All About Jazz

Home » Articles » CD/LP/Track Review

1

Phil Haynes: My Favorite Things (1960-1969)

Geno Thackara By

Sign in to view read count
For some reason, cover songs almost always seem to come across more jokey in folk/bluegrass mode than any other. There's just a certain innate good humor in upbeat romps with acoustic string instruments, especially so when the treatment is applied to formerly loud rock and roll songs. Perhaps it also feels that way because such pieces so often serve as cute one-off novelties in an otherwise straightfoward set. Drummer Phil Haynes and his "freewheeling jazz-grass string band" here, on the other hand, generally avoid twangy sounds—the lineup is cello/guitar/bass/drums—and never treat this set of beloved material with less than full sincerity.

That's not to say My Favorite Things (1960-1969) doesn't have its share of humor. There are few performers who can avoid laughs with James Brown's "Sex Machine," and they even straight-facedly render the Star Trek theme in jaunty technicolor glory. Still, those moments only reinforce the clear sense of fun and camaraderie that runs throughout the set. The crew reworks their chosen chestnuts, sometimes quite radically, always with affection and respect.

Haynes provides a nimble foundation behind the skins, though Jim Yanda's guitar work and the deep-toned cello of Hank Roberts serve more as the in-front leads with impressively versatile picking and bowing. Roberts has quite a range of his own in handling the occasional vocal duties, though at least half the time, one of their instruments takes the lead line and stands in for the words (which are sometimes unnecessary when the melodies get mutated anyway). It feels unfair not to single out Drew Gress for praise as well, though he primarily does his job by not standing out—he and Haynes make a rhythm unit whose strength rests in tight and non-flashy interplay.

The arrangements through this double-disc set wander far and wide, making the results inevitably somewhat hit-and-miss (if interestingly so). The tie-dye haze of "California Dreaming" and "Surfer Girl" gets slowed down almost to avant-garde range. Otis Redding's "Respect" loses the verses in favor of a sort of jazzy barn dance. An eclectic Beatles mini-suite kicks off the second disc by concisely summarizing both the strengths and flaws of the album as a whole. Two bright portions of "Here Comes the Sun" make a sweet and charming highlight; an enervating slow drag through "Hey Jude," not so much.

With the band not quite being content with rock and pop chestnuts, a dose of John Coltrane takes the late stretch from quasi-humorous to earnestly spiritual. You can hardly aim much higher than A Love Supreme (Impulse!, 1964), and from the affectionate and understated "Resolution" motif to a spoken poem adapted from Trane's own devotional, this treatment manages to be just different and humble enough to stand on its own. They've still impressively saved the best for last; Roberts' expressive bowing wrings emotional shades out of "Both Sides Now" as eloquently as Joni Mitchell ever has herself. The set has some crazy ups and downs, but it's these simply beautiful moments that linger most when it's over.

Track Listing: CD1: Little Wing; Purple Haze; Fire; Do You Know the Way to San Jose; Surfer Girl; Walk On By; California Dreaming; What's Going On; R.E.S.P.E.C.T.; Touch Me; People Are Strange; Come Together; What a Wonderful World. CD2: Here Comes the Sun; And I Love Her; Let It Be; Mother Nature's Son; Hey Jude; Here Comes the Sun; Cracker Speak; Sex Machine; Star Trek; Somewhere; A Love Supreme; Resolution; My Favorite Things; Both Sides Now.

Personnel: Hank Roberts: cello, vocals; Jim Yanda: guitar; Drew Gress: bass; Phil Haynes: drums.

Title: My Favorite Things (1960-1969) | Year Released: 2018 | Record Label: Corner Store Jazz

Tags

Related Video

comments powered by Disqus

Shop Music & Tickets

Click any of the store links below and you'll support All About Jazz in the process. Learn how.

Little Wing

Little Wing

Phil Haynes
My Favorite Things (1960-1969)

El-Smoke

El-Smoke

Phil Haynes
Settings for Three

Kabuki

Kabuki

Phil Haynes
Sanctuary

CD/LP/Track Review
Extended Analysis
Read more articles
My Favorite Things (1960-1969)

My Favorite Things...

Corner Store Jazz
2018

buy
Settings for Three

Settings for Three

CornerStoreJazz
2018

buy
Sanctuary

Sanctuary

Self Produced
2016

buy
Sanctuary

Sanctuary

Self Produced
2015

buy
In Concert

In Concert

Self Produced
2015

buy

Related Articles

Read Out in the Open CD/LP/Track Review
Out in the Open
by Jack Bowers
Published: November 16, 2018
Read Contemporary Chaos Practices CD/LP/Track Review
Contemporary Chaos Practices
by Don Phipps
Published: November 16, 2018
Read Changed Beings CD/LP/Track Review
Changed Beings
by Chris May
Published: November 16, 2018
Read We Must Mustn't We CD/LP/Track Review
We Must Mustn't We
by John Sharpe
Published: November 16, 2018
Read Two Infinitudes; The One You "see" and the One That Is You. CD/LP/Track Review
Two Infinitudes; The One You "see" and the One...
by Glenn Astarita
Published: November 16, 2018
Read Always Forward CD/LP/Track Review
Always Forward
by Jack Bowers
Published: November 15, 2018
Read "Intimate Ella - A Tribute to Ella Fitzgerald" CD/LP/Track Review Intimate Ella - A Tribute to Ella Fitzgerald
by Nicholas F. Mondello
Published: February 2, 2018
Read "Formidable" CD/LP/Track Review Formidable
by Victor L. Schermer
Published: November 24, 2017
Read "with whom you can be who you are" CD/LP/Track Review with whom you can be who you are
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: September 21, 2018
Read "Traveler" CD/LP/Track Review Traveler
by Mark Sullivan
Published: May 14, 2018
Read "Please Advise" CD/LP/Track Review Please Advise
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: March 5, 2018
Read "Up All Night" CD/LP/Track Review Up All Night
by Doug Collette
Published: January 1, 2018