Jay Leonhart: Don't You Wish?

Patrick Burnette By

Sign in to view read count
Jay Leonhart: Don't You Wish?
Jay Leonhart has been active as a jazz bassist from the 1960s, and since 1983's Salamander Pie (Digital Music Productions, 1990), he has, from time to time, headlined records as that rara avis, the singer-songwriter who plays acoustic bass rather than acoustic guitar. (one example: "Goodbye, Miami" from the debut—it sounds more prescient day by day.)

Leonhart is an accomplished, fluid bassist who's appeared on gigs and records with a host of top-notch musicians. On Don't You Wish? he does the neat trick of accompanying his own vocals, aided and abetted by pianist Tomoko Ohno, who plays pleasant mainstream piano and doesn't press things when she solos. The sparse instrumentation and focus on the singer recalls albums like Joni Mitchell's'Blue (Rhino Records, 1971), but the idiom here is jazz, and its doubtful that Leonhart would compare himself as a singer with prime Mitchell. With his witty lyrics and limited vocal range, he's more reminiscent of Tom Lehrer (though more gifted vocally and less biting in his observations) and Donald Fagen (Leonart namechecks Steely Dan on a song from his debut and does sound a bit like Fagen).

Leonhart is not as polished a lyricist as Fagen or Lehrer—rhymes are sometimes fudged (he mentions "bulbs and seeds" to get an "eeds" rhyme in his song "Tulip") and rhythms are padded out with the occasional "did" or other filler. Still, props to "Tulip" for being a song about the 1600's Dutch tulip "mania" in the first place. Between "Tulip" and "Life in the Middle Ages," you'll pick up a little historical knowledge in the disc's fifty-two minutes.

Several songs unwind as sustained narratives—"Playboy Club," for instance, whose timing may be unfortunate given the current cultural climate, though the tune gently mocks Leonhart's sexual obsessions rather than the bunnies themselves. Sometimes a song tells a story so effectively that it's a bit of shock when the opening verse reappears at the end. It's like re-reading the first paragraph of a short story rather than hearing a chorus return.

Many of the songs are deeply autobiographical. In "Curtains," for instance, Leonhart counts on the listener being as worried as he is about being late to a Mel Torme gig (and, yes, he rhymes "Torme" with "delay" on that one). But a certain wry self-awareness keeps the navel- gazing from getting too ponderous, and the songs always feel like genuine self-expression rather than posing. Leonhart's led an amazing life and he wants to tell you what's he's experienced—and learned—along the way. If you don't mind the somewhat reedy vocals, you'll find much to enjoy in Don't You Wish? . Leonhart has his limits as a singer-songwriter, but his point of view is so distinctive that you're likely to forgive them by the end of the album, when the record concludes with a gentle and lovable ode to a UFO believer called "They're Coming to Get Me."

Track Listing

Playboy Club; Don't You Wish; Curtains; I Got the Blues; Tulips; Schadenfreude; Change My Occupation; Life in the Middle Ages; Missin' Rb Blues; They're Coming to Get Me.


Jay Leonhardt, bass and vocals; Tomoko Ohno, piano.

Album information

Title: Don't You Wish? | Year Released: 2018 | Record Label: Self Produced

Post a comment about this album


Shop Amazon


Antti Lotjonen Quintet East
Read Apura!
Karl Evangelista
Read McModal
Markos Chaidemenos

All About Jazz needs your support

All About Jazz & Jazz Near You were built to promote jazz music: both recorded and live events. We rely primarily on venues, festivals and musicians to promote their events through our platform. With club closures, shelter in place and an uncertain future, we've pivoted our platform to collect, promote and broadcast livestream concerts to support our jazz musician friends. This is a significant but neccesary effort that will help musicians now, and in the future. You can help offset the cost of this essential undertaking by making a donation today. In return, we'll deliver an ad-free experience (which includes hiding the bottom right video ad). Thank you.

Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.