Sophisticated Giant: The Life and Legacy of Dexter Gordon
ISBN: #9780520280649 University of California Press
Maxine Gordon was the last of Dexter Gordon's several wives and she has written a biography of Gordon, a task with which he charged her before he died in 1990. The saxophonist had actually done some writing on an autobiography before he died and Maxine Gordon was able to use this material in her book. But, while he had written about most of his life, he wrote nothing about the 1950s, a period that he would not talk or write about. Her extensive research illuminates that decade as well as most of the other phases of this well-known jazz musician's life.
Gordon's was both a charmed and a difficult life. He was born into an accomplished family and was a gifted musician-competent enough to join Lionel Hampton
's band on the road when he was 17 years old. He was also drawn to drugs early and addiction remained a part of his life until the 1970s. At least, I think that marked the end of his use, but I'm not positive. That's because the book makes clear the chronology of his drug use, his incarcerations, being "clean," and family life in some phases of his life, but in other times, less so. The author seems to have set herself up in a bit of a cleft stick. On one hand, she says that her intent is not to soft-peddle the rougher details of his life. On the other hand, Maxine Gordon is very invested in showing us Dexter's optimistic nature and the fact that several times he arose, phoenix-like, from events that others would not have been able to transcend.
The author's approach toward Dexter's battle with drugs is presented in as low-key a way as possible; to drain it of any moral judgmentalism. Her analysis of the draconian drug laws of California in the '40s and '50s shows what a trap these were for any addict and particularly so for the black jazz community of Los Angeles.
Maxine Gordon's approach to the difficult relationships in Dexter's life is similarly low-key; almost off-handed. She has a child by trumpeter Woody Shaw
, who often played with Dexter. She and Shaw parted company and she began a relationship with Gordon. I'm not looking for dirt, but I would like to hear more about the emotional aspect of these shifting relationships. She wraps up their decision to get married in two sentences: "Looking back, it seems so simple, but this was not an easy decision. It was fraught with drama, anger and jazz gossip." I think it's the author's responsibility to give the reader a fuller sense of the human dimension of the process.
The same might be said about her approach to Dexter's relationship with previous wives and children. No doubt it might have been tricky for Maxine Gordon to win the cooperation of the families with whom he spent so little time. But I do think that some attempt at outreach and recording the results of those attempts is a job that a biographer should undertake. It stands to reason that this would help create a more dimensional portrait of the protagonist of this story. It feels like this was sacrificed in the name of "uplift."
Apart from this, I have no other major issue with the book. The writing is clear and we are moved swiftly and chronologically through the phases of an eventful life.
There is no attempt at musical analysis, per se, but there is a very interesting analysis of the relationship between the jazz musician, the musician's union and the recording companies. One section shows clearly that the settlements of the two recording bans instituted by the musician's union during the 1940s did not redound to the financial benefit of jazz musicians. The tenacity of jazz musicians despite the continually tenuous financial prospects is given its rightful due here. This shared experience of continuing to advance the music in the face of adversity built a tremendous sense of community among the musicians and Maxine Gordon makes a point of showing how important it was for Dexter to be a member of this community. He was a beloved comrade, clearly always generous in acknowledging the help of other musicians and in providing gigs for others when he could.