Home » Jazz Articles » Jazz Humor » Mr. P.C.'s Guide to Jazz Etiquette and Bandstand Decorum
Mr. P.C.'s Guide to Jazz Etiquette and Bandstand Decorum
Inspired by the cutting edge advice of Abigail Van Buren, the storied bass playing of Paul Chambers, and the need for a Politically Correct doctrine for navigating the minefields of jazz etiquette, I humbly offer my services.
Started: 2009
October 2009
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.:Here's the scene: A friend of mine has a trio gig at a local club. I drop by with my horn after my own gig, and he invites me to sit in. I finish my tune (which, I think, goes pretty well), and then I'm just standing there wondering: Is he going to ask me to play another one or not? I have no idea, and my question to you is how I'm supposed to handle ...
Continue Reading...December 2009
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.: I would appreciate your candid advice on a recurring issue I've been having. As a trombone player, my slide has occasionally speared someone at my gigs. Once I even managed to mangle the manager of the hotel! What do you recommend to avoid these awkward moments: Yellow traffic cones marking the danger zone"? Soft padding on the end of the slide? or Attaching a bayonet and ...
Continue Reading...January 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.; One night during my drum solo the guys in the band walked off and left me all alone. The next set, during the vocalist's song, I walked off and went to the bar for a couple of shots. This seemed to upset her a great deal. Should I have ordered water or pop instead? John
Dear John:I sincerely doubt it, since most club owners depend on the drinking musician ... Continue Reading...February 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.:So, like, sometimes I hang out with my friends and listen to jazz at this happy hour thing where the waiters are really cute, and my friends can, you know, come up with all these cool songs to call out when the band asks for requests.I feel so totally insecure and stuff 'cause I can never request anything that will impress the band AND the cute waiters. I mean, come on, when you listen ...
Continue Reading...March 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.: I went to a jam session yesterday and am confused as to why I got evil stares from the band guys. I was very prepared. I brought five copies of my six-page arrangement to Lush Life" (in B). Granted, I forgot to tape them and a few pages flew off the bandstand, but otherwise I thought it went well. I did have to stop and start the band several times because they just didn't understand ...
Continue Reading...April 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.:What is the bassist trying to tell the rest of the band when he sits on the tonic for, like, three choruses in a row? Is it oh-so-clever I'm so on top of the harmony, nobody but me knows what's going on," or I'm bored, please stop taking those extra choruses"? (Or maybe I'm lost but can get away with it cuz I'm the bassist" or OK, time for a drum solo"?) - Steve, Middletown CT ...
Continue Reading...May 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C:I'm about to travel with my group (a pianist, bassist and drummer), to a gig in a really remote area. I'm wondering: If we somehow get stranded and eventually run out of food--a la the Donner Party--which guy should I eat first? Chuck D., Seattle
Dear Chuck:You're kidding, right? Because, thankfully, most jazz musicians nowadays are vegetarians. But, okay, let's assume you're one of the carnivore holdouts. Imagine you're ... Continue Reading...June 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.: When I finish a gig with a bunch of other white musicians, we all shake hands like we're just held some freaking corporate board meeting. That's bad enough. But when I play with a group of black guys, I totally dread the end of the gig.I mean, what are my choices? I can extend my hand in the generic white guy way, but then I feel like The Man," like I'm making ...
Continue Reading...July 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.:Why do drummers play so loud? Can't we have them tested for steroids? John, Philadelphia
Dear John:Drummers have to play loud to hear themselves over the din of their own cymbals, which can be deafening. It's a vicious cycle and--yes--I've seen some drummers resort to steroids, but only out of desperation.It gets worse: The louder drummers play, the faster they lose their hearing, making them play even louder, which in ... Continue Reading...August 2010
by Mr. P.C.
Dear Mr. P.C.:There is a certain scenario that continues to present itself when I am playing at a nightclub. I'll be sitting at a table before the gig or on a break, looking at charts or maybe just trying to cool out for a minute. One of the waiters will approach me and say something like, Excuse me, could you move? We need this table for people."Beyond just getting me to move, what is the larger ...
Continue Reading...


