In the world of 1950s hard bop, there is no more prominent bassist than Paul Chambers
. The man was absolutely everywhere.
He shows up on an astonishing number of jazz classics, including Miles Davis
' Kind of Blue
, John Coltrane
's Giant Steps
, Thelonious Monk
's Brilliant Corners
, Sonny Rollins
' Tenor Madness
and Oliver Nelson
's The Blues and the Abstract Truth
. He was a sideman on 200 albums from the '50s and '60s.
So it's natural to associate Chambers with a certain kind of jazzconventional bop with adventurous soloists, always the supporting rhythm man. Bass on Top
turns that convention on its headand it's not an easy listen.
Chambers leads on every tune, playing melody and long solos. Credit the bassman for having the guts to try something very different, and Blue Note for supporting an experiment that surely wasn't very commercial.
But I'm not a fan of Bass on Top. I admire the idea, but not the reality.
Maybe it's my ears. I have trouble hearing all those low notes. And maybe it's just an old prejudice. Bass on Top
is so far from what I'm used to hearing. I recognize what Chambers is doingplaying the bass as if it were a sax or trumpet. But it feels foreign. I've listened several times, but I just can't connect. The songs are very familiar, but the instrumentation is not.
It's not all negative. The opening number, Jerome Kern's "Yesterdays," is actually moving. It starts almost like chamber music, with Chambers playing with a bow, a long, melancholy statement of the melody. It's beautiful. Then it moves into standard jazz improvisation, and I feel lost at sea with the long, heavy bass solo.
Chambers uses the bow again on Miles Davis' "The Theme." Again, the bass solos leave me cold, but Kenny Burrell
's guitar and Hank Jones
' piano play more prominent roles, and drummer Art Taylor playfully trades phrases with Chambers. It's joyful. In fact, Burrell is, for me, the album's biggest selling point. He never disappoints.
But whether it's a toe-tapper like Charlie Parker
's "Chasin' the Bird" or the old chestnut "Dear Old Stockholm," I just can't warm up to those long bass solos. The band is terrific. The song selection is top-notch. The experiment is absolutely worthy. But the execution leaves me cold.
Rating: 3 stars (out of 5)
Availability: Easy to find
Cost: Around $5 used