All About Jazz

Home » Articles » Live Reviews


Peter Br


Sign in to view read count
Peter Brötzmann Trio
Empty Bottle, Chicago
January 12, 2005

On a bizarre January night—for Chicago, anyway—of thunder and torrential rain, European free-jazz pioneer Peter Brötzmann returned to the Empty Bottle to produce some extremely heavy weather of his own. Brötzmann's in town this week to play in several different venues in a variety of musical settings, and here he was teamed with drummer/percussionist Hamid Drake and bassist Kent Kessler. Both musicians have played with Brötzmann many times (their 1999 release Live at the Empty Bottle is a classic) and the trio's return to this packed venue did not disappoint; they played two riveting sets of completely improvised music.
The trio was alert, intense, and loud. Brötzmann played with an intensity and force that belied his sixty-one years. The first one-hour set consisted of two "songs"; Brötzmann played tenor on the first and clarinet on the second. The tenor piece was harsh, surging and bombastic, but had moments of startling tenderness, such as its haunting interlude of the leader's unaccompanied microtonal tenor sighing—in this context, call it a blues—with Kessler's arco bass and Drake's cymbals joining in gradually and gorgeously. Of course, this was followed by howling, spastic clusters of tenor rage over Drake's handplayed but muscular drumming; Brötzmann's "pretty" playing hasn't an iota of sentimentality and it never overstays its welcome.
The clarinet feature began with a half-toned, flutter-tongued clarinet intro and included a fantastic a cappella, scalar bass solo from Kessler and explosive, polyrhythmic playing from Drake—certainly, no drummer has played as well with Brötzmann since his collaborations with Han Bennink. The two seem to understand each other perfectly and it's fascinating to watch one suggest an idea as to where the improvisation should go and the other acquiesce or resist. Either way, the suggestion is always heard and understood; it's just that sometimes the other man has another notion. This piece—and the first set—culminated in pure, glowing squalling noise, Brötzmann wailing in his instrument's upper register over a free cacophany of churning bass and drums that felt almost religious. In any case, it was a strong reminder of the fact that this genre was known as "energy" music. Under the noise and polyphony, though, the piece had a melancholy, almost Old-World feeling—deep down, anyway.
A familiar figure appeared during the set break: local hero Ken Vandermark, setting his bass clarinet and baritone sax on stands. Hooray! Vandermark never got a chance to play his bass clarinet, but no one seemed upset: the second set was one long improvisation where Vandermark (on baritone) and Brötzmann (on gloriously contrasting alto) played with violent muscle and intensity, Brötzmann more than keeping up with the younger man. Again, this hour-long piece went through a variety of "movements", but it's the individual moments that stick in the memory: Kessler's mad, unaccompanied bowed solo, all knuckles and flailing arms; Brötzmann's long, somber lines over a repeated, circular-breath motif from Vandermark, the two producing a sense of ominous, sweet fragility; Drake's two alternating drum parts near the end that, once understood by the other three, produced a platform for all to unite to utterly devastating effect—this was some set. When the piece came to a close, Vandermark, Drake and Kessler turned to the leader to see if he was, indeed, exhausted. He was, and so was the audience.

Outside, the thunder continued; inside the club, it had exhausted itself.

Photo Credit
Ziga Koritnik


comments powered by Disqus

Related Articles

Read Dixie Dregs at Lincoln Theatre Live Reviews
Dixie Dregs at Lincoln Theatre
by Eric Thiessen
Published: March 18, 2018
Read The Dixie Dregs at Scottish Rite Auditorium Live Reviews
The Dixie Dregs at Scottish Rite Auditorium
by Geno Thackara
Published: March 17, 2018
Read Bruselas Flamenco Festival 2018 Live Reviews
Bruselas Flamenco Festival 2018
by Martin Longley
Published: March 17, 2018
Read Kyle Taylor Parker at The Green Room 42 Live Reviews
Kyle Taylor Parker at The Green Room 42
by Tyran Grillo
Published: March 17, 2018
Read Festival International de Jazz de Port-au-Prince, 2018 Live Reviews
Festival International de Jazz de Port-au-Prince, 2018
by Mark Sullivan
Published: March 16, 2018
Read Derek Bailey // Three Presences at Cafe Oto Live Reviews
Derek Bailey // Three Presences at Cafe Oto
by John Eyles
Published: March 8, 2018
Read "WDR 3 Jazzfest 2018" Live Reviews WDR 3 Jazzfest 2018
by Henning Bolte
Published: February 16, 2018
Read "Buenos Aires International Jazz Festival 2017" Live Reviews Buenos Aires International Jazz Festival 2017
by Mark Holston
Published: January 31, 2018
Read "Daniel Bennett Group at Tomi Jazz" Live Reviews Daniel Bennett Group at Tomi Jazz
by Tyran Grillo
Published: August 24, 2017
Read "12 Points Festival 2017" Live Reviews 12 Points Festival 2017
by Henning Bolte
Published: August 6, 2017
Read "Mike Westbrook at Bury St. Edmunds Festival" Live Reviews Mike Westbrook at Bury St. Edmunds Festival
by Duncan Heining
Published: June 14, 2017