Home » Jazz Articles » Claron McFadden, Roberta Alexander, Nancy Braithwaite, Michael Sti...


Album Review

Claron McFadden, Roberta Alexander, Nancy Braithwaite, Michael Stirling, Vaughan Schlepp: To Paradise with Onions: Songs and Chamber Works of Edith Hemenway


Sign in to view read count
Claron McFadden, Roberta Alexander, Nancy Braithwaite, Michael Stirling, Vaughan Schlepp: To Paradise with Onions: Songs and Chamber Works of Edith Hemenway
American composer Edith Hemenway wrote some of the most sublimely impressionistic music of the 20th century. Yet, outside of a small circle of aficionados and admirers, she remains virtually unknown. Unfortunately, despite her long career, To Paradise with Onions is the first time her work has been released on disc. Produced by longtime collaborator, clarinetist Nancy Brathwaite, this exquisite album consists of six of Hemenway's literature-inspired suites.

Based on Poet Laureate W. S Merwin's prose from 1979, "Asian Figures," for instance, is a series of brief clarinet and piano duets. Accompanying Brathwaite is pianist Vaughan Schlepp; their stimulating and tense exchanges give the piece a vibrant and captivating immediacy. From the whimsical "I Eat the Cucumber My Way"—with its dramatic atmosphere marked by Schlepp's percussive piano and Brathwaite's sinewy clarinet—to the melancholic and hypnotic "Autumn Rides Down On One Leaf," the two musicians paint abstract sonic images that provoke and move. Angular and crystalline phrases create the futuristic ambience of "Thread Has to Go Where the Needle Went" which delightfully contrasts with the cinematic lyricism of the wistful "Ferns Bend Into The Water/Over There."

Schlepp joins sopranos Roberta Alexander and Claron McFadden for a haunting rendition of "Four Poems of Langston Hughes," one of Hemenway's masterpieces. Alexander and McFadden's overlapping voices float over Schlepp's expressive pianism with elegance and grace. The performance is in keeping with the soulfulness of Hughes' verse. For example, Schlepp creates a blues-tinged harmonic tapestry on "Down and Out" while the vocalists' song shimmers with a hymn-like spirituality.

The seven-movement "Questions of Travel," after an Elizabeth Bishop poem, is an intriguing and multilayered composition that Brathwaite, Schlepp and cellist Michael Stirling interpret with almost mystical nuance and introspection. The sombre "Journey of Ancients" features the stately growl of the clarinet over resonant and reverberating piano notes and darkly-hued cello drones, while the serene "Siesta" is lullaby-like as it starts with softly undulating clarinet and cello lines. Schlepp contributes resonant notes that echo the preceding melody with tenderness and emotion.

This splendid and singular CD is a welcome introduction to Hemenway's unjustly underappreciated oeuvre. Being performed by artists who truly connect with and thoroughly absorb the composer's creative vision makes To Paradise with Onions that much more special. Hopefully, more of Hemenway's brilliant output will be recorded in the near future.

Track Listing

Doors: Moderate, despondent; Doors: Very slow and expressive, but in a steady tempo; Doors: Agitated; Questions of Travel: Landscape Viewed from a Train Window; Questions of Travel: The Dog Plagued by Fleas; Questions of Travel: Waterfalls; Questions of Travel: Journey of the Ancients; Questions of Travel: The Rented Car; Questions of Travel: Siesta; Questions of Travel: Think of the Long Trip Home; To Paradise for Onions; A Child’s Garden of Verses: Fairy Bread; A Child’s Garden of Verses: Where Go the Boats?; A Child’s Garden of Verses: Windy Nights; A Child’s Garden of Verses: The Cow; A Child’s Garden of Verses: Rain; A Child’s Garden of Verses: Farewell to the Farm; Asian Figures: I eat the cucumber my way; Asian Figures: Autumn rides down on one leaf; Asian Figures: Thread has to go where the needle went; Asian Figures: Ferns bend into the water / over there egrets are flying / I sit helpless with longing; Asian Figures: It’s only where pretty girls live / that he thinks his lost hen / might be found; Asian Figures: Oh temple flower / blooming in the dragons’ mouth; Asian Figures: Daybreak with clouds flying and one star / like a knife in the hill; Asian Figures: if I could find her I would see nothing else; Asian Figures: Life / candle flame / wind coming; Asian Figures: When you’re finished go home; Four Poems of Langston Hughes: Island; Four Poems of Langston Hughes: Down and Out; Four Poems of Langston Hughes: Midwinter Blues; Four Poems of Langston Hughes: Hope.


Claron McFadden: voice (soprano); Roberta Alexander: voice (soprano); Nancy Braithwaite: clarinet; Michael Stirling: cello; Vaughan Schlepp: piano.

Album information

Title: To Paradise with Onions: Songs and Chamber Works of Edith Hemenway | Year Released: 2019 | Record Label: EtceteraNOW

Post a comment about this album

Get the Jazz Near You newsletter All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who create it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

To expand our coverage even further and develop new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for a modest $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination will vastly improve your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.




Get more of a good thing!

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories, our special offers, and upcoming jazz events near you.