Home » Jazz Articles » Album Review » Woody Shaw: At Onkel Po's Carnegie Hall: Vol. 1: Hamburg 1979
Woody Shaw: At Onkel Po's Carnegie Hall: Vol. 1: Hamburg 1979
ByBetween 1965 and 1972, Shaw went on to high-profile spells with Horace Silver, Chick Corea, McCoy Tyner, Max Roach, Joe Henderson and Art Blakey. He achieved a kind of stardom, but it was that of a musician's musician not a headliner. He was dogged by ill-health, which held him back in career terms, and he compounded this by spending extended periods away from New York performing in Europe, which he found more congenial. He was already a marginalised figure when he recorded his masterpiece, Rosewood (Columbia). Made with a twelve-piece band, the album was voted Best Jazz Album of 1978 in Down Beat. Shaw passed in distressing circumstances in 1989, aged 44.
In career terms, Shaw was an under-achiever. But he left behind a large body of superb jazz, most of it on other musicians' albums, which show how different things might have been. He shone most brightly as a soloist and he never showed tremendous inclination to compose (only one track on Rosewood is a Shaw original), which is not necessarily a prerequisite of own-name stardom though it helps.
High-calibre live recordings of Shaw continue to be unearthed and released. The 2CD set At Onkel Po's Carnegie Hall: Vol.1: Hamburg 1979 is one such. Shaw leads a quintet featuring three holdovers from the Rosewood sessionsCarter Jefferson, Onaje Allan Gumbs, Victor Lewisand newbie Stafford James, who replaced Rosewood's Clint Houston.
It is a straight-ahead blowing session but a good one. Disc One comprises two tracks each a minute or two shy of twenty-five minutes: John Coltrane's "Some Other Blues" and Jerome Kern's "All The Things You Are." Disc Two has three somewhat shorter ones: two Shaw originals, "Stepping Stone" and "In A Capricornian Way," and one by Gumbs. Audio quality is excellent.
Track Listing
CD1: Some Other Blues; All The Things You Are. CD2: Announcement; Stepping Stone; In A Capricornian Way; It All Comes Back To You.
Personnel
Woody Shaw
trumpetWoody Shaw: trumpet, flugelhorn; Carter Jefferson: soprano and tenor saxophone; Onaje Allan Gumbs: piano; Stafford James: bass; Victor Lewis: drums.
Album information
Title: At Onkel Po's Carnegie Hall: Vol. 1: Hamburg 1979 | Year Released: 2019 | Record Label: Jazzline Records