207

Gentle Giant: Live in Santa Monica 1975

John Kelman By

Sign in to view read count
Gentle Giant: Live in Santa Monica 1975 With DRT's 2005 35th Anniversary remasters of much of Gentle Giant's back studio catalog, the opportunity to hear this remarkable 1970s progressive rock band in performance from back in the day is being embraced by a new group of fans—many who were too young (if even born) at the time.



Live in Santa Monica 1975 comes with a warning, however: while a legitimate commercial release, it's more bootleg in quality. In some spots the quality is thin, but listenable and clear; elsewhere the sound is muddy; some songs begin abruptly and a few bars in; and two aborted takes of "For Nobody, from a 1977 performance, are curiously appended to flesh the disc out to a still spare forty-four minutes.



It's a safe bet that Santa Monica is not a good entry point for Giant novices, but for existing (and, perhaps, pathological) fans there are a number of things to recommend.



First, by this time keyboardist/multi-instrumentalist Kerry Minnear—always less-than-confident about his singing—had sworn off lead vocals in performance, making it necessary for Derek Shulman to assume all lead vocals outside of the studio. And while Shulman would sing "Experience, from In a Glass House (1973) on the group's commercial live release Playing the Fool (1977), here fans get the rare opportunity to hear Minnear sing lead vocals during the first half of the song.



Second, Giant was tackling some of its back catalog by turning it into medleys. Here, unlike Playing the Fool, there's the opportunity to hear "Advent of Panurge, from Octopus (1972), and "Experience as stand-alone songs. And, for ardent Giant fans, that alone is worth the price of admission.



Sound quality aside, it's an energetic performance. "Cogs in Cogs, from The Power and the Glory (1974)—despite entering a few seconds in, and with tape wow and flutter causing some annoyance—exemplifies much of what defined Gentle Giant: complex material filled with rich counterpoint that, nevertheless (and more than many of its peers), rocks hard.



Giant's studio releases—in particular the early ones before drummer John Weathers joined—were always a tad rarefied, but live rearrangements always added a lot more grit to the mix. The Power and the Glory's "Proclamation is even more visceral and funky than the version on Playing the Fool. Another misstep of Santa Monica, however, is that "Proclamation segues into an uncredited version of the folkloric-meets-pseudo-classicism-meets Caribbean rhythms of "Funny Ways.



The two aborted runs at "For Nobody, from Missing Piece (1977) are for archivists only, being of extremely poor sonic quality. Still, for Giant enthusiasts who want to hear how this group continually reinvented its shows by melding different pieces together, and managed to achieve the near-impossible—move from passage-to-passage with seamless instrument changes that ranged from conventional rock instruments to cello, violin, trumpet, saxophone, recorders and more—Live in Santa Monica 1975 is a flawed, but unique window into this innovative group in its heyday.


Track Listing: Cogs in Cogs; Proclamation; Experience; So Sincere; Advent of Panurge; For Nobody #1; For Nobody #2.

Personnel: Derek Shulman: vocals, alto saxophone, descant recorder, bass, percussion; Ray Shulman: bass, violin, acoustic guitar, descant recorder, trumpet, vocals, percussion; Kerry Minnear: all keyboards, cello, vibes, tenor recorder, vocals, percussion; Gary Green: electric, acoustic and twelve-string guitars, alto and descant recorders, vocals, percussion; John Weathers: drums, vibes, tambour, vocals, percussion.

Year Released: 2007 | Record Label: Glasshouse Records | Style: Fusion/Progressive Rock


Shop

More Articles

Read A Dark and Stormy Day CD/LP/Track Review A Dark and Stormy Day
by Dave Wayne
Published: March 1, 2017
Read Pocono Git-Down CD/LP/Track Review Pocono Git-Down
by Edward Blanco
Published: March 1, 2017
Read Rímur CD/LP/Track Review Rímur
by Henning Bolte
Published: March 1, 2017
Read Schönbrunn CD/LP/Track Review Schönbrunn
by Tyran Grillo
Published: March 1, 2017
Read Northern Adventures CD/LP/Track Review Northern Adventures
by Jack Bowers
Published: February 28, 2017
Read Collider CD/LP/Track Review Collider
by John Sharpe
Published: February 28, 2017
Read "Oddara" CD/LP/Track Review Oddara
by James Nadal
Published: October 15, 2016
Read "Montréal" CD/LP/Track Review Montréal
by Roger Farbey
Published: February 11, 2017
Read "Need to Bring Out Love" CD/LP/Track Review Need to Bring Out Love
by Jack Bowers
Published: April 5, 2016
Read "Rumi Songs" CD/LP/Track Review Rumi Songs
by Mark Sullivan
Published: September 4, 2016
Read "Continuum" CD/LP/Track Review Continuum
by Karl Ackermann
Published: March 31, 2016
Read "Mujo" CD/LP/Track Review Mujo
by John Sharpe
Published: July 16, 2016

Post a comment

comments powered by Disqus

Sponsor: Jazz Near You | GET IT  

Support our sponsor

Support All About Jazz's Future

We need your help and we have a deal. Contribute $20 and we'll hide the six Google ads that appear on every page for a full year!

Buy it!