All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review

387

Tony Banks: A Curious Feeling

John Kelman By

Sign in to view read count
It's curious, indeed, that Genesis keyboardist/co-founder Tony Banks never achieved the fame that Phil Collins, Steve Hackett, Peter Gabriel and Mike Rutherford did as solo artists. As one of the group's primary writers, his distinctive melodies and voicings have defined the Genesis sound since its inception. Still, based on the majority of Banks' extracurricular solo activities, it's easy to conclude that he needed Genesis to fully realize his own ideas.

Were it not for his 1979 debut as a leader, A Curious Feeling, that is. Firmly planted in the progressive rock camp at a time when Genesis was in transition, morphing from its progressive rock roots into a stadium megastar, it's an overlooked gem that deserved far more than it received when first released. Having completed remixing and remastering the Genesis catalogue into box sets including 1970- 1975 (Rhino, 2008) and Live 1973-2007 (Rhino, 2008), Nick Davis has sonically revitalized Banks' album— a solo project, perhaps, but one that retains the key characteristic distancing Genesis from its progressive rock cousins: the song comes first, instrumental virtuosity second.

Recorded while Genesis was taking a break to let Collins work out some personal problems, it reflects the group's transitioning, but is closer to the compositional expansiveness of Wind & Wuthering (Rhino, 1977) than the concise songs of ...And Then There Were Three... (Rhino, 1978). Banks plays all the instruments with the exception of drums, handled by Genesis touring mate Chester Thompson, and singer Kim Beacon.

Starting life as an adaptation of Daniel Keyes' 1959 novella Flowers for Algernon, but ultimately altered into the story of an everyman who is losing his mind while completely aware of it, A Curious Feeling's greatest strength is its avoidance of progressive rock's tendency to excess and pomposity. A concept album at a time when that, in itself, was reason enough for a good lambasting, it's a 55-minute suite that feels continuous, even though it isn't. Banks' neoclassical leanings are most dominant on "From the Undertow," "Forever Morning" and "The Waters of Lethe"—three instrumentals performed by the keyboardist alone, built from the ground up with layers of piano and synths—but with his inherent melodicism definitive throughout.

Beacon—who sadly passed away a couple years ago and was, other than his work here and with String Driven Thing, largely relegated to anonymity—has an attractive voice, but lacks the personality of either Gabriel or Collins. Banks' songs (no surprise) could easily fit into the Genesis repertoire, with enough synth-laden instrumental passages to be considered progressive, while leaning away from irregular meters towards a more accessible sound.

And yet, there's a difference. Comparing A Curious Feeling to Genesis songs like "Mad Man Moon," from Trick of the Tail (Rhino, 1976), and much of Wind & Wuthering, what becomes clear is what made Genesis Genesis. Completely liberated to go where his muse will, Banks' pastoral romanticism and lyrical bent come completely to the fore on A Curious Feeling, an album that, 30 years later, sounds the way it always should have, and finally has the chance to reach the audience it deserves.

Track Listing: From the Undertow; Lucky Me; The Lie; After the Lie; A Curious Feeling; Forever Morning; You; Somebody Else's Dream; The Waters of Lethe; For a While; In the Dark.

Personnel: Kim Beacon: vocals; Tony Banks: keyboards, guitars, basses, percussion; Chester Thompson: drums, percussion.

Title: A Curious Feeling | Year Released: 2009 | Record Label: Esoteric Recordings

Tags

comments powered by Disqus

Shop Music & Tickets

Click any of the store links below and you'll support All About Jazz in the process. Learn how.

CD/LP/Track Review
Extended Analysis
Multiple Reviews
Read more articles
The Movie Box 1981-2007

The Movie Box...

Rhino/Warner Strategic Marketing
2009

buy
Live 1973-2007

Live 1973-2007

Rhino/Warner Strategic Marketing
2009

buy
A Curious Feeling

A Curious Feeling

Esoteric Recordings
2009

buy
1970-1975

1970-1975

Rhino Records
2008

buy

Related Articles

Read Ancestros CD/LP/Track Review
Ancestros
by Karl Ackermann
Published: November 18, 2018
Read The Bitter Suite CD/LP/Track Review
The Bitter Suite
by Jack Bowers
Published: November 18, 2018
Read Ornettiquette CD/LP/Track Review
Ornettiquette
by Chris Mosey
Published: November 18, 2018
Read The Astral Revelations CD/LP/Track Review
The Astral Revelations
by John Sharpe
Published: November 18, 2018
Read The Sound Of The Earth CD/LP/Track Review
The Sound Of The Earth
by Glenn Astarita
Published: November 18, 2018
Read Return to the Future CD/LP/Track Review
Return to the Future
by Mark Sullivan
Published: November 17, 2018
Read "The Diary Of Robert Reverie" CD/LP/Track Review The Diary Of Robert Reverie
by Roger Farbey
Published: June 1, 2018
Read "Rain or Shine" CD/LP/Track Review Rain or Shine
by Jack Bowers
Published: December 15, 2017
Read "Mønk" CD/LP/Track Review Mønk
by Chris May
Published: September 20, 2018
Read "From Silence to Somewhere" CD/LP/Track Review From Silence to Somewhere
by Glenn Astarita
Published: March 21, 2018
Read "The Angel and the Brute Sing Songs of Wrath" CD/LP/Track Review The Angel and the Brute Sing Songs of Wrath
by Karl Ackermann
Published: January 6, 2018
Read "Bright Yellow with Bass" CD/LP/Track Review Bright Yellow with Bass
by John Sharpe
Published: December 2, 2017