2

John Butcher, Thomas Lehn, Matthew Shipp: Tangle

John Eyles By

Sign in to view read count
Recorded at Café Oto in February 2014, on the first night of pianist Matthew Shipp's three-day residency at the venue, Tangle is the first recording of the trio of saxophonist John Butcher and synthesiser player Thomas Lehn with Shipp. (The YouTube clip, below, was filmed on the night in question.) Typically, there were previous links between the three, with evidence being available on past Fataka releases; Butcher and Lehn had first collaborated as far back as 1996 and, in June 2012, the two had recorded with John Tilbury as captured on Exta (Fataka, 2013); at a previous Shipp residency at Oto, in 2010, he and Butcher had played as a duo for the first time , as heard on At Oto (Fataka, 2012). Lehn and Shipp seem to have had no previous contact prior to this date, though.

The music consists of four tracks, totalling just over forty-three minutes, so they probably represent an entire set by the trio. The first three tracks, together entitled "Cluster," play seamlessly as one continuous piece which takes up the lion's share of the album, with the six-minute "Tiefenschärfe" rounding it off. "Cluster" begins in subdued fashion, with Shipp playing a series of chords so formally that one might suspect this to be a notated composition by the pianist; however, the sleeve credits all three members for the piece, usually a sure sign of an improvisation. Alongside Shipp, Lehn's synthesiser acts as a welcome anarchic element, interjecting occasional beats, clicks and glitches that complement the piano.

When Butcher enters on saxophone, a couple of minutes in, things rapidly shift onto more familiar improv territory, with the sax and piano exchanging phrases while the synth finds plenty of space to comment without detracting from them. Once Butcher has found his feet, his playing becomes noticeably freer and he soon cuts loose and blows, bringing a similar reaction from Shipp. In fact, the dynamic between Butcher and Shipp resembles that on At Oto where, through subtle musical negotiation, they found common ground on which they were both comfortable.

The end result is a model of trio improvisation in that all three seem constantly aware of the others' playing, so that each contribution from any of the three has an obvious effect. Changes of mood or tempo do not happen at the behest of any one player but evolve organically from the playing of all three. The music is at its most thrilling when all three are playing full-on together—but even then, it never becomes, um, tangled. Just as impressive are the more measured, ensemble passages. If, as we must hope, this trio records together again, they should not name the group after this album!

Track Listing: Cluster I; Cluster II; Cluster III; Tiefenschärfe.

Personnel: John Butcher: saxophone, feedback; Thomas Lehn: analogue synthesiser; Matthew Shipp: piano.

Title: Tangle | Year Released: 2016 | Record Label: Fataka

Tags

comments powered by Disqus

Shop for Music

Start your music shopping from All About Jazz and you'll support us in the process. Learn how.

Building a Jazz Library
Album Reviews
Multiple Reviews
Catching Up With
Album Reviews
  • Exta by John Eyles
Extended Analysis
Album Reviews
Multiple Reviews
Album Reviews
Live Reviews
Album Reviews
Read more articles
Into Darkness

Into Darkness

Iluso Records
2018

buy
So Beautiful, It Starts to Rain

So Beautiful, It...

Clean Feed Records
2017

buy
Last Dream at the Morning

Last Dream at the...

Relative Pitch Records
2017

buy
Tangle

Tangle

Fataka
2016

buy
So Beautiful, It Starts To Rain

So Beautiful, It...

Clean Feed Records
2016

buy
 

Plume

Challenge Jazz
2013

buy

Upcoming Shows

Date Detail Price
Jun26Wed
John Butcher, Eddie Prévost
Iklectik
London, UK

Related Articles

Read LP1 Album Reviews
LP1
By Dan Bilawsky
June 17, 2019
Read The Garden Of Earthly Delights Album Reviews
The Garden Of Earthly Delights
By Friedrich Kunzmann
June 17, 2019
Read Groove Machine Album Reviews
Groove Machine
By Don Phipps
June 17, 2019
Read Life in the Modern World Album Reviews
Life in the Modern World
By Nicholas F. Mondello
June 17, 2019
Read Live at I.C.U.U. Album Reviews
Live at I.C.U.U.
By Karl Ackermann
June 16, 2019
Read 789 Miles Album Reviews
789 Miles
By David A. Orthmann
June 16, 2019
Read Follow Me Album Reviews
Follow Me
By Roger Farbey
June 16, 2019