All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review


simakDialog: The 6th Story

Ian Patterson By

Sign in to view read count
The title, simple yet enigmatic, hints at the epic tale that is SimakDialog—the Indonesian prog-jazz band formed by keyboard player Riza Arshad in 1993. The band's international debut Patahan (MoonJune Records, 2007) served as a global calling card, with critics referencing jazz-fusion influences such as trumpeter Miles Davis, keyboardists Chick Corea and Joe Zawinul, The Pat Metheny Group et al. The foundation of the music, however, has always been the hypnotic Sundanese gamelan rhythms and this meeting between ritual/folkloric grooves and more jazz-centric lines from Arshad and electric guitarist Tohpati also largely defines The 6th Story.

Four years on from Demi Masa (MoonJune Records, 2009), the twin percussion unit of kendang drummers Endang Ramdan and Erlan Suwardana is joined by Cucu Kurnia, whose assorted metal percussion ever so subtly spices the constant rhythmic flow. Bassist Adhitya Pratama anchors the sextet with slow-funk pulses that rarely quicken—an understated yet essential element of SimakDialog's collective sound. Most of the tunes boast fine melodies, introduced by Arshad and Tohpati in tight unison lines that navigate quirky meters before one then the other solos. The main exception is the altogether looser "Harmologic," where Arshad and Tohpati improvise simultaneously, seeming to push and pull each other in separate yet overlapping fields of gravity.

The episodic "Stepping In" moves swiftly from the head to a chain of keyboard/guitar-led melodic developments. When Tohpati drops out the intensity wanes, freeing Arshad, who inhabits the new-found space with a delightful sinewy run. The guitarist's queue to rejoin signals a psychedelic passage that soon gives way to clearer, more cutting guitar lines. All the while the percussion cooks, never wavering. The head reappears and a final flash of unified melody ends this visceral and cerebral feast with a pronounced sense of drama.

The melodic and improvisational aesthetic is not a million miles from bebop. Certainly, the knotty melodic contours and freewheeling solos of "Lain Parantina" and "Common League" will resonate with jazz fans and those more inclined towards contemporary progressive rock/fusion. On the former, Arshad and Tohpati are fired-up, spurred on by the percussion. The collective sound rises and swells but just when it seems set to peak in dramatic fashion the music recedes to gentler pastures, though not without a final exclamative flourish. The latter tune—at just under four minutes—ends as the coals are beginning to glow.

There's a more meditative and overtly lyrical side to simakDialog, evidenced in the seductive melody of "What Would I Say"; Arshad and Tohpati's measured solos are emotionally charged. It's a winning tune evocative of the best moments of guitarist Al Di Meola's early solo recordings. "As Far as it Can Be (Jaco)" is a nuanced slower number, blue-toned and lyrical. Greater rhythmic impetus colors "For Once and Never"—whose heroic motif is unforgettable—and "5,6," where bass/keyboard vamps and spacey soundscapes underpin Tohpati's rockier solo. Arshad combines elegant, flowing acoustic piano with Zawinul-esque synthesizer minimalism on the compelling hybrid "Ari."

Arshad and Tohpati have spent two decades refining SimakDialog's sound and changes in personnel and stylistic variations have been part of that process. The band though has never sounded more organic and The 6th Story's beguiling narratives and striking dynamics represent a highpoint in its discography. Whatever label you might hang on it, Indonesian jazz-fusion, prog-jazz or world/jazz—they all work—this is another unique, intoxicating chapter from master storytellers.

Track Listing: Stepping In; Lain Parantina; Harmologic; What Would I say; For Once And Never; Common League; As Far as it Can Be (Jaco); 5,6; Ari.

Personnel: Riza Arshad: Fender Rhodes electric piano, acoustic piano, synth, soundscapes; Tohpati: electric guitar; Adhitya Pratama: bass guitar; Endang Ramdan: Sundanese kendang percussion (left); Erlan Suwardana: Sundanese kendang percussion (right); Cucu Kurnia: assorted metal percussion.

Title: The 6th Story | Year Released: 2014 | Record Label: Moonjune Records


Related Video

comments powered by Disqus

CD/LP/Track Review
Live Reviews
CD/LP/Track Review
Read more articles
Live at Orion

Live at Orion

Moonjune Records

The 6th Story

The 6th Story

Moonjune Records

Demi Masa

Demi Masa

Moonjune Records



Moonjune Records


Related Articles

Read Peaks of Light CD/LP/Track Review
Peaks of Light
by Mark Sullivan
Published: March 18, 2018
Read In Denmark I Was Born CD/LP/Track Review
In Denmark I Was Born
by Gareth Thompson
Published: March 18, 2018
Read In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983 CD/LP/Track Review
In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983
by Chris Mosey
Published: March 18, 2018
Read A Year Ago Today CD/LP/Track Review
A Year Ago Today
by Doug Collette
Published: March 18, 2018
Read Dreams of Belonging CD/LP/Track Review
Dreams of Belonging
by C. Michael Bailey
Published: March 18, 2018
Read Ravensburg CD/LP/Track Review
by Mike Jurkovic
Published: March 17, 2018
Read "Déjà Vu" CD/LP/Track Review Déjà Vu
by Troy Dostert
Published: September 20, 2017
Read "Accelerated Projection" CD/LP/Track Review Accelerated Projection
by Don Phipps
Published: February 14, 2018
Read "Double Strike" CD/LP/Track Review Double Strike
by James Nadal
Published: May 31, 2017
Read "Can't Get Started" CD/LP/Track Review Can't Get Started
by Bruce Lindsay
Published: August 24, 2017
Read "when the shade is stretched" CD/LP/Track Review when the shade is stretched
by Mark Sullivan
Published: January 17, 2018
Read "A Sequence of Waves (Twelve Stories and a Dream)" CD/LP/Track Review A Sequence of Waves (Twelve Stories and a Dream)
by Paul Naser
Published: December 8, 2017