Philly Pops Orchestra Revisits "The Stage Door Canteen"
Peter Nero, Artistic Director Lynn Roberts
, featured vocalist
The Kimmel Center for the Performing Arts
March 27, 2010
Why a concert review of the popular music of World War II on a jazz-focused website? The very question suggests how misguided it can be to separate jazz from its past. Many of the standards that jazz groups play today come from this period. And nearly all of the innovators of modern jazzDizzy Gillespie
, Dexter Gordon
, John Coltrane
, Anita O'Day
, Stan Getz
, J.J. Johnson
, to name but a fewcut their teeth in the swing bands of the period. The big bands of 1936-1945 (the period represented in this concert) were inherently jazz and blues-based, and brought the jazz idiom into the popular culture in an unprecedented way, providing the morale and respite that sustained America and England through five devastating years of World War II. There has never been the same close relationship between music and the spirit of the nation as what prevailed between the big bands and what Tom Brokaw has called "The Greatest Generation." Jazz itself has benefited ever since though, unlike the war years, it can no longer claim to be virtually synonymous with popular music.
"The Stage Door Canteen" at the Kimmel Center featuring big band vocalist Lynn Robertswho sang with the bands of Benny Goodman
, Harry James, Jimmy and Tommy Dorsey
(with whom she once shared the stage of New York City's Paramount Theatre with Frank Sinatra
and Buddy Rich
)served as testimony to the beauty, sentiment, and flair of the music that carried a generation through a world war. Pops Music Director Peter Nero made sure that the event had all the right ingredients: excellent selection of songs; spot-on arrangements based on the originals but up-scaled for orchestra; a sense of nostalgia with a modern feel; and the still-powerful vocal chords and disciplined renditions of Lynn Roberts after more than six decades of touring and recording with the big bands.
Adding to festive and vibrant program was a re-creation of the Andrews Sisters by three women of the Voices of the Pops. Wearing soldiers' caps and capturing the playful cat-like mannerisms of the popular vocal trio, they showed how much has changed musically and culturally since then. Roberts, by contrast, wore present-day trendy outfits, which she changed from white to black during the intermission (as if to symbolize the shift in public sentiment from excitement to grief as the war dragged on). The concert reached a climax with the anthems of the U.S. Armed Forces, with service men and veterans in the audience asked to stand when their specific anthem was played. The only disappointment was the scarcity of younger soldiers in the audience, and a dearth of women and African-Americans who served so nobly during WW II, not to mention Korea, Vietnam, the Gulf, and Iraq. (This concern will be addressed in the form of a "social commentary" at the end of the review. The issues stirred up in this reviewer upon reflection on what was otherwise an occasion of grandeur and delight are of such significance as to deserve special attention.)
The concert began with the Count Basie arrangement of Gershwin's "Strike Up the Band," augmented superbly for full orchestra. Ron Kerber delivered a lively tenor sax solo with shades of the great Paul Quinichette
. Lynn Roberts then sang Jimmy McHugh's "Sunny Side of the Street" and World War II favorite, "We Mustn't Say Goodbye," with the sweetness of the vocalists of the time, especially her stated idol, Helen Forrest
. The mock "Andrews Sisters" delivered "Bei Mir Bist du Schoen" with panache. Kenny Brader spun a terrific trumpet solo with a full, melting Harry James sound on the James' hit "I Don't Want to Walk without You." (The solo improvisations throughout were superbly executed.) These nostalgic songs were then given an exclamation point by "Times Square," a rocking dance number from Leonard Bernstein's first musical, On the Town
. Following two Lynn Roberts vocals, "I Left My Heart at the Stage Door Canteen" and "I'll Be With You in Apple Blossom Time," Nero displayed his piano mastery with his typical pyrotechnics and classical music references on Jerome Kern's/Dorothy Fields' "Pick Yourself Up," written for and recorded by Fred Astaire in 1936a Depression era song revived by Nat "King" Cole
and, as President Obama reminded us by quoting the song's lyrics in his Inaugural address, very appropriate for our own times. A danceable Glenn Miller
fox trot version of "Moonlight Serenade" was followed by Harry James
' version of Harry Warren's "You'll Never Know How Much I Love You."