SFJAZZ Collective: Ottawa, Canada March 1, 2009


Sign in to view read count
'Consensus' was a marvelous, horn-driven modal piece that, like the rest of the performance, avoided direct imitation and spoke directly to the spirit of Tyner
SFJAZZ Collective
Dominion-Chalmers United Church
Ottawa, Canada
March 1, 2009

It was a stellar weekend for jazz in Ottawa, Canada. First, on Saturday, February 26 fans were treated to an intimate but outstanding evening of music by local bassist John Geggie and his guests, guitarist Vic Juris and drummer John Fraboni. Then, the following evening, the SFJAZZ Collective made its first appearance in town (sponsored by the TD Canada Trust Ottawa International Jazz Festival), with one of its strongest line-ups ever—saxophonists Joe Lovano (tenor) and Miguel Zenón (alto); trumpeter Dave Douglas; trombonist Robin Eubanks; pianist Renee Rosnes, bassist Matt Penman and drummer Eric Harland.

SFJAZZ Collective Rosnes, Eubanks, Douglas, Penman, Lovano, Harland, Zenón

There's a running joke within the group, according to Penman, since none of the group's members are from San Francisco anymore. This revamped SFJAZZ Collective may maintain the core premises of the collective founded by saxophonist Joshua Redman and executive artist director Randall Kline at the turn of the decade, but by consisting entirely of died-in-the-wool New Yorkers now, the group has taken on a different complexion since its first tour in 2004—edgier and, alongside its thoughtful and challenging arrangements and compositions, more open-ended as well.

Each year, the collective convenes to pay tribute to the music of a different jazz legend. Past years have seen each member of the group, in addition to writing a piece of his/her own, contribute arrangements of music by Thelonious Monk, John Coltrane, Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock. The 2009 edition of the group honors seminal pianist McCoy Tyner, and this year's line-up couldn't be a better choice to pay tribute to an artist who helped define a specific harmonic language and bring a visceral energy to his own music and that of his employer, during his protracted, thoroughly documented role as the pianist in Coltrane's most admired quartet during the early-to-mid 1960s. Without a vibraphonist (first Bobby Hutcherson, then Stefon Harris) for the first time in its career, the collective capitalizes on the absence of the lighter, "cooler"-sounding instrument and has reinvented itself as a unit with a much more heated, meaty sound.

With seven Tyner arrangements and seven original compositions, the group has plenty to choose from in building a 90-minute program that varies from night to night. Opening with a suite that tied together Tyner's "Fly with the Wind" (arranged by Rosnes), "Indo-Serenade" and "Parody" (both arranged by Eubanks), this edition of the sextet immediately differentiated itself with a freer and more hard-hitting approach that was definitely New York in vibe. Far more than simple "heads" with plenty of solo space, these were often complex arrangements, with solos integrated in a mini-big band context but one in which there's freedom to move, but with almost invariably an underlying structure or, if not that, a premise from which to start. Lovano blew the first knock-down, drag-out solo of the evening, his deep tone and plaintive screams in vivid contrast to the more cerebral yet still evocative Zenón, whose own music often combines head and heart. Solos passed effortlessly from musician to musician, making each more a part of the overall arrangement than discrete entities, though with musicians of this caliber, there's no denying the individual virtuosity at play.

But it was (and is) a collective, and the elegant energy of the arrangements was so pervasive that there was barely time to catch breath before the next compelling moment arose. With each member of the collective a leader in his/her own right, working in a group such as this frees the principals from the normal responsibilities of running a band/project, allowing them to think less and play more. The result was an endless run of outstanding solos, but particularly potent turns by Douglas, Eubanks and Zenón on the altoist's lyrical but energetic closer, "No Filter." Douglas' tender "Sycamore" provided a brief respite, especially after Lovano's aptly titled "Jazz Free," which combined completely open-ended group improvisation with a challenging arrangement, even as solos were passed around liberally. Matt Penman's solo, a combination of Charles Mingus-like aggression and more delicate melodicism, was especially notable, providing clear evidence why, in such a a brief period of time, he's made it to the "A" list of younger New York bassists, alongside Drew Gress, Scott Colley, FLY and Christian McBride.

Each piece was introduced by a different member of the group, with Douglas ("It's so great to be back here, I love Iowa") and Harland memorable for their sense of humor. Harland spoke about his arrangement of the encore, Tyner's "Consensus"—from Super Trios (Milestone, 1977)—which may not have been an actual tune at all but was nevertheless turned into a marvelous, horn-driven modal piece that, like the rest of the performance, avoided direct imitation and spoke, instead, directly to the spirit of Tyner.

SFJAZZ Collective Robin Eubanks, Dave Douglas, Joe Lovano, Miguel Zenón

The collective's ability, in fact, to get to the heart of what the honored artist is about is what has made the SFJAZZ Collective such a vibrant ongoing project, with plenty of space to evolve and no shortage of great jazz artists to choose from. With 600 in attendance, the venue was about 2/3 full, a fine showing for a brittle, cold Ottawa evening. For those in attendance at the SFJAZZ Collective's vital performance, there was more than enough heat generated to provide at least a brief break from the seemingly endless Ottawa winter.

Photo Credit

John R. Fowler

Visit Renee Rosnes, Robin Eubanks, Dave Douglas, Matt Penman, Joe Lovano, Miguel Zenón, Eric Harland and SFJAZZ Collective on the web.

Post a comment



Shop Amazon


Jazz article: Jazz Is Led at Neighborhood Theatre
Jazz article: Harumo Imai Band at Keystone Club
Jazz article: Mary Ellen Desmond: Comfort and Joy 2021
Jazz article: Jazzmeia Horn at Jazz Alley
Jazz article: Veronica Swift at the Newman Center


Read Saturdays With Mort (Fega)
First Time I Saw
Saturdays With Mort (Fega)
Read 2021: The Year in Jazz
Year in Review
2021: The Year in Jazz

Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.