Audience Requests, Invisible Soloists and Rhythm Changes

Dear Mr. P.C.:

I'm just an audience member, but I have a question on behalf of a lot of us listeners:

If I make a request and the band plays it, do I have to listen to the whole thing? After they play the melody and then go into all the other stuff, sometimes I'd rather talk to my friends or just leave.

—Short Attention Span Suzie      

Dear SASS:

Don't you think the guys in the band would rather talk to their friends or just leave too? Your request—which you never should have made—is a compact; it binds you and the band together in what becomes a set period of shared suffering.

Only the silence at the end can set you and the band free; that's why the last note of "Moondance" is always the sweetest.

Dear Mr. P.C.:

A vocalist counted off a blues, and we (the trio) played a chorus up front, since that's the easiest way to set it up. So I'm soloing through the intro chorus, and the singer comes up and says to me "I want you to solo on this."

I can't talk while I play, but also my brain was exploding. Couldn't she tell I was soloing? Did she want me to stretch out longer even though it was an intro? Did she want to make sure I took a solo during the song as well?

So I couldn't talk and didn't know what to say anyway. Thinking I'm ignoring her she says more insistently "I mean it, I want you to solo on this!" She was getting kind of mad. I was still soloing, still utterly baffled, and I've stayed that way to this day.

—Confused in Carolina

Dear Confused:

Were you making it clear that you were soloing, or were you so caught up in making music that you completely neglected to show it? Just how did you expect this singer—or the audience—to know you were soloing if all you did was play a bunch of notes? That's exactly why people don't like jazz, you know—too many notes, too little action.

Maybe someday you'll share your singer's concern for the music, its audience, and its future; until then, would it kill you to look like you care?

Dear Mr. P.C.:

Why does "I Got Rhythm" begin on beat two?  If they have rhythm shouldn't it begin on beat one?

And why do chords to "rhythm changes" change?  Shouldn't the rhythm change?

—Jazzprof

Dear Jazzprof:

Most jazz players—like their symphony counterparts—are afraid of an exposed mistake, so they're not ready to commit until they've already heard beat one. "I Got Rhythm" is actually supposed to start on beat one, but performer latency displaces it to beat two. That's why it's a "rhythm changes" song—because the rhythmic execution doesn't match the composer's intent. 

As for your second question: The term "rhythm changes" has nothing to do with the chords. "Chord changes" are changes to chords, and like rhythm changes, they're just something we all have to endure.

Have a question for Mr. P.C.? Ask him.