Make a difference: Support jazz online

Support All About Jazz Your friends at All About Jazz are looking for readers to help back our website upgrade project. Of critical importance, this project will result in a vastly improved design across all devices and will make future All About Jazz projects much easier to implement. Click here to learn more about this project including donation rewards.


The Penguin Guide To Jazz Recordings, 8th Edition

John Eyles By

Sign in to view read count
The Penguin Guide To Jazz Recordings
Richard Cook and Brian Morton
Softcover; 1534 pages
ISBN: 0141023279

Now in its eighth edition, fourteen years since it first appeared, Richard Cook and Brian Morton's The Penguin Guide To Jazz Recordings is not going to spring any great surprises on us. It doesn't need to; it has a tried and trusted formula that works. Its blend of facts and opinion is just about perfect, making it an invaluable reference work without the dry scholarly tone that some reference works can have. And the re-introduction of an index—after its absence in the last edition—greatly adds to its use as a work of reference.

It's rare to dip into this guide without coming away better informed and wishing to take issue with one or more of the authors' judgements. (Why does Keith Rowe no longer merit an entry? Why has Steve Lacy's wonderful Spirit Of Mingus been demoted from four to three stars?). But the ultimate test of a work like this is how often it is used; my copies of the previous seven editions—each tatty, well-thumbed, dog-eared and annotated—bear witness to its success over those fourteen years.

Every two years, the arrival of a new edition is the cue for jazz fans across the globe to enter a prolonged period of social hibernation while they identify and then digest Cook and Morton's additions and revisions. The scale of these can be breathtaking; in the two years since the appearance of the seventh edition, the dynamic duo have added assessments of some two thousand new CDs—that's an average of three per day. They have also added listings of over four hundred new artists.

At such a rate of production, it's not surprising that Cook and Morton occasionally don't get it spot on first time—and to their great credit, the pair are never dogmatic, and have always been willing to return to past assessments and revise them when they feel it necessary. They also revise entries in the light of an artist's new releases and/or demise.

The book is of equal value to both experienced jazz listeners and novices. The long-established system of the authors awarding graphically-flagged crowns to albums that are their personal favourites provides a quick, easy guide to beginners; while for experienced listeners, the movement of albums in and out of the crowns, edition by edition, is more fascinating than following the stock exchange.

With the last edition, the introduction of a second category, the Core Collection, was intended to further help newcomers to jazz. Personally, I have my doubts; even as an experienced listener I'm baffled by the relationship between the two categories. Let's take Miles Davis as an example: Milestones and The Complete In A Silent Way Sessions are both in the Core Collection. Kind Of Blue is both crowned and in the Core Collection. The Complete Live At The Plugged Nickel and Miles Davis & Gil Evans: The Complete Columbia Studio Sessions are only crowned. Why? The implication is that the choices for crowns are subjective, while the Core Collection is somehow more objective. Yet all are being chosen by just two authors—and all such judgements are ultimately subjective.

Having said that, the choices for both categories are hard to argue with. Taken together, they provide a great list for listeners old or new. I'm grateful to have been steered towards some of the past crowns I'd never have stumbled upon by chance. And it is great to see Alexander von Schlippenbach's (newly crowned) Monk's Casino get due recognition.

Yes, Cook and Morton may sometimes seem like the jazz equivalent of the Stasi—rewriting history and air-brushing out those who have fallen from grace—but if they didn't exist, we'd have to invent them. Long may they thrive.


comments powered by Disqus

More Articles

Read Good Morning Blues Book Reviews Good Morning Blues
by Richard J Salvucci
Published: January 11, 2018
Read The Great Jazz and Pop Vocal Albums Book Reviews The Great Jazz and Pop Vocal Albums
by Roger Crane
Published: December 19, 2017
Read Listening For The Secret: The Grateful Dead And The Politics Of Improvisation Book Reviews Listening For The Secret: The Grateful Dead And The...
by Ian Patterson
Published: December 10, 2017