It's usually best to assess a project on its own merits, rather than getting caught up in expectation or preconception. Fans of guitarist John Scofield's more jazz-centric work, including his early-'90s Blue Note work and his recent recording EnRoute, will undoubtedly find the glossy production of That's What I Say disappointing and, well, a little safe. But of all the high-visibility jazz guitarists on today's scene, Scofield is unquestionably best-suited to a project of this nature. While he has the kind of chops and harmonically adventuresome spirit to tackle the most challenging contexts, he's also a deeply soulful guitarist, as much a descendent of B.B. King as Wes Montgomery.
And this is a production. Drummer Steve Jordanwho, along with organist/pianist Larry Goldings and bassist Willie Weeks, makes up the core quartet with Scofieldis also the record's producer. He has pulled out all the stops with a host of guests including singers Mavis Staples, Doctor John, Aaron Neville, Warren Haynes, and, somewhat surprisingly, John Mayer. Also featured: percussionist Manolo Badrena; a four-piece horn section; and an almost kitchen sink approach to sonic ear candy. In fact, this is the closest Scofield has ever come to making an out-and-out pop record.
Still, even on this collection of well-known Charles covers, Scofield manages to inject a degree of unpredictability in his playing. While he stays almost entirely inside the lines, he still demonstrates his characteristically angular approach, and a more unconventional way of navigating the simplest of changes that is especially evident when playing against Warren Haynes' bottleneck guitar on "Night Time is the Right Time or John Mayer's more straightforward rock lines on "I Don't Need No Doctor.
While all the guests contribute to the homage, the least-embellished tunes are the ones that work the best. "Busted finds Scofield, Goldings, and Jordan in fine form updating the organ trio tradition, with a stronger backbeat than anything you'd likely have heard from Jimmy Smith or Jack McDuff. And while it may only last a scant minute and a half, Scofield's duet with Goldings on "Cryin' Time is the most poignant moment on the disc. The funky hidden track that follows the album's closera nylon-string guitar solo rendition of "Georgia on My Mind has the kind of deep and unforced groove that makes you wish Scofield would stick with musicians of this calibre, rather than the more on-top-of-the-beat jamband players in his Uberjam group.
In fact it's the very song-form nature of That's What I Say that, while certainly not for jazz purists, makes it a far more satisfying listen than the more extended jamband aesthetic of Uberjam or Up All Night. Heartfelt and always soulful, That's What I Say could have used a little less production and a little more gut instinct. But despite that, it manages to be both a fun listen and a personal tribute that isn't at all out of place in Scofield's overall body of work.
Busted; What'd I Say; Sticks and Stones; I Don't Need No Doctor; Cryin' Time; I Can't Stop Loving You; Hit the Road Jack; Talkin' Bout You/I Got a Woman; Unchain My Heart (Part 1); Let's Go Get Stoned; Night Time is the Right Time; You Don't Know Me; Georgia on My Mind
John Scofield (guitar, leslie guitar, talking choir); Larry Goldings (Hammond B3 Organ, Wurlitzer, vibes, talking choir); Willie Weeks (bass, Ampeg baby bass, talking choir); Steve Jordan (drums, cocktail drums, watercooler jug; background vocals, finger snaps, tambourine, handclaps, talking choir); Dr. John (vocals, piano); Warren Haynes (vocals, bottleneck guitar); John Mayer (vocals, guitar); Aaron Neville (vocals); Mavis Staples (vocals); Manolo Badrena (percussion, timbales, Spanish speaking, tambourine); Alex Foster (tenor saxophone, heys and has); Earl Gardner (trumpet, heys and has); Howard Johnson (baritone saxophone, heys and has); Keith O
All About Jazz & Jazz Near You were built to promote jazz music: both recorded albums and live events. We rely primarily on venues, festivals and musicians to promote their events through our platform. With club closures, limited reopenings and an uncertain future, we've pivoted our platform to collect, promote and broadcast livestream concerts to support our jazz musician friends. This is a significant but neccesary step that will help musicians and venues now, and in the future. You can help offset the cost of this essential undertaking by making a donation today. In return, we'll deliver an ad-free experience (which includes hiding the sticky footer ad). Thank you!
Get more of a good thing
Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.