Home » Jazz Articles » Highly Opinionated » Bolden: A Movie Review And Beyond


Bolden: A Movie Review And Beyond


Sign in to view read count
Bolden’s environment was as rough as his music. In the film we get the environment, but the music isn’t as rough.
Directed by Daniel Pritzker
Abramorama; King Bolden LLC
Release Date: May 3, 2019

Bolden is a film about jazz legend and cornetist Buddy Bolden, released on May 3rd, 2019. There was only one theater playing it in Manhattan, all the way on 12th Avenue and 57th St. The author was the only person present there for an 11:50am Monday viewing on May 13th. The film only showed for one week in Brooklyn. Bolden was conceived by a white billionaire and jazz fan, Daniel Pritzker, who turned to Wynton Marsalis for the music and as an adviser, the latter a role he also undertook for Ken Burns' documentary JAZZ (PBS, 2001). Pritzker saw Bolden, in his words, as a way to create a film about the soul of America. Can a white billionaire teach the world about how jazz was created? My interest in the film was hoping to see on screen what I felt Bolden's music was all about. As a trumpet player myself, I wanted to witness the power of the blues on a horn. In the trailer, Bolden is seen playing music that sends a woman into spiritual catharsis. Pritzker pushes what he sees as the sexual aspects within the music, attempting to portray sexuality from another time. He heads directly into racism. In the film he also deals with mental illness in jazz, another subject that demands further research. All of this is delivered in a musical fantasy, somewhat removed from reality, that borders on science fiction through its abstraction.

Bolden largely takes place in the Louisiana State Insane Asylum where Bolden was committed in 1907, at 30 years old. He remained there for the rest of his life until he died in 1931, at 54 years old. Throughout the film he wanders the hospital while most of the inmates/patients are asleep. It seems to be dark and raining outside throughout the film. Bolden is in the last four months of his life and he hears a live radio broadcast of Louis Armstrong through a vent coming from the nurse's office. The music causes him to have flashbacks of his life before confinement. The entire film then follows a back and forth between Bolden in the hospital and extremely vivid flashbacks created with incredible cinematography. There is a loose forward motion narrative, but Pritzker is more interested in creating scenes from turn of the century New Orleans. These moments are when the film is mesmerizing. King Bolden holding court at Funky Butt Hall -just what could that have been like? Pritzker, Marsalis, and Gary Carr as Bolden take you there.

Bolden is also seen being forced to severely restrict his music playing at white society events, where entitled white people come across like secret alien lizard's incapable of emotional expression. The film has three white villains that want to destroy Bolden. A Judge Perry played by actor Ian McShane proclaims that the soul of black people must be destroyed. Further flashbacks bring Bolden deep into acts of sexual expression from his and his partner's perspectives. As the film progresses, all of these issues are exacerbated with Bolden losing a battle with schizophrenia. There is one particularly haunting scene where Bolden is challenged by possibly a young King Oliver or Freddie Keppard, and when he goes to play, his cornet has no valves, at least in his mind. No valves, no sound, no music. Bolden's mother Alice and wife Nora love him but are unable to help him during his decent. In one sequence of events, a creole clarinetist of color named George Baquet, a real-life musician that played with Bolden in 1905, tries to learn from Bolden and ends up integrating some of Bolden's concept into his straighter concept. This exchange speaks to the relationship between proper technical execution and pure emotional expression. It's important to witness the exchange, but surely not everything in life and music needs to be broken down into an intellectual concept. Through my own lens looking at Bolden, I'm haunted by Don Cherry speaking about how music shouldn't sound written down. Bolden may or may have not read music. Some people write out improvisation these days. Ornette Coleman said you can transcribe a solo, but you can't transcribe an environment. Bolden's environment was as rough as his music. In the film we get the environment, but the music isn't as rough, to me. Some people might prefer it that way. I think it's who Bolden was and what he played that drove the dance floor at Funky Butt hall, not how he did it. I think it was the sound and feeling from his soul played through that horn. Bolden, the very first jazz musician, and here in the film stated as the inventor of the music, spent the last 24 years of his life in an insane asylum. Charlie Parker spent time at Camarillo. Charles Mingus may have checked himself into Bellevue. Donald Ayler lived in a mental home for many years. My friend Giuseppi Logan has been living in a mental facility for several years now. The history and reality of mental illness in jazz is certainly worth a dissertation at least, maybe a book. Of course, the evils of alcohol, and the venom drank during Bolden's time is certainly a major factor in relation to this. In the film, I recall only one scene with Bolden drinking, but for some reason they do suggest he was involved with heroin in a full abstract scene, rescued by his manager, who stalks Bolden throughout the film.

Sex in the film is intense. There are at least two mostly nude sex scenes with Bolden. The front row at Funky Butt Hall is deep in the groove with Bolden, and Bolden with them, almost dancing as he plays. Bolden seems to love his wife Nora who becomes pregnant, but he cheats on her. In one flashback Bolden seems to possibly see all the women he has ever been with frolicking at some kind of fantasy picnic. The film is not appropriate for an audience hoping to see black women treated as equal human beings. There is one woman that plays a cello in visions that Bolden has that are confusing. Bolden's mother tries to help him as his illness worsens and he strikes her with a water pitcher, an event that is supposedly true.

Lost in all of this is real Buddy Bolden. Donald M. Marquis has written the definitive work on him, spending years doing exhaustive and extreme research. In his book In Search of Buddy Bolden First Man of Jazz (LSU, 1978), he uncovered a multitude of facts. Marquis has evidence of Bolden attending parades as a kid and participating in the Baptist Church. In his music, Bolden combined both. Marquis draws attention to Bolden using his name for his band, an important aspect of his musical personality, that he was a leader for virtually his entire musical career. He was unable to find evidence that Bolden could or couldn't read and write music. Some musicians claim he could read, some say he didn't. Bolden did have haters in his day, ready to draw attention to possible shortcomings, even many years after he was done blowing. Marquis draws attention to how Bolden's substantial popularity was based almost entirely by word of mouth, and based on his powerful personality, not his technical skill and execution. There was no social media back then of course. Bolden's relationship with his audience was real, personal and authentic. He could reportedly hear another band and memorize an entire arrangement, and then teach each part to his band. He had a teacher named Manuel Hall, through he may not have been a mentor. Bolden was late coming to the horn, at 17 years old. He was adept at playing his version of spirituals and played them quite often. It would have been nice to hear Marsalis as Bolden play a spiritual.

Marquis confirmed the legend that women fought over holding Bolden's hat, coat, and handkerchief. Why wasn't that a scene in the film? I'm always baffled when real life stories that are beyond Hollywood are denied in films about jazz musicians, yet things that never happened are included. Miles Davis' autobiography is loaded with real life Hollywood scenes that have yet to make it into a film. In real life, Funky Butt Hall became a church, why not draw attention to that? The balloon scene in the movie is disproven by Marquis, yet Pritzker chooses to use that, enhancing the nature of the film as a fantasy.

Marquis found evidence that Bolden had a lick, or a theme, in everything that he played. I translate that to mean Bolden was the first jazz musician with his own everything. Tone, melody, sound, swing, and rhythm. I do not believe it is spiritually possible to recreate this. To get to Bolden, interviews with his mother are more revealing, where she said that he broke his heart when he played, and that he would rather play than eat. Personal recollections say he had a moan in his playing but that he could also play sweet as hell when needed. Bolden could switch feelings on a dime, which would confuse dancers. He didn't play high, but he did play loud. If you play outdoors you have to play loud, and Bolden was outside all the time. For me, these descriptions of Bolden's music remind me of myself on trumpet, another reason I was drawn to the film. I don't play high, but I do play loud. I switch up feelings. I'm invested in the sexual energy of the music, and how that energy exists in the sound coming from a horn. Charles Gayle himself told me that when I play, he can hear the strut.

Back to Bolden, Marquis also researched his life after he was committed to the insane asylum, discovering that he occasionally played his horn with musicians there, playing louder and better than them. Tragically, after 1920 he no longer recognized his mother and sister. Bolden's funeral included no New Orleans send-off and was mostly unattended. Only the general location of his body in a graveyard is known. At one point his coffin was dug up and then buried beneath another coffin to make room. Things like this make me feel that sometimes jazz may be the cruelest musical path of all time, despite being filled with so much joy. Bolden is a legend but was never treated as one while he was alive. One of the reasons I check in with Giuseppi Logan is that he's not a photo in a book or a footnote. He's a human being on a very personal path that only he could walk, just like Bolden.

In the one surviving photo of Buddy, though pulling out deeper meaning from pictures is not advised, I see a man who may have been struggling with mental health issues at the time. What we do know about the real Buddy Bolden is that during his reign as king, he had tremendous power on his silver cornet. We know that for a period he was working all over New Orleans, and people loved his music. Weather it was his big 4, his big blues, or both, he made power moves that launched a music that has been changing lives ever since. Buddy was the right person at the right time, and made the right moves, setting all of us up. No Buddy, no Freddie Keppard, no King Oliver, no Louis Armstrong, no Lee Morgan, no Wynton Marsalis, no Matt Lavelle and countless others.

Hey, Buddy Bolden!
Thank you.
For Buddy and Giuseppi.


For the Love of Jazz
Get the Jazz Near You newsletter All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who create it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

You Can Help
To expand our coverage even further and develop new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for a modest $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination will vastly improve your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.



Jazz article: Give Your Regards to Broadway—and Hollywood
Jazz article: A Tale of Two Jazz Humbugs
Highly Opinionated
A Tale of Two Jazz Humbugs
Jazz article: Jazz Inside And Out: Select Posts from 2013-2015


Get more of a good thing!

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories, our special offers, and upcoming jazz events near you.