Make a difference: Support jazz online

Support All About Jazz Your friends at All About Jazz are looking for readers to help back our website upgrade project. Of critical importance, this project will result in a vastly improved design across all devices and will make future All About Jazz projects much easier to implement. Click here to learn more about this project including donation rewards.


Portland Jazz Festival Day 3: February 18, 2007

John Kelman By

Sign in to view read count
Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3

Roundtable Discussion: The Myth of the ECM Sound

The final day of the Portland Jazz Festival's opening weekend also featured the last of three roundtable discussions about ECM Records. The subject was "The Myth of the ECM Sound"—with a large group of participants, including ECM's Steve Lake, writer/moderator Howard Mandel, publicist Don Lucoff, writers Neil Tesser and Josef Woodard, writer/audiophile expert Thomas Conrad, writer/studio engineer Larry Appelbaum, and yours truly. The stage was set for some serious debunking of the myth.

After an introduction that attempted to dispel common misconceptions about ECM—that there are stock technical approaches like microphone placement, reverb settings and other post-production techniques—what became clear as the discussion progressed was that ECM does have an identifiable sound, but it's more expansive than any narrow definition. Transparency, clarity and nuance were among the common terms bantered about.

One source of disagreement that occurred throughout the weekend was whether or not the ECM sound is "cold." Another was the subject of the label's broader soundscapes, which rarely emulate the gritty sound one might hear in a club. But through discussion of contentious issues like these, a clearer picture of the label's identity emerged.

A particularly clear moment came in comparing ECM's New Series releases of classical material to the same material found on other labels where less attention is paid to the clarity of sound. Equally, in the jazz realm, comparisons between recordings by pianist Keith Jarrett's American Quartet of the 1970s on Impulse! and ECM helped create a clear distinction. One may prefer the performances by the quartet on Impulse!, but it's difficult to deny that the ECM recordings sound better.

Another distinguishing characteristic that not only defines the label, but also provides a link between the New Series and regular series, is that even with the classical recordings, Manfred Eicher is looking for the single best performance, as opposed to using digital editing software like ProTools to piece together the "perfect" performance from a series of different takes.

A common thread that emerged throughout the weekend was that there can be great power in silence. The power of nuance can be just as moving as the viscerally frenetic. Last, the very fact that ECM now records in a number of different studios and church halls (not to mention live concert venues) with a variety of engineers would lay waste to any claim of a single specific approach.

Tomasz Stańko Quartet

An afternoon double-bill of Polish trumpeter Tomasz Stanko's quartet and American woodwind multi- instrumentalist Charles Lloyd's quartet brought a strong close to the ECM theme of the 2007 Portland Jazz Festival by presenting two groups that couldn't be more different—yet, underneath it all, shared more in common than one might think.

Over the past five years, beginning with Soul of Things (ECM, 2002), Stanko's group of young Polish players has shown remarkable growth. With each successive album—Suspended Night (ECM, 2004) and Lontano (ECM, 2006)—pianist Marcin Wasilewski, bassist Slawomir Kurkiewicz and drummer Michel Miskiewicz have become more intimately in tune with themselves and Stanko, and more capable of approaching the trumpeter's music with greater freedom. Lontano was their most liberated effort yet; over half the album consisted of three lengthy spontaneous explorations.

While the group's performance was focused on material from Lontano and there was plenty of freedom in evidence, the quartet grooved harder than on record. The music began in abstraction, but ultimately found its way into a groove not unlike that of Miles Davis' classic "All Blues." Still, despite firm pulses throughout most of the set, the growth which was evident on the record has been realized to an even greater extent now, fifteen months and many performances later.

Wasilewski has begun shedding influences, once worn on his sleeve but now subsumed within an emerging, more personal voice. Comparing Wasilewski with Diego Ramirez (who performed the previous day), he manifests a greater maturity, and the mark of a pianist with nothing to prove. Kurkiewicz and Miskiewicz also share this kind of confidence. In the early days of Soul of Things, the bassist and drummer more commonly assumed a support role. Now they're taking increasing liberties with their solo opportunities, and the overall feeling is that this is now a group of equals.


comments powered by Disqus

More Articles

Read Vorcza at Nectar's Live Reviews Vorcza at Nectar's
by Doug Collette
Published: January 20, 2018
Read Rossano Sportiello Trio at The Jazz Corner Live Reviews Rossano Sportiello Trio at The Jazz Corner
by Martin McFie
Published: January 20, 2018
Read Jazztopad 2017: Concerts In Living Rooms Live Reviews Jazztopad 2017: Concerts In Living Rooms
by Martin Longley
Published: January 17, 2018
Read Lean On Me: José James Celebrates Bill Withers @ NYC Winter Jazzfest Live Reviews Lean On Me: José James Celebrates Bill Withers @ NYC...
by Dan Bilawsky
Published: January 15, 2018
Read Carl Bartlett, Jr. at Jazz At Kitano Live Reviews Carl Bartlett, Jr. at Jazz At Kitano
by Keith Henry Brown
Published: January 13, 2018
Read Kurt Rosenwinkel at Chris’ Jazz Café Live Reviews Kurt Rosenwinkel at Chris’ Jazz Café
by Victor L. Schermer
Published: January 2, 2018
Read "Ostrava Days 2017" Live Reviews Ostrava Days 2017
by Martin Longley
Published: November 23, 2017
Read "Yoko Miwa Trio at Scullers" Live Reviews Yoko Miwa Trio at Scullers
by Doug Hall
Published: November 3, 2017
Read "Vorcza at Nectar's" Live Reviews Vorcza at Nectar's
by Doug Collette
Published: January 20, 2018
Read "Kurt Rosenwinkel at Chris’ Jazz Café" Live Reviews Kurt Rosenwinkel at Chris’ Jazz Café
by Victor L. Schermer
Published: January 2, 2018