All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review


Carl Saunders: Eclecticism

Jack Bowers By

Sign in to view read count
There is one unequivocal reason to acquire this album, and it can be summarized in two words: Carl Saunders. If you’ve not yet heard this unsung master of the trumpet / flugelhorn, it’s time you did. And if you’ve already been introduced I needn’t say more, as no doubt the decision has already been made to lay your hands on a copy of his second album, Eclecticism. While I can’t honestly say that I was inflamed by the decision to pair Saunders with a string orchestra, his consummate artistry overshadows every digression including several out–of–the–ordinary choices of material. What emerges is a near–facsimile of “Carl Saunders meets the Metropole Orchestra,” although Carl didn’t have to travel to the Netherlands to record it. Some listeners may find the strings and French horns delightful; I’d prefer less strings, more Saunders. As is the fashion these days, Carl overdubs his trumpet on most tracks to become a one–man “trumpet section,” a device that works quite well in spite of the recording’s often intemperate reverb. The rhythm section, even though submerged at times beneath the weight of the strings, is top–drawer, and here we must append an asterisk to the “one unequivocal reason” for procuring the album, as there is an ancillary reason — pianist Billy Childs, whose tasteful interludes always leave one nodding his (or her) head in earnest appreciation. Saunders and Childs comprise an harmonious team, each one as staunchly resourceful as he is technically precise. Saunders plays muted trumpet on Jackson Stock’s “Pentiction,” flugel on the standard “Old Folks” (arranged by Joe Lano). He wrote “Reaching for You,” “Blues for the Common Man” and adapted Frédéric Chopin’s “Valse Opus 64, #2” for trumpet, strings and rhythm. The date’s better–known arrangers include Bob Florence (“Fascinatin’ Rhythm”), Bill Holman (“Surrey with the Fringe on Top”) and Clare Fischer (“Last Night When We Were Young’). Other original compositions are by Scott Tibbs (“The Price of Admission,” “Night Reverie”) and Larry Dominello (“First Gift”) who also arranged “Reaching for You.” As far as unalloyed Jazz is concerned, Saunders and Childs have some of their best moments on the curtain–raiser (“Fascinatin’ Rhythm”) and finale (“Blues for the Common Man”). Elsewhere, the strings tend to impede any decisive movement in that direction. Eclecticism, of course, means choosing the most suitable components from a number of sources or styles, and as a showcase for Saunders’ trumpet–playing acumen, this wide–ranging album achieves its goal. On the other hand, one can’t help thinking that Saunders could have unloaded the strings, saved himself a substantial piece of change, and made an even better one with Childs, bassist Magnusson and drummer Savino. Maybe next time . . .

Contact:SNL Records, Suite 181, 3230 E. Flamingo Road, Las Vegas, NV 89121. Web site,; e–mail [email protected]

Track Listing: Fascinatin' Rhythm' / Reaching for You / Valtz Opus 64 #2 / First Gift / Surrey with the Fringe on Top / Las Night When We Were Young / The Price of Admission / Pentiction / Night Reverie / Old Folks / Blues for the Common Man

Personnel: Carl Saunders - trumpet, flugelhorn; Billy Childs - piano; Bob Magnusson - bass; Santo Savino - drums; Larry Dominello, Clare Fischer, Bob Florence, Bill Holman, Joe Lano, Carl Saunders, Jackson Stock, Scott Tibbs - arrangers; strings & French horns on most cuts, Assa Drori - concertmaster.

Title: Eclecticism | Year Released: 2001


comments powered by Disqus

Related Articles

Read The Questions CD/LP/Track Review
The Questions
by Dan Bilawsky
Published: March 20, 2018
Read Meerkat Parade CD/LP/Track Review
Meerkat Parade
by Geno Thackara
Published: March 20, 2018
Read The Poetry of Jazz CD/LP/Track Review
The Poetry of Jazz
by Mark Corroto
Published: March 20, 2018
Read The Unknowable CD/LP/Track Review
The Unknowable
by Glenn Astarita
Published: March 20, 2018
Read Like A Radio CD/LP/Track Review
Like A Radio
by Doug Collette
Published: March 20, 2018
Read Live In Healdsburg CD/LP/Track Review
Live In Healdsburg
by Dan Bilawsky
Published: March 19, 2018
Read "The Street Doctor" CD/LP/Track Review The Street Doctor
by Jakob Baekgaard
Published: January 26, 2018
Read "Double Down" CD/LP/Track Review Double Down
by James Nadal
Published: June 10, 2017
Read "Straight Ahead From Havana" CD/LP/Track Review Straight Ahead From Havana
by James Nadal
Published: June 6, 2017
Read "Ask Seek Knock" CD/LP/Track Review Ask Seek Knock
by Roger Farbey
Published: June 28, 2017
Read "Twin" CD/LP/Track Review Twin
by Fiona Ord-Shrimpton
Published: April 6, 2017
Read "Wobbly Dance Flower" CD/LP/Track Review Wobbly Dance Flower
by Jerome Wilson
Published: October 4, 2017