All About Jazz

Home » Articles » Live Reviews


Grant Stewart Trio with Special Guest John Swana at Chris’ Jazz Café

Victor L. Schermer By

Sign in to view read count
Grant Stewart Trio with Special Guest John Swana
Chris' Jazz Cafe
Philadelphia, PA
August 18, 2017

In this supremely swinging hard bop set, Toronto-born New York saxophonist Grant Stewart joined long-time Philadelphia musicians: organist Lucas Brown, drummer Dan Monaghan, and special guest John Swana to knock out standards with a rare execution that was as tight as what might be the final takes on a recording date. The event was notable for Swana's first-time return to trumpet after several years following an embouchure problem that led him to play valve trombone and EVI (Electronic Valve Instrument). It was thrilling and nostalgic for Philly jazz fans to hear his special trumpet sound again. (Swana told this reviewer that he gradually recovered his embouchure through intensive practice, a heroic recovery considering that many players never pick up the instrument again when this occurs.)

Saxophonist Stewart more than lived up to his stellar reputation, playing, as Michael West of Jazz Times wrote, "steady swinging, muscular hard bop." West noted that Stewart's sound is "lean and sinewy, yet flush with lyricism, humor and rhythmic possibilities, much like tenor icons Dexter Gordon and Sonny Rollins, to whom Stewart is frequently compared." Mark Stryker of the Detroit Free Press couldn't have described Stewart's special qualities better: "What separates Stewart from so many of his peers stuck in the quicksand of hard bop nostalgia is the sheer creative spark and spontaneity of his solos. When Stewart gets hot the questions of individuality evaporate amid the in-the moment thrills of his invention." These observations accurately describe Stewart's playing on this night.

The ease with which Stewart created fascinating lines won the audience over from the very first notes of the Camelot perennial, "If Ever I Would Leave You," where Lucas and Monaghan also had opportunities to show their wares. Swana joined the group on trumpet for "Yesterdays." His sound was as fresh and full as ever, as he created phrase after phrase with consummate craftsmanship. Stewart swung brightly in a double time version of "The End of A Love Affair," which Dexter Gordon made his own in his Carnegie Hall concert of 1978 (release on Columbia, 1998). While there were touches of Gordon and of Rollins in Stewart's improvisations, the inventiveness was his own, his solo interspersed with hemidemisemiquavers that were the epitome of rapidity. By this time, as he traded eights, it was clear that drummer Monaghan was totally in his element with this group. He showed himself to be a master of hard bop rhythmic swing. Who knew?

On the ballad, "Laura," impeccable phrasing by both Swana and Stewart gave the standard a fresh luster. The group then went back to the origins of bebop for Dizzy Gillespie's "Woody'n You," with Swana on valve trombone. Swana then returned to the trumpet for Kenny Dorham's "Una Mas" where the creative connection between Dorham and Swana became crystal clear. The set concluded with Sonny Stitt's "The Eternal Triangle," a rocking version, with Swana on valve trombone, and in which Monaghan provided a phenomenal drum solo that brought the house down. In a way, the whole set belonged to Monaghan, as it was his rhythmic pulse and unstoppable ingenuity that enabled the group to relate so comfortably to one another.

Set List: If Ever I Would Leave You; Yesterdays; The End of a Love Affair; Laura; Woody'n You; Una Mas; The Eternal Triangle.

Personnel: Grant Stewart: tenor saxophone; John Swana: trumpet, valve trombone; John Lucas Brown: organ; Dan Monaghan: drums.

Photo Credit: Victor L. Schermer


comments powered by Disqus

Shop Music & Tickets

Click any of the store links below and you'll support All About Jazz in the process. Learn how.

Related Articles

Read 48th Annual Pitt Jazz Seminar Live Reviews
48th Annual Pitt Jazz Seminar
by Mackenzie Horne
Published: November 18, 2018
Read Martin Lesch Band  at The Jazz Corner Live Reviews
Martin Lesch Band at The Jazz Corner
by Martin McFie
Published: November 18, 2018
Read The Pittsburgh Jazz Orchestra at Greer Cabaret Theater Live Reviews
The Pittsburgh Jazz Orchestra at Greer Cabaret Theater
by Mackenzie Horne
Published: November 15, 2018
Read Enjoy Jazz 2018 Live Reviews
Enjoy Jazz 2018
by Henning Bolte
Published: November 14, 2018
Read Jazz for all Ages Live Reviews
Jazz for all Ages
by Martin McFie
Published: November 14, 2018
Read Baku Jazz Festival 2018 Live Reviews
Baku Jazz Festival 2018
by Ian Patterson
Published: November 13, 2018
Read "Mary Ellen Desmond: Comfort and Joy 2017" Live Reviews Mary Ellen Desmond: Comfort and Joy 2017
by Victor L. Schermer
Published: December 15, 2017
Read "GoGo Penguin at Out To Lunch" Live Reviews GoGo Penguin at Out To Lunch
by Ian Patterson
Published: January 25, 2018
Read "Matthew Shipp Trio at SFJAZZ" Live Reviews Matthew Shipp Trio at SFJAZZ
by Harry S. Pariser
Published: December 19, 2017
Read "Terence Blanchard at Christ Church Cranbrook" Live Reviews Terence Blanchard at Christ Church Cranbrook
by Troy Dostert
Published: December 29, 2017
Read "Hot Sugar at Jazz Cafe Montparnasse" Live Reviews Hot Sugar at Jazz Cafe Montparnasse
by Martin McFie
Published: July 14, 2018
Read "Jean-Luc Ponty at The Cabot" Live Reviews Jean-Luc Ponty at The Cabot
by Doug Hall
Published: August 27, 2018