We think of the 1950's as a time of relative social conformity, but in fact, there were significant cultural shifts happening. For one, male stereotypes were being unpacked and to some degree, unfrozen. Where once films and music gave us male characters that were either hyper-macho or limp-wristedly homosexual, male characters and performers who showed emotional vulnerability began to emerge from the underground.
Two musicians who were exemplars of this change were Frank Sinatra
and Chet Baker. The music these two made shared an emotional vulnerability, but that can be overdrawn. A closer look shows that their relationship to the wider culture was very different.
Sinatra did stretch male stereotypes, but within the boundaries of older, explicitly macho imagery. Frank Sinatra and his arrangers Billy May and Nelson Riddle in In the Wee Small Hours
(1955) and Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
(1956) bridged a popular music gap and showed that songs could swing and still deliver an intimate romantic message.
Baker, however, pressed towards an androgyny that fit badly with that image and which gained an astonishing traction in American culture. In this essay, I'll take a closer look at Baker and...
Chet Baker's style of singing on Chet Baker Sings
(1954) finished off what Bing Crosby
started. Crosby had initiated the movement from "hot" to "cool," as he taught singers how to use the microphone. But, even though Bing's style was relatively laid back, he still used "hot" techniques like vibrato, slurs and small ornamentations to "sell" the tune. This continued to be the standard, but Baker took it a step further, either eliminating or dramatically taking down the heat of these techniques. Also, in the range and timbre of his voice, he did not sound as a man singing was supposed to. Given the negative response by fellow musicians, friends and critics, it took some guts for Baker to continue to sing.
Baker was one in a long line of trumpet players who sang. Louis Armstrong
, Jabbo Smith
, Roy Eldridge
, Bunny Berigan
, Louis Prima
, Hot Lips Page
and Dizzy Gillespie
all sang well. They thought of themselves as entertainers, liked to sing and were happy to give their chops a break. Berigan's style was lighter, but even after he had a hit with "I Can't Get Started," he almost always deferred to a band singer and just played. The rest of those guys sang with a ballsier approach, sometimes ironic or sly, often bluesy. Armstrong always sang romantic tunes, but I hear an artfulness that separates the singer from the object of his affection and the song itself becomes the object. He did sing with great tenderness in the last phase of his career. Baker's singing was the first in this lineage that said out loud: "This is what it means to be vulnerable."
Baker's trumpet playing was not unique. It was distinguishable from but similar to the playing of others active at that time, like Jack Sheldon
, Don Fagerquist
, Don Joseph
, Tony Fruscella
and John Eardley. Of these, only Jack Sheldon also sang. His voice was better than Baker's, but his singing style ranged from cooing drollness to belting. To Sheldon, romantic meant sexy, while Chet was never so indiscreet, or overt. His sexiness was hidden below layers of romanticism and self-protection.
Rhythmically and in note choice, Baker's singing paralleled his playing. But the fragility, tremulousness and high tenor range of his voice amplified the vulnerable quality of the music. The only voice like it belonged to (Little) Jimmy Scott, who had a hit in 1950 with Lionel Hampton
's "Everybody's Somebody's Fool" and who showed up in the same year with Charlie Parker
, singing "Embraceable You," but Scott sang with all of the heat that Baker eschewed.
Reading about Baker's foray into singing is like wading into a critical abattoir. Almost no one liked it-musicians, friends or critics.
There are conflicting stories about how Baker's vocals got recorded. Some say he demanded it and that owner of the Pacific jazz label Dick Bock balked. Others say that Bock wanted it and Baker resisted. Either way, it seems to be true that Baker's inexperience(or ineptitude) made for innumerable retakes, marathon sessions and a lot of audio cutting and pasting.
Two things were not subject to criticism. One was his phrasing, which rhythmically paralleled his playing. The second was his scatting note choice, which reflected the melodic gift he shows in his trumpet solos.
There was a lot of criticism about his singing out of tune. I'm pretty sensitive to people staying in tune and I don't hear the problem very much, except on some held notesthe hardest to sing in tune and beyond his vocal support system.