Home » Jazz Articles » New Jazz Orchestra: Le Déjeuner Sur L’herbe


Album Review

New Jazz Orchestra: Le Déjeuner Sur L’herbe


Sign in to view read count
New Jazz Orchestra: Le Déjeuner Sur L’herbe
I remember reading about this record in Melody Maker when it came out. These were all the people I admired in one band! Yet I never ever saw a copy until one day twenty years later in a record shop in Ipswich, I pulled this gem from the racks. £2.50! I couldn't believe the price or the condition. Twenty years of searching and the music didn't disappoint.

In fact, New Jazz Orchestra director, Neil Ardley, did issue the album privately and illegally on CD at one point but this is its first legit and beautifully presented release. Dusk Fire have done the music proud. Le Déjeuner Sur L'herbe was the follow-up to the first NJO record Western Union (1965) and it was a major advance. The orchestra had built an identity through a long-standing residency at University College of London courtesy of one of the students, George Foster, who ran the Jazz Society there. In fact, the orchestra averaged a gig a week for two years from 1965—7, quite an achievement in the economic climate of the time.

Déjeuner is one of the finest British jazz records of any period. The obvious comparison in terms of its overall sonic impression has to be Gil Evans. For one thing, the absence of piano or guitar—Frank Ricotti plays vibes -lends itself to a sound that is inevitably brass-led, though, here, one that eschews the brighter colours that might be associated with a Basie or Thad Jones. Yet, the orchestra could also play free and could match any other for fire power. Take, for example, Michael Garrick's "Dusk Fire." I love the original Rendell-Carr Quintet take but this version might just top it. The undersung {Jim Philip}} on tenor perhaps lacks {Don Rendell}}'s more subtle grasp of the tune's eastern-derived modes but makes up for this in the sheer ferocity of his playing. This is, if anything, a wilder, freer take on a hardy perennial. The two nods in the direction of the masters—{Miles Davis}}' "Nardis,"" arranged by Ardley, and John Coltrane's "Naïma," arranged by Alan Cohen—are recast quite beautifully. "Naïma" features with some fine, breathy tenor packed with sixteenth notes from Jim Philip over sotto voce brass, whilst "Nardis" unfolds majestically and lovingly. Jack Bruce's bass solo is set against gently supporting vibes and drums before {Ian Carr}}'s fluegelhorn opens the tune out. The piece closes around a brief interlude from tuba player George Smith.

Elsewhere, Howard Riley's "Angle" is given an excellent reading, which allows the band to move into freer territory, whilst Mike Taylor's "Ballad" glows in the hands of saxophonist Dave Gelly (Gelly also contributes to the accompanying booklet). Mike Gibbs' theme-led "Rebirth" closes the album with the New Jazz Orchestra's only entry into Latin-tinged territory. But it is really the two remaining tracks—the opening title track by Neil Ardley and "Study," which truly lift this album into a whole other category of "greatness."

"Study" was incorrectly attributed to Andrés Segovia on the original LP. Here, the composer is rightly credited as Alexandre Tansman, born in Poland but resident for much of his career in France. However, the correct title is in fact "Kolysanka No. 1—(Berceuse d'Orient)" and it is taken from Suite in Modo Polinico. It is well worth tracking down the 1958 recording by Segovia and hearing against Mike Taylor's setting here, which one suspects involved the hand of Ardley himself in its orchestration for the NJO. Taylor, and Ardley, move the piece from its original lullaby, andante cantabile setting to something much more grand and stately, more an adagio perhaps. It's impossible not to think of Sketches of Spain listening to this piece with its solos and closing duet from Henry Lowther and Barbara Thompson, here on soprano, that was often the high spot of an NJO performance. The sheer grace and elegance of "Study" is simply evocative of the open plains of Spain, its big skies and wonderful sunsets, as the piece builds from the opening statement of the scale and the simple melody derived from it, including a brief modulation up a semi-tone (I think). It's one of those performances you can bask in.

It's also worth noting here that the New Jazz Orchestra recorded a whole album of pieces by Mike Taylor in 1973, Mike Taylor Remembered, which finally achieved an official release on Dusk Fire in 2007. As for the title track, it is a minor masterpiece of form, deceptively easy on the ear but utilizing a number of different scales. Ardley's harmonic sense allows this exercise in polytonality to unfold in its own time and, while it sounds exotic in its use of modes, it never seems odd or discordant. Throughout, the playing is magnificent and it is great to hear musicians like Ian Carr, Barbara Thompson and Dick Heckstall-Smith in a big band setting. Ardley told author-pianist Brian Priestley in August 1971 that "Le Déjeuner Sur L'herbe" was for him a breakthrough composition:

""Le Déjeuner Sur L'herbe" was the first time I tried to compose a piece from beginning to end, with no repeating chord sequence. The tune actually comes from a secondary part in a Debussy prelude, and I used the notes in it as motifs from which the rest of the piece came. (Priestley 1971, 12)

It is very apparent from the interview that Ardley is looking outside African-American inspirations—the title of course comes from Manet's impressionist painting. Over the course of his career, Ardley would continue to expand the jazz composer's palette, as well as the instrumentation available to the composer. If Le Déjeuner Sur L'herbe represents a crystallizing moment in his career, it also defines a unique period in British jazz. The lion was no longer en passant. It was rampant and it could roar.

Track Listing

Tracks: Le Déjeuner Sur L’herbe; Naïma; Angle; Ballad; Dusk Fire; Nardis; Study; Rebirth. Rec. 1969.


Personnel: Neil Ardley conductor, director; Derek Watkins, Henry Lowther, Harry Beckett, Ian Carr trumpets; John Mumford, Derek Wadsworth, Mike Gibbs, Tony Russell trombones; George Smith tuba; Dick Heckstall-Smith, Dave Gelly, Jim Philip, Barbara Thompson woodwinds, saxophones; Frank Ricotti vibes, percussion; Jack Bruce double bass, Jon Hiseman drums.

Album information

Title: Le Déjeuner Sur L’herbe | Year Released: 2015 | Record Label: Dusk Fire

Post a comment about this album

Get the Jazz Near You newsletter All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who create it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

To expand our coverage even further and develop new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for a modest $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination will vastly improve your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.



Noah Haidu
A Little Optimism
Brendan Lanighan Octet
Five English Folk Songs
Neil Luck & Mimi Doulton
The Flowering Am
(Blade of) Carlstedt Motzer Torn


Get more of a good thing!

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories, our special offers, and upcoming jazz events near you.