All About Jazz needs your help and we have a deal. Pay $20 and we'll hide those six pesky Google ads that appear on every page, plus this box and the slideout box on the right for a full year! You'll also fund website expansion.
A sense of restraint pervades this whole programme of piano trio music, and it works to make it less compelling, especially when the underlying approach is oblique both harmonically and rhythmically.
On one level the trio seems to be trying to make maximum use of minimum material. While this approach can result in music that demands attention, the results here just seem to hang in the air. On "Coincidence," the three musicians seem intent on avoiding emphatic interplay and the kind of sleight-of-hand interaction that would make for compelling listening.
On "Versunkene Stadt" Friedrich fingers his keys in the intro like a man whose sole ambition is to recreate the archetypal ECM sound from a time when that label was better known for the antiseptic quality of its recordings than the inherent value of the music it was putting out.
"Karusell" drifts by in an arrhythmic vein, although on this occasion matters seem just a little worse, as the group seems to be working as three individuals who just happened to be in the same room. When drummer Tony Moreno breaks out into a restrained backbeat for no more than a few bars, the proceedings sink into near-incoherence.
In a way this is all a real shame. It's not difficult to imagine how someone like Paul Bley would make all sorts of moves over "Velvet," and while Friedrich puts in his most telling work of the disc on this one, he simply doesn't have that master's depth of personality or individuality.
Overall this could just about amount to a logical conclusion to the developments in the piano trio format that Bill Evans first flagged up over forty years ago. Such speculation seems less than constructive, however, especially when this trio loses so much by any such comparison.