Support All About Jazz

All About Jazz needs your help and we have a deal. Pay $20 and we'll hide those six pesky Google ads that appear on every page, plus this box and the slideout box on the right for a full year! You'll also fund website expansion.


I want to help
514

Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian: Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian

John Kelman By

Sign in to view read count Views
Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian: Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian Despite his deep harmonic language and highly evolved personal sound, enigmatic guitarist Bill Frisell has often been criticized for musical choices that appear to ignore his jazz roots. But he treats jazz simply as one part of a larger musical continuum where Thelonious Monk and Hank Williams can harmoniously coexist. Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian presents him at his jazziest, yet it's still unequivocally a Bill Frisell record, with the broad scope and quirky mannerisms that have defined his career from the very beginning.

Compare Ron Carter and Miles Davis' "Eighty-One from E.S.P. (Legacy Recordings, 1965) with the version that opens this record. With one guitar, Frisell distills the essential harmonies of a quintet and delivers them without the feeling that anything has been lost. His mastery of elongated notes and seemingly infinite decays creates a rich sound that's appealing, ethereal and often ambiguous.

Frisell has been playing with Motian in various contexts for a quarter of a century, and he worked with Carter on two fine albums by drummer Joey Baron, including Down Home (Intuition, 1997). So, while this is a first-time union, the shared history of the trio's members creates an inherent chemistry which was missing on on Frisell's 2001 Nonesuch collaboration with bassist Dave Holland and drummer Elvin Jones. Here Frisell is able to take a song like the traditional "Pretty Polly and let it shift between free time and the verge of swing, all the while blending a skewed folksiness with more delineated behind-the-beat blues phrasing.

It's a shame that Carter isn't the first-call bassist he used to be, because here he demonstrates an unassailable groove, muscular sound and big ears on Frisell's "Monroe, first heard on Good Dog, Happy Man (Nonesuch, 1999). But instead of Jim Keltner's firm backbeat, Motian and Carter give it a gently lilting swing.

Frisell's innate sense of humour has always made him an astute interpreter of Monk. Here two blues pieces—the lesser-known "Raise Four and classic "Misterioso —are given definitive contemporary treatments. In both cases swing is the thing, but Motian—as off-kilter a drummer as Frisell is a guitarist—creates the subtlest unsettled feeling, despite Carter's firm anchor.

This is also Frisell's most sonically unaffected disc. Motian's "Introduction, from It Should've Happened a Long Time Ago (ECM, 1985), is more direct, with just the subtlest hint of looping replacing the dense guitar synth of the original. Proof that sometimes all you need is the simplest instrumentation to create a wellspring of ideas on songs ranging from the country of "I'm So Lonesome, I Could Cry to the mainstream "On the Street Where You Live.

Regardless of where he finds his music, Frisell can always be counted on for an odd-angled approach that keeps his musical partners and listeners on their toes. Half the fun is not knowing what's coming next, and Bill Frisell, Ron Carter, Paul Motian may well be the most unpredictable mainstream record you'll ever hear.

Visit Bill Frisell and Ron Carter on the web.


Track Listing: Eighty-One; You Are My Sunshine; Worse and Worse; Raise Four; Pretty Polly; On the Street Where You Live; Monroe; Introduction; Misterioso; I'm So Lonesome, I Could Cry.

Personnel: Bill Frisell: guitar; Ron Carter: bass; Paul Motian: drums.

Year Released: 2006 | Record Label: Nonesuch Records | Style: Straight-ahead/Mainstream


  • 1968
    1968
    Bill Frisell
    Previously Unreleased AAJ...
  • Strange Meeting
    Strange Meeting
    Bill Frisell
    Previously Unreleased AAJ...
CD/LP/Track Review
Extended Analysis
Live Reviews
Rediscovery
Read more articles
When You Wish Upon a Star
When You Wish Upon a...
Okeh
2016
buy
Guitar in the Space Age!
Guitar in the Space...
Okeh
2014
buy
Silent Comedy
Silent Comedy
Tzadik
2013
buy
Big Sur
Big Sur
Okeh
2013
buy
The Kentucky Derby Is Decadent and Depraved
The Kentucky Derby Is...
Savoy Jazz
2012
buy
Floratone II
Floratone II
Savoy Jazz
2012
buy
Pat Metheny Pat Metheny
guitar
Ornette Coleman Ornette Coleman
sax, alto
John Scofield John Scofield
guitar
Jim Hall Jim Hall
guitar
Gary Burton Gary Burton
vibraphone
Nels Cline Nels Cline
guitar, electric
Marc Ribot Marc Ribot
guitar

Bill Frisell Events

Date Event Time Tickets
Sep17Sat Bill Frisell
Mountain Theater
Mill Valley, CA
11:00 am
Sep18Sun Bill Frisell
Monterey Jazz Festival
Monterey, CA
12:00 pm
Oct4Tue Bill Frisell
Blue Note Jazz Club
New York, NY
8:00 pm
Oct5Wed Bill Frisell
Blue Note Jazz Club
New York, NY
8:00 pm
Oct6Thu Bill Frisell
Blue Note Jazz Club
New York, NY
8:00 pm
Oct7Fri Bill Frisell
Blue Note Jazz Club
New York, NY
8:00 pm
Oct8Sat Bill Frisell
Blue Note Jazz Club
New York, NY
8:00 pm

More Articles

Post a comment

comments powered by Disqus

Join the staff. Writers Wanted!

Develop a column, write album reviews, cover live shows, or conduct interviews.