Dear All About Jazz Readers,

If you're familiar with All About Jazz, you know that we've dedicated over two decades to supporting jazz as an art form, and more importantly, the creative musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made All About Jazz one of the most culturally important websites of its kind in the world reaching hundreds of thousands of readers every month. However, to expand our offerings and develop new means to foster jazz discovery we need your help.

You can become a sustaining member for a modest $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky Google ads PLUS deliver exclusive content and provide access to future articles for a full year! This combination will not only improve your AAJ experience, it will allow us to continue to rigorously build on the great work we first started in 1995. Read on to view our project ideas...


Free Jazz / Black Power

Ian Patterson By

Sign in to view read count
Free Jazz / Black Power
Philippe Carles and Jean-Louis Comolli
256 Pages
ISBN: ISBN 978-1-62846-039-1
University Press of Mississippi

Forty four years after its publication in French, Philippe Carles and Jean-Louis Comolli's thought-provoking, fiercely intellectual book Free Jazz/Black Power finally finds its way into English, thanks to Grégory Pierrot's translation and the good folk at University Press of Mississippi. The four words of the title reference four histories that "in the 1930s or 1950s, did not seem like they could converge or interact." Essentially then, Free Jazz/Black Power is a treatise on the confluence of avant-garde jazz and radical African American politics, with a piercing eye cast on the ideological discourse of (white) jazz criticism, which in the main panned free-jazz as so much jarring noise.

The book's narrative—and the Algeria-born French authors' left-leaning approach—cannot be fully understood outside the context of its time, that's to say, a time of heightened socio-political tensions in the USA—not to mention France and Algeria—as radical black politics took wing and as anti-Vietnam war protests chimed with the pro-independence movements of the politically oppressed around the globe. Carles and Comolli wear their Marxist badges on their sleeves, viewing all jazz and jazz criticism as politically and economically determined, with jazz—from its African-American origins—essentially depicted as a cry for freedom, while capitalism/the white establishment is cast in the role of jazz's colonizer, usurper, oppressor and manipulator.

The author's exploration of the reasons behind the largely negative reactions to free-jazz—on both sides of the Atlantic—through an analysis of the social, cultural and political origins of jazz from its earliest days was boldly innovative in 1971, predating the so-called New Jazz Criticism by two decades. To fully understand free-jazz and the violent reaction to the music it is necessary, the authors assert, to be aware not only of African American history but of African-American intellectual traditions as well. The authors may be Marxist in outlook but their stance reflects the influence of American thinkers such as E. F. Frazier, W.E. Du Bois, Sterling Brown, and above all, Leroi Jones (Amiri Baraka).

Why, the authors ask from the outset, if jazz's pioneers were black, were its critics---with a small number of notable exceptions—predominantly white? How did jazz become a sanitized popular music for consumption by white audiences, often far removed from its African-American roots? Why did the black middle classes largely reject jazz in its rawest form? Why was white America and the black bourgeoisie so keen to embrace jazz as art? These are simple enough questions but the author's explanations reveal complexities that get to the heart of the race/class issue in America—with echoes that resonate down through the decades to today.

That free-jazz—dating here from approximately 1960 to 1971—was an inevitable consequence of African-American's intolerable conditions is a central tenet of the book. The discriminations and exploitations that blacks faced—not only socio-politically or economically but psychologically—in the grip of white cultural domination created, the authors posit, "a point of no return that makes the leap of free jazz absolutely necessary."

If free-jazz appeared initially to be a purely musical phenomenon as the authors state, then it was the pressure of the greater political forces at large that signalled the music's actual political status and function. Jazz and politics have, say Carles and Comolli, always been closely interwoven and this theory makes for a refreshing and challenging alternative to the usual, linear and non-conflictive jazz histories that abound: "When white determinations reign for too long, antagonistic determinations, resistance, and contradictions are reactivated. This movement back and forth makes up the history of jazz, just as it makes up the ideological struggle of Negroes."

One of the authors' most interesting assertions is that free-jazz and not bebop represented the first true revolution in the history/evolution of jazz; for Carles and Comolli bebop exercised "a kind of aesthetic activism" and although it had represented a radical shift from swing, bebop soon found itself culturally and economically exploited. Unlike bebop, free-jazz, state the authors, was characterized by an emphasis on political signalization via the musician's heart-on-sleeves statements and in the song titles that referenced African heritage and demanded freedom.




comments powered by Disqus


Start your shopping here and you'll support All About Jazz in the process. Learn how.

Related Articles

Book Reviews
Ziga Koritnik: Cloud Arrangers
By Nenad Georgievski
February 3, 2019
Book Reviews
Ricochet: David Bowie 1983
By Nenad Georgievski
February 2, 2019
Book Reviews
Shake Your Hips: The Excello Records Story by Randy Fox
By C. Michael Bailey
February 2, 2019
Book Reviews
Billie Holiday: Lady Sings The Blues
By Ian Patterson
January 16, 2019
Book Reviews
Tracy Fessenden: Religion Around Billie Holiday
By Steve Provizer
January 8, 2019
Book Reviews
Sonny Rollins: Meditating on a Riff
By Steve Provizer
December 31, 2018
Book Reviews
Dexter Gordon: Portrait of a Sophisticated Giant
By Steve Provizer
December 30, 2018