Meeting of the Minds and Sounds: The Clarinet and The Oud

Doug Collette By

Sign in to view read count
The clarinet is hardly as an exotic instrument as the oud, but both instruments have their places in modern jazz and it's always fascinating to hear how each sounds within those contexts they're placed. As a point of comparison, the music on these two releases is at once haunting and comforting, mesmerizing and intoxicating, ultimately luring in a listener to experience musicianship as involved as it is ingenious. As a result, the records offer exposure to familiar strains set in often stark relief with unconventional textures, the novel contrast of which may eventually spur the musiclover to delve further into the utilization of all these instruments, featured and otherwise.

Francois Houle -Alexander Hawkins -Harris Eisenstadt:
You Have Options
Songlines Recordings

Wielded by Francois Houle as he plays with pianist Alexander Hawkins and drummer Harris Eisenstadt, the prominence of the clarinet on You Have Options is a welcome reminder of the instrument's versatility. Original compositions from the trio's members surround selections by Steve Lacy ("Dusk"), Andrew Hill ("Art") and an improvisation on Charles Ives' "Largo," comprising an album recorded subsequent to live performances so mutually rewarding the threesome were compelled to work together in the studio. The airy but evocative atmosphere of the early tracks continues largely unabated for the near-hour total playing time, while plentiful space within the arrangements remains inviting rather than daunting for the duration as well. The expansive musicianship thus allows for poring over the project's backstory as outlined in the enclosed booklet, not to mention perusal of cover images that mirror the sounds inside.

Gordon Grdina's The Marrow
Songlines Recordings

Equally enthralling in their own wayGordon Grdina and his ensemble The Marrow are nonetheless much more assertive in their collective instrumental probing than Houle/Hawkins/Eisenstadt. Yet like that of its companion piece, the provocative playing on Ejdeha mirrors the graphic design of its digi-pak, presenting something of a Rorschach test for listeners upon which they can project, once seduced by the music on the CD. Along with cellist Hank Roberts, bassist Mark Helias and he of the exotic percussion, Hamin Honari, the leader utilizes his oud to meld a composite of the finely-woven timbres wherein the quartet actually renders the absence of space a virtue. The closely-knit interplay is a wonder to behold, even if it takes repeated hearings to fully appreciate its density, but the rewards multiply each time through, making every successive pass worthwhile.

Tracks and Personnel

You Have Options

Tracks: Clue; Art; Run Riot; The Pitts; Prayer; Advice; Largo; You Have Options, I Have a Lawyer; Le Concombre de Chicoutimi; Dusk.

Personnel: Francois Houle: clarinet; Alexander Hawkins: piano; Harris Eistenstadt: drums.


Tracks: Telesm; Idiolect; Ejdeha; Bordeaux Bender; Wayward; Full Circle; Boubacar .

Personnel: Gordon Grdina: oud; Mark Helias: bass; Hank Roberts: cello; Hamin Honari: tombak, daf, frame drum.

Post a comment




Northwestern Songs
Arne Torvik
I Am Not A Virus
Jordan VanHemert
Sam Rivers
A Congregation of Folks
Daniele Germani
Push The Limits
Ben Patterson
Old Friends
Mark Winkler


All About Jazz needs your support

All About Jazz & Jazz Near You were built to promote jazz music: both recorded albums and live events. We rely primarily on venues, festivals and musicians to promote their events through our platform. With club closures, limited reopenings and an uncertain future, we've pivoted our platform to collect, promote and broadcast livestream concerts to support our jazz musician friends. This is a significant but neccesary step that will help musicians and venues now, and in the future. You can help offset the cost of this essential undertaking by making a donation today. In return, we'll deliver an ad-free experience (which includes hiding the sticky footer ad). Thank you!

Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.