All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review

550

Dan Weiss: Tintal Drumset Solo

John Kelman By

Sign in to view read count
Since emerging on the New York scene a few years ago, drummer Dan Weiss has managed to involve himself with some significant names, including saxophonist David Binney and guitarists Joel Harrison, Gary Lucas, and Rez Abbasi. And while he's clearly demonstrated a broad reach, it's his work with Abbasi—both in performance and on Abbasi's latest album, Snake Charmer—that reveals his special interest in Indian music, albeit, in Abbasi's case, with a more contemporary bent.

Weiss has, in fact, been studying tabla and Indian classical music with his Guru (teacher) Samir Chatterjee since '98, making him especially well-suited for Abbasi's fusion of the Indian improvising tradition with a Western harmonic aesthetic. But Weiss' interests go much deeper than that, as he proves on Tintal Drum set Solo, where he takes the concept of a traditional Indian tabla solo and migrates it to a conventional drum set. The hour-long performance, also featuring guitarist Miles Okazaki's simple yet hypnotic melody that develops from a more languid tempo to a faster pace by the album's end, as well as Weiss' own percussive Indian vocalizing, seems to go by in no time.

When listening to Tintal Drum set Solo, the trick is to reverse more conventional roles. Whereas, in a typical Western context, one would expect the guitar to be the melodic centre and the drums to be the rhythmic support, here one needs to place Weiss' kit up front, with Okazaki in the supporting role. This becomes even more evident when referring to Weiss' detailed liner notes that reveal how the piece—actually consisting of 42 separate sections—is built on a number of different compositions. Focus too much on Okazaki, and you lose sight of that fact; but reverse the roles and the melodic variations become far clearer.

There's often talk about jazz drummers who approach their kit in a melodic way—Bill Stewart, for example—and what makes Tintal Drum set Solo such an engaging listen is Weiss' similar propensity for using every part of the drum set as a lyric component, the same way the tabla is able to articulate its own melodic framework.

As much as Tintal Drum set Solo can be an intriguing listen if one is able to stray from conventional thought, it's also a remarkable technical achievement when one considers that the tabla are played with hands and fingers in close proximity, while the drum set requires greater range of physical motion. In the same way that, for example, Western classical compositions for piano have been adapted to guitar, Weiss has taken the challenge of translating music written for one instrument to another that—while both are percussion instruments—is completely different when it comes to execution.

Tintal Drum set Solo may be of special interest to drummers who want to hear the melodic potential of their instrument fully exploited, but is of equal interest to anyone who can dispense with predisposition and accept the drum set's broader possibilities.

Track Listing: 1-8: Vilambit (Slow) Tintal; 9-20 Madya (Medium) Tintal; 21-42: Drut (Fast) Tintal.

Personnel: Dan Weiss: drum set, voice; Miles Okazaki: guitar.

Title: Tintal Drumset Solo | Year Released: 2005 | Record Label: Chhandayan Production

Tags

comments powered by Disqus

CD/LP/Track Review
Read more articles
Starebaby

Starebaby

Pi Recordings
2018

buy
Sixteen: Drummers Suite

Sixteen: Drummers...

Pi Recordings
2016

buy
Fourteen

Fourteen

Pi Recordings
2014

buy
 

Timshel

Sunnyside Records
2011

buy
Jhaptal Drumset Solo

Jhaptal Drumset Solo

Chhandayan Production
2011

buy
Timshel

Timshel

Sunnyside Records
2010

buy

Related Articles

Read Shades CD/LP/Track Review
Shades
by Doug Collette
Published: October 20, 2018
Read Putumayo Presents: Ska Around the World CD/LP/Track Review
Putumayo Presents: Ska Around the World
by Jim Trageser
Published: October 20, 2018
Read Pattern Recognition CD/LP/Track Review
Pattern Recognition
by Mark Sullivan
Published: October 20, 2018
Read Just This CD/LP/Track Review
Just This
by Chris Mosey
Published: October 20, 2018
Read Live at Sowieso CD/LP/Track Review
Live at Sowieso
by Glenn Astarita
Published: October 20, 2018
Read Displaced Diaspora CD/LP/Track Review
Displaced Diaspora
by Chris May
Published: October 19, 2018
Read "Journey Moments" CD/LP/Track Review Journey Moments
by Mike Jurkovic
Published: July 18, 2018
Read "In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983" CD/LP/Track Review In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983
by Chris Mosey
Published: March 18, 2018
Read "Postcard Collection" CD/LP/Track Review Postcard Collection
by Jack Bowers
Published: June 21, 2018
Read "A Gathering Foretold" CD/LP/Track Review A Gathering Foretold
by Geannine Reid
Published: December 12, 2017
Read "Joe Frazier Round 3 (CD Single)" CD/LP/Track Review Joe Frazier Round 3 (CD Single)
by John Kelman
Published: June 6, 2018
Read "D'Agala" CD/LP/Track Review D'Agala
by John Sharpe
Published: January 28, 2018