illustrate how changes in personnel and setting can alter a performance. The absence of a live audience and crucially, the subtraction of Eric Dolphy and the substitution of Jimmy Garrison for Reggie Workman allows Trane to refocus his ideas and refine and edit his solo, and brings Elvin down a notch or two from the flights of intensity of the live date. Garrison plays less aggressively than Workman (and is also less audible in the mix); his subtle touch on the bass strings has a moderating effect on the ensemble as a whole.

It is fortunate that Coltrane managed to produce this album in the teeth of his detractors, because the sessions recorded later in 1962 and 1963, Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, Ballads, and John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman, were far less adventurous and represent a capitulation to the demands of the music business and the realities of supporting a working band and a family. The Impulse contract and live performance guarantees negotiated by his lawyer Harold Lovette had made John Coltrane the second highest-paid jazz musician in America, after his former boss Miles Davis. Memories of living in a cold-water flat in Philadelphia were not so distant. Abandoning the direction of Coltrane may have been a necessary compromise, but bowing to the attacks of his critics frustrated Trane's development for the better part of two years.

Track Listing: Out of this World; Soul Eyes; The Inch Worm; Tunji; Miles' Mode.

Personnel: John Coltrane, tenor sax; Elvin Jones, drums; McCoy Tyner, piano; Jimmy Garrison, bass.

Format: 192kHz/24-bit. Mastering details and tape provenance not provided by the label.


During the time that separated Coltrane and Crescent, John Coltrane fulfilled his responsibilities to his sidemen and to his producer Bob Thiele, building a catalog of saleable LPs and fulfilling a busy nightclub and concert performance schedule. But he grew tired of playing the same songs on the bandstand (and in Europe, the concert stage) night after night. Coltrane was composing new work that was not yet being recorded or performed, based on modal forms, blues, shifting tonality, African traditional and 20th-century classical music. Decades of harmonic study and practice were seeking expression.

In response to the killing of four little girls in a church bombing in Birmingham, John wrote and recorded the lament "Alabama" which Thiele added to live tracks on the 1963 release Live at Birdland. Crescent is likewise suffused with sadness and spiritual yearning.

The opening tune, "Crescent," reveals a unity of sound, where two years earlier there were four separate voices. The piece is a textbook example of small-group composition and arrangement. Elvin is playing with real dynamics, not just at the very top of his range. If the hidebound critics couldn't hear, much less appreciate, what Trane was doing in 1961-62, surely they could have followed the logical development of his solo choruses, the clearly delineated melodic lines. Trane's playing has all of the intensity of his work on A Love Supreme in a more compact form.

"Wise One" and "Lonnie's Lament," two eloquent, melancholy minor-key ballads, form a thematic suite with "Crescent." Listening to the two pieces, it is difficult not to get lost in the beauty of Trane's perfected technique and cantabile tone. His melodic balladry is unlike any of his contemporaries, neither sentimental nor cliché. There is a kind of asperity to it, like chasing a smooth scotch with bitters. McCoy Tyner's solo on "Wise One" exposes a side of his playing less often heard, the deft phrases and light touch a perfect accompaniment to the gentle tenor sound. Jimmy Garrison, who played a supporting role in much of the Quartet's work, takes a spotlighted solo in "Lonnie's Lament." The bassist did not enjoy long life; he died at age 42 but left a body of recordings, especially his work with Coltrane and Ornette Coleman, that points to his value as a member of the band. His playing is characterized by economy of line and a smooth attack on the strings. Garrison was the calm hand that firmly restrained Elvin Jones.

A feature for Elvin, "The Drum Thing" gives the nonpareil percussionist room to paint synesthetic sound-color pictures. Constrained by the mastering engineer's need for plenty of groove modulation space in order to fit the drummer's astonishing dynamic range on a single LP side, Elvin wasn't given much extended solo space on previous Impulse recordings of the Quartet—any more than John's legendary hour-long solos could be recorded and pressed to vinyl at that time. Coltrane's generosity—laying out on his horn so the skins could tell their story—seals the album with the blessings of light, kindness and forbearance.

Track Listing: Crescent; The Wise One; Bessie's Blues; Lonnie's Lament; The Drum Thing.

Personnel: John Coltrane, tenor sax; Elvin Jones, drums; McCoy Tyner, piano; Jimmy Garrison, bass.

Format: 192kHz/24-bit. Mastering details and tape provenance not provided by the label.


There's a further deep shadow over the entire history of American jazz music: the intentional destruction and accidental loss of archival material, including original master tapes. In 1998, Bill Holland, a writer for Billboard Magazine, wrote a groundbreaking exposé on the scandal, which had not been widely divulged outside the record industry. Music lovers can be grateful that some successor corporations (notably, Sony) took measures to preserve and protect the original masters of their acquired jazz holdings. But others did not. Owing to neglect of America's great art music, the catalogs of many jazz labels have large gaps in their archival holdings.

In May 2016, Universal Music Group announced a new entity called the Verve Label Group, which would manage Universal's classical label holdings and jazz label catalogs. From the press release:

"Verve also oversees the catalog of the legendary Impulse! Records with an artist roster that includes John Coltrane, Charles Mingus and many more."

Were the new transfers of Coltrane albums to 192/24 files commissioned after the launch of the Verve Label Group? Verve's website does not discuss the Impulse! reissues or provide any details on tape sources, the name of the reissue coordinator or remastering engineer. Listeners contemplating an investment in the new reissues are provided only the following caveat-laden technical note (from a vendor website):

"This album is a high-resolution digital transfer of material originating from an analogue recording. It may contain noise, distortion or other artifacts, and may also contain audio which is limited in bandwidth and dynamic range, due to the technology available at the time of its original creation. As such, it is offered as a high-resolution documentation of a historical release."

Certainly true, but not informative to experienced jazz collectors, and hardly encouraging to new prospective customers.

Useful information can be found in the liner notes to the 2002 double-CD set Coltrane (Deluxe Edition) which state that the source for the reissue was second-generation, compressed and equalized tapes of all tracks except "Miles' Mode," for which an original tape was extant, and that the bonus tracks were mastered from original tape sources.

It is possible, therefore, that the same second-generation tapes were used for the new 192/24 transfer of Coltrane. The sound quality of the download is good but unexceptional. The apparent, but unverifiable absence of the original master tape is a loss, because the underlying recording has artistic and historic merit. Lacking the bonus tracks, artwork and liner notes, it is not an especially good value, but has one advantage over the regular CD for computer audio enthusiasts: you can subtly alter the sound of 24-bit files with the filters provided on many DACs and music server programs.

There is good news: the sound quality on Crescent is outstanding, and comparable to other Rudy Van Gelder recordings of the same era mastered from verifiable original studio tapes. This will come as no surprise to analogue reissue fans. Bernie Grundman's remastering of Crescent for a 45 RPM vinyl set on Original Recordings Group a few years ago received high praise. Now digital listeners can enjoy hearing the vivid details of Coltrane's sound in this new transfer. Coltrane appears to stand directly in front of the microphone, so that Van Gelder doesn't have to 'chase the Trane' as the perfectionist engineer would do when recording Coltrane's nightclub performances. Elvin's subtle accompaniment allows Garrison's bass to register with weight and clarity, and the piano sound is also unusually clear and unveiled.

Turn up the volume, move back from the loudspeakers, close your eyes and focus on Elvin's mallet work at the beginning of "The Drum Thing" or his crystalline brushed cymbals on "The Wise One"; Jimmy Garrison's bass solo on "Lonnie's Lament" and McCoy's pearlescent runs; and especially Trane's plaintive tone, his voice coming through the horn ....and you'll be standing in the un-shadowed light of great musical art.

Special thanks to spoken-word jazz artist and photographer Brian Auerbach for suggesting the title and theme of this column.


DeMicheal, Don "John Coltrane and Eric Dolphy Answer the Jazz Critics" (Down Beat March 1962)

Holland, Bill "Labels Strive to Rectify Past Archival Problems" (Billboard, ca. 1998)

Post a comment



Shop Amazon



Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.