All About Jazz needs your help and we have a deal. Contribute $20 (or more) and we'll hide those six pesky Google ads that appear on every page for a full year! You'll also fund website expansion.


I want to help

424

Paul Motian: I Have the Room Above Her & Motian in Tokio

By
Published:
Sign in to view read count
Paul Motian
I Have the Room Above Her
ECM Records
2005

I Have the Room Above Her is an odd title choice, considering the title track is one of only two songs that drummer Paul Motian didn't write himself. Maybe Motian's too modest to go with one of his own titles, but judging by the strength of his original songs, he needn't be. (Incidentally, the aforementioned Kern-Hammerstein tune and Monk's "Dreamland are the weakest tracks; these Joe Lovano-centered pieces, ballads both, seemed a bit florid and lethargic.)

Motian's compositions are like his drum playing—sparse, often delicate, seamless and never overstated. The stand-out "Shadows provides what the title implies: it's dark, lingering, carefully shaded. The songs don't sound like they were written by a drummer and that's a good thing. Motian knows when to fall back, as if he's reluctant to get in the way of either Lovano or guitarist Bill Frisell. And it's a remarkably flash-free, egoless venture; no one has anything to prove. The opener "Osmosis Part III is so subtle it's almost sleepy, an appropriate setting-of-the-tone for the rest of the disc.

"Osmosis Part I surfaces five tracks after "Part III , in the spirit of this non-linear project, which—while hardly "free time—isn't restrained by the strictures of rigid post-bop forms. Here Frisell lays counter textures (though never counterintuitive) underneath Lovano's saxophone. Alternately delicate and rollicking, fragmented and fluid: Frisell works his instrument like Motian engages his ride cymbal.

Bill Frisell/Joe Lovano/Paul Motian
Motian In Tokio
JMT-Winter & Winter
Release 1991; Reissued 2004

The same trio does quite a bit of engaging on the recently reissued Motian In Tokio from 1991. Consisting mostly of Motian compositions, the program serves as a thematic link to the trio's current work, while also holding its own nicely. Frisell's sound is heavier and more ethereal, the drums more forceful. The disc—handsomely bound in paperboard—looks like a small sketchbook, but sounds much bigger, as large as life.

I Have the Room Above Her

Tracks: Osmosis, Pt. III; Sketches; Odd Man; Shadows; I Have the Room Above Her; Osmosis, Pt. I; Dance; Harmony; The Riot Act; The Bag Man; One in Three; Dreamland.

Personnel: Bill Frisell: (guitar); Joe Lovano: (tenor saxophone); Paul Motian: (drums)

In Tokio

Tracks: From Time to Time; Shakalaka; Kathelin Gray; The Hoax; Mumbo Jumbo; Birdsong I; Mode VI; Two Women from Padua; It Is; Birdsong II.

Personnel: Bill Frisell: guitar; Joe Lovano: tenor saxophone; Paul Motian: drums.


Shop For Jazz

CD/LP/Track Review
Profiles
Extended Analysis
Profiles
Extended Analysis
Jazz Poetry
Interviews
Read more articles
ECM Recordings
ECM Recordings
ECM Records
2014
buy
[no cover]
Paul Motian
Soul Note
2013
buy
Paul Motian: Jack of Clubs
Paul Motian: Jack of...
Soul Note
2013
buy
Paul Motian: Paul Motian (Old & New Masters Edition)
Paul Motian: Paul...
ECM Records
2013
buy
The Windmills Of Your Mind
The Windmills Of Your...
Winter & Winter
2011
buy
Paul Motian Trio 2000 + Two: Live at the Village Vanguard, Volume lll
Paul Motian Trio 2000...

2011
buy
Bill Frisell Bill Frisell
guitar
Joe Lovano Joe Lovano
saxophone
Enrico Rava Enrico Rava
trumpet
Don Cherry Don Cherry
trumpet
Kenny Wheeler Kenny Wheeler
trumpet
Fred Hersch Fred Hersch
piano

Post a comment

comments powered by Disqus

Join the staff. Writers Wanted!

Develop a column, write album reviews, cover live shows, or conduct interviews.