All About Jazz

Home » Articles » Extended Analysis

618

John Coltrane: John Coltrane: Live at Birdland

C. Michael Bailey By

Sign in to view read count
John Coltrane
Live at Birdland
MCA/Impulse! 33109
1963

In the early morning of Sunday, September 15, 1963, a gaggle of malcontents planted 12 sticks of dynamite in a window well outside the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama. The dynamite exploded eight hours later killing Denise McNair, 11, and Cynthia Wesley, Carole Robertson and Addie Mae Collins, all 14, in the process galvanizing the Civil Rights Movement. Three months later, on November 18, 1963, John Coltrane stepped up to the microphone in fabled Englewood, NJ studio of one Rudy Van Gelder and over a McCoy Tyner Tremolo, blew his searing and definitive statement on the subject of the bombing— "Alabama." "Alabama" is the single most provocative piece on what is considered one of the most well rounded John Coltrane live recordings Coltrane Live at Birdland. The piece is most certainly why this Coltrane live recording was chosen for this series.

The odd thing is that "Alabama" and its sister piece "Your Lady" (also recorded in Englewood) are not even live recordings and the live recordings included on Coltrane Live At Birdland are not all that were recorded on October 8, 1963. Like many jazz recordings (particularly live jazz recordings) Coltrane Live at Birdland is actually a patchwork of recording events. The original release was comprised of 5 pieces, three recording in the club on October 8, 1963 ("Afro-Blue," "I Want to Talk About You," and "The Promise") and the remaining two ("Alabama" and "Your Lady") a little over a month later. The original vinyl LP was released in January 1964. The first compact disc release was 1992. The original recording was augmented with an additional song ("Vilia" recorded in Englewood, March 6, 1963) and re-released in 1996. Why the original recording was not re-released with all of the live pieces (versions of "Rockin ["Tranin' In"]," "Mr. P.C.," and "Lonnie's Lament") remains a bit of a mystery.

All of this begs the question- How are we to consider Coltrane Live At Birdland one of the best live jazz recordings? I suspect that we must forgive the imperfections of the disc (or those of the writer's premise) and accept the release as a complete work of art as we do other incomplete or otherwise imperfect endeavors such as Coleridge's Kubla Khan and Mozart's Requiem. In that, we might suspend our compulsive dependency on by-the-letter definition and turn our attention to the important thing, the music.

Coltrane Live at Birdland displays Coltrane's most famous quartet: McCoy Tyner on piano, Jimmy Garrison on bass and the thermonuclear Elvin Jones on drums. With respect to the saxophonist's constantly evolving style, Coltrane Live at Birdland falls squarely between Ballads and A Love Supreme and on those Birdland dates, John Coltrane does sound like he is passing through. The Mongo Santamaria standard "Afro-Blue" was long a Coltrane concert favorite. The 10-minute performance here is thought to be his best and most accessible performance of this piece. Elvin Jones's drumming is at its bombastic densest with great emphasis on the cymbals. The Billy Eckstein composition, "I Want to Talk About You" like "Afro-Blue" was a favorite performance piece for Coltrane and he recorded it more than ten times. Here, the piece has a riveting solo Coltrane coda giving light for things to come.

Down Beat critic John McDonough in his review of the last recorded public appearance of the tenor saxophonist (The Olatunji Concert: The Last Live Recording— Impulse! 314 589 120) echoed another critic in touting Coltrane as "Jazz's most boring genius." Coltrane's later music largely leaves me with the same feeling. I far prefer his Atlantic Hard Bop days when he was just beginning to transform jazz as Charlie Parker had done the generation before and before his vision reached light speed and his invention, critical mass. However, let there be no mistake. If the listener wishes to hear the master in transition, look no further than Coltrane Live at Birdland.


The Ten Best Live Jazz Recordings

















#1
At The Village
Vanguard


Bill Evans Trio (1961)



#6
At The Village
Vanguard


Sonny Rollins (1957)





#2
At The Village
Vanguard


John Coltrane (1961)



#7
At Birdland


John Coltrane (1963)





#3
At The
Plugged Nickel


Miles Davis (1965)



#8
Smokin' At The
Half Note


Wynton Kelly (1965)





#4
At Antibes


Charles Mingus (1960)



#9
Concert
By The Sea


Errol Garner (1955)





#5
At Newport
1956


Duke Ellington (1956)



#10
At Massey Hall


The Quintet (1953)



#11 - The Best of the Rest ...


Title: John Coltrane: Live at Birdland | Year Released: 2005 | Record Label: Impulse!

Tags

comments powered by Disqus

Related Articles

Read The Vintage Years 1970 - 1991 Extended Analysis
The Vintage Years 1970 - 1991
by John Kelman
Published: June 23, 2018
Read Trouble No More - The Bootleg Series Vol. 13 / 1979-1981 Extended Analysis
Trouble No More - The Bootleg Series Vol. 13 / 1979-1981
by Doug Collette
Published: November 19, 2017
Read Love, Gloom, Cash, Love Extended Analysis
Love, Gloom, Cash, Love
by Patrick Burnette
Published: October 21, 2017
Read Motel Shot: Expanded Edition Extended Analysis
Motel Shot: Expanded Edition
by Doug Collette
Published: July 16, 2017
Read Long Strange Trip: The Untold Story of the Grateful Dead Motion Picture Soundtrack Extended Analysis
Long Strange Trip: The Untold Story of the Grateful Dead...
by Doug Collette
Published: July 14, 2017
Read Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band 50th Anniversary Super Deluxe  Edition Extended Analysis
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band 50th...
by Doug Collette
Published: May 27, 2017
Read "Trouble No More - The Bootleg Series Vol. 13 / 1979-1981" Extended Analysis Trouble No More - The Bootleg Series Vol. 13 / 1979-1981
by Doug Collette
Published: November 19, 2017
Read "Motel Shot: Expanded Edition" Extended Analysis Motel Shot: Expanded Edition
by Doug Collette
Published: July 16, 2017
Read "Love, Gloom, Cash, Love" Extended Analysis Love, Gloom, Cash, Love
by Patrick Burnette
Published: October 21, 2017
Read "The Vintage Years 1970 - 1991" Extended Analysis The Vintage Years 1970 - 1991
by John Kelman
Published: June 23, 2018
Read "John Mayall: In The Pocket at 84" SoCal Jazz John Mayall: In The Pocket at 84
by Jim Worsley
Published: March 11, 2018
Read "The Nels Cline 4 At Higher Ground" Live Reviews The Nels Cline 4 At Higher Ground
by Doug Collette
Published: July 8, 2018
Read "Bill Anschell: Curiosity and Invention" Interviews Bill Anschell: Curiosity and Invention
by Paul Rauch
Published: November 9, 2017
Read "Meet Geri St. Clair" Out and About: The Super Fans Meet Geri St. Clair
by Tessa Souter and Andrea Wolper
Published: November 6, 2017