Erna Ferry: Devil May Care

Comparatively speaking, the Rodger Fox Big Band sounds terrific, as does guest pianist (and organist) Bill Cunliffe. Even so, the band is encumbered, as is Ferry, by the excessive "echo chamber effect that pervades Auckland's Avondale Studios, which often makes listening more a chore than a pleasure. I found this weakness especially displeasing, as I'm a big fan of Fox's sturdy ensemble.

Aside from being annoying, the exaggerated acoustics serve as a constant reminder that there is a microphone separating Ferry from her audience. To me, the best vocal albums are those in which the singer seems to be in the same room, crooning directly into my ear with no trace of electronic enhancement. That's definitely not the case here. Ferry is placed at a clear disadvantage, one that even her best efforts can't erase.

A pity, as the choice of material is sound and the charts, by Fox, Jeff Driskill, Mike Crotty, and the late Gordon Brisker, are first-rate. Likable solos, too, by Fox, Cunliffe, tenors Pete France and Cameron Allen, alto Godfrey de Grut, baritone Andrew Baker, and guitarist Neil Watson. But Ferry is the headliner, and the bloated acoustics do her no favors. Next time, let's pare the backup group down to a trio, okay?

Comments