Karrin Allyson: Ballads: Remembering John Coltrane

I am listening to The John Coltrane Quartet's Ballads as I write this piece. I have never considered Coltrane a player of "pretty music." Where Charlie Parker was "just looking for the pretty notes" during his frenetic creative spurts, Coltrane was just planning to look for a place for all notes, presented in just the right order and at the right tempo. Coltrane's solo on Miles Davis' "'Round Midnight" on 'Round about Midnight is a perfect example of what would become the tenorist's "wall of sound."

"Giant Steps" brings his vision a little closer to fruition and Coltrane's "My Favorite Things," from Live At the Village Vanguardâï¦Again probably could be considered Coltrane attaining spiritual perfection. Harold C. Schoenberg, former New York Times music critic, described music from Beethoven's final period as "music on a rarified plane—not pretty but merely sublime." So with John Coltrane.

I do not find John Coltrane's playing on Ballads pretty. It is his genius clarified through the cheesecloth of standards that makes this recording so timeless. His Impulse! recording with Johnny Hartman ( John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman, Impulse! 157, 1963) is the same way, but this time with a melding of voice and saxophone, somehow softening Coltrane's thorny exterior. Karrin Allyson takes this a step further with her new release, Ballads: Remembering John Coltrane.

With a voice and facility equal to any singer presently singing, Ms. Allyson infuses this special collection of standards with a pure beauty without sacrificing the Coltrane vision. Using the same arrangements as the Coltrane Quartet and for the most part following his playing, Ballads: Remembering John Coltrane offers the listener an idea of what Coltrane was thinking when blowing these ballads out of the bell of his horn. "Say It" is breathtaking as is "Too Young to Go Steady" and "All, or Nothing at All." Fellow saxists Bob Berg, Steve Wilson, and James Carter make no attempt to emulate the master, only to express happiness in playing the same music he once did. James Williams and John Patitucci are most tasteful in their support.

Karrin Allyson's Ballads: Remembering John Coltrane along with Rebecca Parris' Koch Jazz release, My Foolish Heart, are the best vocal discs of 2001. Period.

A perfectly conceived concept album.