George Gruntz: Mental Cruelty

AAJ Staff By

Sign in to view read count
George Gruntz: Mental Cruelty
The original issue of George Gruntz's 1960 soundtrack to Mental Cruelty was as obscure as it gets. The 100 LPs printed at the time immediately disappeared into the abyss due to some corporate bullshit, leaving a gaping black hole at the start of the Swiss pianist's recording career and a severe market price for the record in the range of $1000.

Atavistic's appropriately titled Unheard Music Series imprint has picked this disc up for reissue, including all 18 tracks plus three additional scraps from tape. At the time Gruntz was hovering in obscurity and generating untold numbers of film soundtracks, theater scores, and operas. He would enter the spotlight later in his career, but at this time he was anything but a household name. Working with French saxophonist Barney Wilen in various configurations, he also briefly joined forces with drummer Kenny "Klook" Clarke. Both appear prominently here.

My initial impression based on the title of the film and the last name of the artist was pure trepidation. What a surprise it was to hear a swinging, relaxed jazz issue forth, somewhere between cool and bop. The "Themes" that recur throughout the disc help unify it and ensure a light but wholesome feel. The through-composed "Main Theme" opens the disc, a freely swinging stroll through the garden. Its melody is so classic that it almost sounds cliche, but that only exemplifies the way these tunes convey a strange sense of familiarity. A sedate blues follows, then a "Student Hang Out" straight out of the Miles Davis Prestige songbook (Raymond Court nimbly holding court on the trumpet).

Down the road the group touches pointedly on tango and a "Romance" with Wilen's voices on soprano and tenor sax eerily resembling Coltrane's early '60s work. A tiny 40-second hunk of fire on "Good Time Joe" yields to a Latin feel (coaxed along by Clarke in elegant style) and later a mid- tempo waltz. With a brief 23 seconds of theme, the soundtrack closes. (Bonus tracks expand briefly on already-familiar tunes.)

The brevity of these pieces (only four of which span more than three minutes) ensures a minimum of solo time, focusing the group's sound on arranged passages and straightforward themes. For the most part, Gruntz hangs low, content to accent the horns and ensure continuity, and it seems that his cohorts appreciate the subtlety and nuance of these pieces. It's tempting to single out soloists for their brief contributions, but in the end the compositions sit foremost. Of course, the main attraction (in terms of star value) is drummer Kenny Clarke, whose playing here never grabs the spotlight but always reinforces forward momentum. And, lest it be forgotten, he's a virtual epicenter of swing.

A fine resurrection, wonderfully romantic and completely unpretentious.

Visit Atavistic on the web.

Track Listing

Main Theme; Blues And Theme; Student Hang Out; Morning After The Wedding Night; Music For Night Children; Jazz Appreciation I; Jazz Appreciation II; Swiss Tease; Romance I; Romance II; Stroll On Theme; Good Time Joe; Latin Stroll On Theme; Main Theme - Romance; Spanish castles; Nick And Marlene; The Proposal; Final Theme; Student hang Out; main Theme Version X; Main Theme Version Y.


George Gruntz - Piano; Barney Wilen - Tenor Saxophone, Soprano Saxophone; Marcel Peeters - Alto Saxophone, Flute; Raymond Court - Trumpet. Karl Theodor Geier - Bass; Kenny Clarke - Drums.

Album information

Title: Mental Cruelty | Year Released: 2003 | Record Label: Atavistic Worldwide

Post a comment about this album


Shop Amazon


Read ReFocus
Tim Garland
Read Quiet Places
Quiet Places
Andreas Vollenweider
Read Duplexity
John Blum and Jackson Krall
Read Now
Lafayette Gilchrist
Read 25 Years
25 Years
Edward Simon
Read Splatter
Roscoe Mitchell

All About Jazz needs your support

All About Jazz & Jazz Near You were built to promote jazz music: both recorded and live events. We rely primarily on venues, festivals and musicians to promote their events through our platform. With club closures, shelter in place and an uncertain future, we've pivoted our platform to collect, promote and broadcast livestream concerts to support our jazz musician friends. This is a significant but neccesary effort that will help musicians now, and in the future. You can help offset the cost of this essential undertaking by making a donation today. In return, we'll deliver an ad-free experience (which includes hiding the bottom right video ad). Thank you.

Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.