James Hurt and Marc Cary at The Jazz Gallery, 3/14/02

AAJ Staff By

Sign in to view read count
It’s clichéd to say, perhaps, but after hearing this show one could simply not avoid the conclusion that this duo concert (at The Jazz Gallery) was an inevitable “meeting of the minds.” There was of course the auspice of this prior to even hearing them play together- however even the facts could not have predicted the transcendent creativity of this evening.

Going into it, the facts were that we knew that James Hurt and Marc Cary were coming from similar places aesthetically in the music and in their approach to playing the piano. They are both pushing the agenda for, in generic terms, a more patently percussive, earthier (for lack of a better word), and unabashedly piano-centric music. Moreover, they are alike in that they both take as much influence from traditional music forms like African drums or Middle Eastern music as from the Jazz tradition itself. Compare Hurt's Dark Grooves, Mystical Rhythms and Cary’s The Antidote to see where the conceptual kinship between these cats comes clearly into play. These recorded statements are both quite unique but one will not mistake how conceptually, Hurt and Cary are drawing water from the same rich source. The emphasis on rhythm that is meted out by percussively-styled piano in the foreground, the incorporation of “ethnic” instruments, and not to mention the cosmic/universal type themes, all go to demonstrate this...
Hurt and Cary strive for similar kinds of effects and sounds at the keys as well, but the generic kinship is not as relevant here as in the broader context of conception, of their musical vision. Of course their approach to piano is embedded in their conception, and vice versa, but the differences and unique qualities of Hurt and Cary came forth in their soloing this night and revealed the truest individuality of them both.
James Hurt opened a set with a solo number and it immediately set the terms for his approach; explorative, but tense in a dramatic way. Hurt is absorbing in the sense that his approach seems very deliberate but strikes one as being richly creative at the same time. One doesn’t wait for him to make his next “bold” move as much as one senses the natural progression of a conceptual mind unfold by moment. Hurt drew on all manner of devices at the keyboard: intervallic rhythmic patterns, Tyneresque chordal crescendos, impressionistic single note suspense, and much more, but all while keeping his conception firmly intact. Hurt was eclectic in his use of the piano, but not in the way he expressed his conception through it.

In contrast to Hurt, Marc Cary showed a slightly more stylized approach to playing piano that no less betrayed invention and a keen musical vision, however. Cary was a bit less broad in his use of the piano but rhythmically was more assertive, and as proof in their duo playing it was Cary who frequently set rhythmic motifs for them to play off of. In fact, Marc Cary tended to lead in the duo situation even if this was not intended; his playing was in the foreground more often than Hurt’s, although it should be pointed out that when Hurt “raised his voice” it was typically to say something quite dramatic; indeed one of the hippest moments of this show was when Hurt began playing cascading arpeggiated chords up the whole of the keyboard with ever-rising volume over Cary’s very solid comping and groove. Hurt seemed to genuinely “hurt” the keyboard at a point, and the sheer forcefulness of this was compelling.

Not lost in this unfurling of individuality and the relative nature of each soloist was a most creative level of interaction. It wasn’t quite telepathy but this was the first ever meeting between these two and as such the communication was stronger than one should really expect. These two, as forceful and dynamic as both can be at the piano, never got in each other’s way and did their damnedest it seemed to play contrasting things that still complemented the other. There was no passive comping here- in the best duos it’s not spoonfed to the listener who’s soloing and who’s comping, and that was surely in effect here, as there was plenty of intriguing counterpoint and rhythmic variations going on.

The material Hurt and Cary played was mostly their original compositions but a couple of standards as well. For a glimpse into the state of modern Jazz piano in the 21st century, the way these two rendered “All The Things You Are” was totally revealing; the melody was abstracted, but not to a modernist’s extreme, and it was moreover totally contemporary in light of the way it seemed to negotiate the ancient with the future; it was rhythmically very DEEP, and yet it employed a full range of harmonic vocabulary including some pointed dissonance amid the generally cosmic overtones.


More Articles

Read Kneebody at Johnny Brenda's Live Reviews Kneebody at Johnny Brenda's
by Mike Jacobs
Published: April 25, 2017
Read Vossajazz 2017 Live Reviews Vossajazz 2017
by Ian Patterson
Published: April 23, 2017
Read Hermeto Pascoal at SFJAZZ Live Reviews Hermeto Pascoal at SFJAZZ
by Harry S. Pariser
Published: April 21, 2017
Read Lewis Nash and Steve Wilson at JazzNights Live Reviews Lewis Nash and Steve Wilson at JazzNights
by David A. Orthmann
Published: April 18, 2017
Read Tallinn Music Week 2017 Live Reviews Tallinn Music Week 2017
by Martin Longley
Published: April 16, 2017
Read Bergamo Jazz Festival 2017 Live Reviews Bergamo Jazz Festival 2017
by Francesco Martinelli
Published: April 14, 2017
Read "Andy Milne and Dapp Theory at SOUTH Jazz Kitchen" Live Reviews Andy Milne and Dapp Theory at SOUTH Jazz Kitchen
by Mike Jacobs
Published: May 19, 2016
Read "Brian Charette/Jim Alfredson Organ Duo at Nighttown" Live Reviews Brian Charette/Jim Alfredson Organ Duo at Nighttown
by C. Andrew Hovan
Published: October 26, 2016
Read "Brilliant Corners 2017" Live Reviews Brilliant Corners 2017
by Ian Patterson
Published: March 27, 2017
Read "Tom Griesgraber and Bert Lams at Kennett Flash" Live Reviews Tom Griesgraber and Bert Lams at Kennett Flash
by Geno Thackara
Published: September 1, 2016
Read "Abullah Ibrahim at SFJAZZ" Live Reviews Abullah Ibrahim at SFJAZZ
by Harry S. Pariser
Published: May 12, 2016

Post a comment

comments powered by Disqus


Support our sponsor

Support All About Jazz's Future

We need your help and we have a deal. Contribute $20 and we'll hide the six Google ads that appear on every page for a full year!