All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review


Vijay Iyer & Rudresh Mahanthappa: Raw Materials

Budd Kopman By

Sign in to view read count
The music of pianist Vijay Iyer and altoist Rudresh Mahanthappa always communicates a feeling of importance, whether they appear individually or together in any of a myriad of groups. The "alter ego" analogy is perhaps a bit stale by now, but their decade-long connection is on full display in Raw Materials.

Their musical background comes from the Carnatic (southern Indian), as opposed to Hindustani (northern Indian) tradition. However, if you're familiar with Iyer's recent release Reimagining (Savoy, 2005) or Mahanthappa's Mother Tongue (Pi, 2004), you'll know that for both of these intense musicians, this musical background underpins and suffuses the music, but it's alloyed with so much of their Western musical experience that the result is something new.

The spirit which emerges from this duo is a true partnership. Iyer and Mahanthappa continually trade the lead role, many times playing "in front" together, creating a dense sound. Much of Iyer's playing has a very Late Romantic feel, as if pre-twelve-tone Schoenberg had spent years in India, merging that white-hot European fire with moist heat. Every note Mahanthappa plays, even softly, has a strong, forceful direction and pressure. His sound is quite vocal, with more than a touch of the reed burr, and he speaks, not implores, through his horn.

The first twelve of these thirteen magnificent tracks come from a suite called "Sangha: Collaborative Fables," and thus seem connected. From the first notes of "The Shape of Things," the musical stage is set, and we are transported to a land of pure music. This introductory piece could easily be mistaken for Wagner during its first measures. Iyer sets the pedal tone and almost a tonality with the opening interval, blurring it with high notes out of "key" and creating a feeling of Indian timelessness. Mahanthappa then enters, proclaiming the same rising fourth, but then hits the leading tone of the Western scale, treating it, however, in the Indian manner of scale, rather than key. The phrase then lands on a clear major third, but the music refuses to be pinned down to tonal considerations. Yet the piece ends in a tonal rest.

The rest of suite's movements, although they create entirely different moods, all share this musical space which drifts back and forth between East and West, blending the two into one. Each track has its charms, but a highlight is "Come Back," a love song which extends and stretches the ballad form and feeling until it almost sounds like a recital of Schubert leider transcribed for piano and saxophone. The two musicians manage the tension expertly over the six-plus minutes, and you might end up with wet eyes from the beauty of it all.

There is much more to appreciate on Raw Materials, a total triumph from beginning to end.

Visit Vijay Iyer, Rudresh Mahanthappa and Raw Materials on the web.

Track Listing: The Shape of Things; All the Names; Forgotten System; Remembrance; Frontlash; Five Fingers Make a Fist; Inside the Machine; Stronger Than Itself; Come back; Fly Higher; Common Ground; Rataplan; Hope.

Personnel: Vijay Iyer: piano; Rudresh Mahanthappa: alto saxophone.

Title: Raw Materials | Year Released: 2006 | Record Label: Savoy Jazz


comments powered by Disqus



Vijay Iyer

Live Reviews
CD/LP/Track Review
Read more articles
Far from Over

Far from Over

ECM Records

Break Stuff

Break Stuff

ECM Records



ECM Records


Related Articles

Read Peaks of Light CD/LP/Track Review
Peaks of Light
by Mark Sullivan
Published: March 18, 2018
Read In Denmark I Was Born CD/LP/Track Review
In Denmark I Was Born
by Gareth Thompson
Published: March 18, 2018
Read In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983 CD/LP/Track Review
In Copenhagen - Live at Jazzhus Slukefter 1983
by Chris Mosey
Published: March 18, 2018
Read A Year Ago Today CD/LP/Track Review
A Year Ago Today
by Doug Collette
Published: March 18, 2018
Read Dreams of Belonging CD/LP/Track Review
Dreams of Belonging
by C. Michael Bailey
Published: March 18, 2018
Read Ravensburg CD/LP/Track Review
by Mike Jurkovic
Published: March 17, 2018
Read "Wrong Turns And Dead Ends" CD/LP/Track Review Wrong Turns And Dead Ends
by Mark Sullivan
Published: December 13, 2017
Read "Old Soul" CD/LP/Track Review Old Soul
by Anya Wassenberg
Published: February 26, 2018
Read "Akua's Dance" CD/LP/Track Review Akua's Dance
by Chris M. Slawecki
Published: June 9, 2017
Read "Just Funkin' Around" CD/LP/Track Review Just Funkin' Around
by Jeff Winbush
Published: August 5, 2017
Read "J Jazz: Deep Modern Jazz From Japan 1969 - 1984" CD/LP/Track Review J Jazz: Deep Modern Jazz From Japan 1969 - 1984
by Chris May
Published: March 15, 2018
Read "Les Liaisons Dangereuses 1960" CD/LP/Track Review Les Liaisons Dangereuses 1960
by Mark Sullivan
Published: June 4, 2017