Sunny Sumter: Sunny

Ms. Sumter is backed by a formidable quintet augmented on three tracks by a five-piece string section. On two songs she is accompanied only by Larry Willis on piano. Mr. Willis’ graceful, mellifluous playing is a welcome presence throughout the disc, but especially on a beautifully framed, shimmering “Overjoyed.”

The concept of the album is hardly unique to jazz: a nearly all ballad set with strings. Unfortunately, it is a project that has come along several years too soon for Ms. Sumter. She does not yet have the dramatic or improvisational ability to hold a listener's interest over a whole sequence of extended ballads. She sings in short, clipped phrases and often stretches a single syllable over several notes. Both are difficult techniques that she has not quite mastered. As a result, Ms. Sumter sometimes parses lyrics in a way that distorts rather than enhances their meaning. The song then becomes a disconnected series of words instead of the expression of a specific point of view. Ballad singing lives or dies on the expressiveness of the singer and her ability to link words to real-life emotional experiences. Ms. Sumter may very well have lived the kind of life that would entitle her to sing "Nobody Knows the Trouble I've Seen," but she certainly doesn't sound like she has.

Still, Ms. Sumter's singing is never less than lovely and there are some exceptional moments on this CD that hold the promise of great things to come.

Comments