Alexander McCabe / Paul Odeh: This Is Not A Pipe

Bruce Lindsay By

Sign in to view read count
The title is, presumably, a nod to "Ceci, C'est Ne Pas Une Pipe," the phrase which Rene Magritte wrote on his famous painting La Trahison Des Images. The painting wasn't, of course, a pipe, just a painting of a pipe. This Is Not A Pipe isn't a pipe either—it isn't even a painting of a pipe. So what is it? Alto saxophonist Alexander McCabe and pianist Paul Odeh have the answer—it's a recording of eight tunes, three standards and five originals.

Okay, that's a rather prosaic if factually correct description. More importantly, it's a recording of an alto/piano duo that's full of musical ideas and eminently capable of bringing those ideas to fruition, a duo whose regular weekly gigs have given McCabe and Odeh a deep understanding of each other's playing. The result is a free-flowing exchange that, coupled with the excellent sound quality, feels like a live performance even though it was recorded in McCabe's own studio.

"Friday's Good" is the album's most straightforward tune, a 12-bar blues that barrels along at a fair old pace, Odeh providing a punchy rhythm over which McCabe blows his alto with gusto. At the other extreme, the mid-section of "This Is Not A Pipe" begins as a brief but frenetic exchange, each instrument chasing and being chased in turn.

In between, the duo moves between fast re-interpretations of bop classics (Gigi Gryce's "Minority," full of dynamism and energy), spacious reflection (McCabe's "Penny's Way") and silky, sweet-natured, tunes (Odeh's "Daphne's Song," McCabe's "Miss Maritza"). Whatever the pace, however complex the structures, McCabe and Odeh never sound hurried or tense, a testament to their experience as a duo and their mutual understanding as musicians.

Track Listing: Miss Maritza; It Could Happen to You; Penny's Way; Emily; This Is Not A Pipe; Friday's Good; Daphne's Song; Minority.

Personnel: Alexander McCabe: alto saxophone; Paul Odeh: piano.

Title: This Is Not A Pipe | Year Released: 2014 | Record Label: Wamco Music


Jazz Near New York City
Events Guide | Venue Guide | Get App | More...

Shop for Music

Start your music shopping from All About Jazz and you'll support us in the process. Learn how.

Related Articles

Read Inmoral
By Mike Jurkovic
Read Live In Berlin
Live In Berlin
By Don Phipps
Read Break Up With the Sound
Break Up With the Sound
By C. Michael Bailey
Read So Us
So Us
By Geno Thackara
Read Dialogue
By Don Phipps
Read Nikobo
By Ian Patterson