It's the jazz equivalent of finding a Van Gogh or a Ming vase in the attic: the discovery of a complete, perfectly-recorded 1964 concert by one of the music's greatest virtuoso solo pianists. In the beginning was Art Tatum
. Then came Oscar Peterson
. Finallyand in many ways the most interesting of the holy trinityErroll Garner
Garner was famed for his long, rambling introductions. In a section of the liner notes jazz historian Professor Robin D. G. Kelley writes, "His signature introductions left audiencesnot to mention his own sidemenin great anticipation of what was to come. He was prone to meandering, rubato introductions that initially bear little resemblance to the song or the key, before suddenly leaping into the melody."
They have to be heard to be believed andto be honestcan become irritating. Many modern listeners may find themselves longing for the "less is more" approach to jazz piano taken by the likes of Ahmad Jamal
. But Garner was at his peak for this midnight concert before an audience of 2,000 in the Royal Concertgebouw, Amsterdam, on November 7, 1964.
Before it got underway, drummer Kelly Martin nervously asked bassist Eddie Calhoun
about the set list for the night. "Man, I can't tell you nothing," said Calhoun. "We just get up there and play. I don't know what this cat is going to do."
In the event, as Professor Kelly puts it, the trio "rocked the 76-year-old concert hall like there was no tomorrow."
Writing in The New Yorker
, critic Whitney Balliett said, "Garner's appeal stems from his style which is rococo and eccentric, and from the easily accessible flash, geniality, and warmth that continually propel it."
Those words conjure up a magical age when jazz was still unfolding, rock was yet to be born and Garner's Concert By The Sea
was the cornerstone of any self-respecting record collection. That classic album now has a worthy companion, blessed with all the aids of modern technology. A collector would have difficulty choosing between them.
The program is pretty typical, most of it standards, kicking off with "Where Or When" and continuing with Cole Porter's "Easy To Love." There's "On Green Dolphin Street" from 1947, composed for a film, which Miles Davis
converted into a jazz classic. More interesting are Garner's versions of "Cheek To Cheek" and "My Funny Valentine," in which he doffs his cap to what was then the avant-garde
and the swinger "Gipsy In My Soul," which he made his very own.
In Garner's version of "Laura," Christian Sands, another contributor to the copious liner notes, hears echoes ofbelieve it or notCecil Taylor
. More plausibly, he highlights Garner's examination of his stride roots in "When Your Lover Has Gone."
In each number the maestro gives you something different to get your teeth into. It's what his particular genius was all about and it is truly marvellous to be reminded of it again.
Where Or When; Easy To Love; On Green Dolphin Street; Theme From “A New Kind Of Love” (All Yours); Night And Day; Cheek To Cheek; My Funny Valentine; Gipsy In My Soul; That Amsterdam Swing; Over The Rainbow; What Is This Thing Called Love; Laura; When Your Lover Has Gone; No More Shadows; ‘S Wonderful; Thanks For The Memory.
Erroll Garner: piano; Eddie Calhoun: bass; Kelly Martin: drums.