Support All About Jazz

All About Jazz needs your help and we have a deal. Pay $20 and we'll hide those six pesky Google ads that appear on every page, plus this box and the slideout box on the right for a full year! You'll also fund website expansion.


I want to help
288

One for All: The Lineup

Ken Kase By

Sign in to view read count Views
One for All: The Lineup Time was when jazz history was measured in terms of linear progress as artists influenced each other to create new sounds. Jazz, it has been said, fed off of itself in a constant state of progression, pushing the music to its limits. But times have changed, and this construct has been revised several times over as legions of musicians found their inspiration in established jazz styles and stuck with them.

The Lineup is the eleventh release by One for All, a group of esteemed and virtuosic instrumentalists. The eight tracks on this release personify the hard bop ethos, but that feeling of being stuck in time is relieved by the freshness of the compositions and the outstanding musicianship throughout. No matter what the genre, nothing can replace the exuberance exhibited by musicians who clearly love what they're doing.

Tenor saxophonist Eric Alexander turns in two fine compositions: "Anatolia," which features his robust tone and restless manner of his playing, and the immensely appealing "Little Lucas," which recalls Wayne Shorter's early compositions for the Jazz Messengers and features trumpeter Jim Rotondi in a Harmon-muted solo. His playing, while rooted in the hard bop tradition, is nonetheless distinctive, and his performance is playful and understated.

Rotondi presents two compositions: "Downtown Sounds," which bears the hallmark of Herbie Hancock's late-'60s/early-'70s period and features an adventurous open horn solo over a Latin-infused groove as pianist David Hazeltine switches to the Fender rhodes for a retro yet vibrant feel. "Express Train" features complex but accessible harmonic and rhythmic shifts and displays Rotondi's beautiful tone.

Trombonist Steve Davis contributes a lovely ballad, "Letter to Mary" and "Smooth," a track which oozes with late-sixties R&B-influenced cool. Pianist David Hazeltine's "The Lineup" is a true swinging period piece that follows the hard bop blueprint with fine performances from the entire sextet. But one longs to hear his keyboard contributions a bit more up front throughout the album, which are quite good, if you listen for them. The least appealing track is their version of the old standard "Sweet and Lovely." While finely executed, it lacks the excitement of the band's originals and brings a corresponding sag in texture.

For many jazz fans, this type of music is the be-all and end-all—the very essence of what constitutes jazz. Lucky for them that this release stands above a seemingly endless stream of releases that attempt to mine the past with less successful results. Straight-ahead zealots deserve nothing less than the very best of what they enjoy, and they'll find that in spades on The Lineup, and indeed on most of One for All's releases.


Track Listing: Anatolia; Little Lucas; Sweet And Lovely; Downtown Sounds; Letter To Mary; The Lineup; Express Train; Smooth.

Personnel: Eric Alexander: tenor sax; Jim Rotondi: trumpet, flugelhorn; Steve Davis: trombone; David Hazeltine: piano; John Webber: bass; Joe Farnsworth: drums.

Year Released: 2006 | Record Label: Sharp Nine Records | Style: Straight-ahead/Mainstream


Shop For Jazz

CD/LP/Track Review
New York Beat
Extended Analysis
Multiple Reviews
CD/LP/Track Review
Read more articles
The Third Decade
The Third Decade
Smoke Sessions Records
2016
buy
One for All: Incorrigible
One for All:...
Jazz Legacy Productions
2010
buy
The Lineup
The Lineup
Sharp Nine Records
2006
buy
No Problem
No Problem
Venus Records
2003
buy
Live at Smoke- Volume 1
Live at Smoke- Volume...
Criss Cross
2002
buy
Billy Taylor Billy Taylor
piano
Jim Rotondi Jim Rotondi
trumpet
Thomas Marriott Thomas Marriott
trumpet
Mark Rapp Mark Rapp
trumpet
Alex Sipiagin Alex Sipiagin
trumpet
Mingus Big Band Mingus Big Band
band/orchestra
Scotty Barnhart Scotty Barnhart
trumpet
Jeff Coffin Jeff Coffin
saxophone

Post a comment

comments powered by Disqus

Join the staff. Writers Wanted!

Develop a column, write album reviews, cover live shows, or conduct interviews.