5

Cataclysmic Commentary: Audience Participation

Troy Dostert By

Sign in to view read count
Cataclysmic Commentary: Audience Participation
Tenor saxophonist Ben Cohen and pianist Eli Wallace represent the current generation of adventurous improvising artists, although their prior releases to date have taken very different approaches to their craft. Over the last couple years Wallace has released records with percussionist Rob Pumpelly under the name of Dialectical Imagination—The Angel and the Brute Sing Songs of Rapture (Atma Nadi, 2017) and The Angel and the Brute Sing Songs of Wrath (Atma Nadi, 2018)—both of which used composition as a vehicle for abstract, classically-influenced improvisation. Cohen, on the other hand, with his trio Viriditas has drawn from the more rootsy, tuneful tradition of Ornette Coleman's early music, joining with bassist Ross Gallagher and drummer Deric Dickens for a sound akin to Coleman's open and freewheeling, yet ultimately melodic, aesthetic. Here they're both going in a different direction altogether, teaming up with drummer Dave Miller for a much more unstructured, aggressive "comment" on the fractured political climate in which we live. The music does live up to its billing, even if the album suffers a bit from a lack of cohesion.

The trio invited fans and friends to come up with song titles in advance of the recording date, and with colorful choices like "Surprise Kitten Explosion 5000" or "Texas Chainsaw Focus Group," it's evident they had some fun with this assignment. With each title serving as a springboard for improvisation, one hears expected results, with the less wholesome titles leading to some of Cohen's most bombastic skronks and shrieks, and more benign ones like "Crowded in Solitude" or "Why Am I Not a Painter?" prompting less confrontational explorations.

There's no question that Cohen can bring the goods when it comes to the music's more extreme moments, as his banshee wail on "Surprise Kitten Explosion 5000" can make one's hair stand on end. Miller and Wallace also make for sympathetic partners, capable of matching Cohen's exuberance but taking a less histrionic approach on the more subdued tracks like "Nun Oil" or "Crowded in Solitude," which demand close listening and a more even-tempered delivery. However, the record is rather brief overall, with nine pieces coming in at around 35 minutes total, and with significant shifts in mood and technique from track-to-track, the album has the feel of a series of one-offs rather than an integrated whole. Which is not to say that the trio doesn't gel, as a piece like "Texas Chainsaw Focus Group" possesses enough fury to engage any jaded fan of free improvisation, with Cohen's acerbic tenor feeding maniacally off of Wallace's and Miller's pile-driving pummelings. But these moments work in isolation on the album.

Shortcomings aside, this is a record that suggests some serious potential for these three musicians in this configuration, so hopefully they will continue to channel their concept a bit more on their future releases. We'll stay tuned.

Track Listing

Surprise Kitten Explosion 5000; Nun Oil; Mean Knees; Crowded in Solitude; Ode to Ella; Texas Chainsaw Focus Group; The Last Time You Used a Real Map; Why Am I Not a Painter?; There’s Junk Mail & Terrorism.

Personnel

Ben Cohen: tenor saxophone; Eli Wallace: piano; Dave Miller: drums, cymbals.

Album information

Title: Audience Participation | Year Released: 2018 | Record Label: Eschatology Records

Post a comment about this album

Tags

Shop Amazon

More

Read The Rise Up
The Rise Up
Mehmet Ali Sanlikol
Read New York Moment
New York Moment
JC Hopkins Biggish Band
Read Pollinator
Pollinator
Matt Ulery
Read Hug!
Hug!
Matt Wilson Quartet
Read Touch & Go
Touch & Go
Susan Tobocman
Read The Ilkley Suite
The Ilkley Suite
Jamil Sheriff
Read Moving Through Worlds
Moving Through Worlds
Fiona Joy Hawkins

All About Jazz needs your support

Donate
All About Jazz & Jazz Near You were built to promote jazz music: both recorded and live events. We rely primarily on venues, festivals and musicians to promote their events through our platform. With club closures, shelter in place and an uncertain future, we've pivoted our platform to collect, promote and broadcast livestream concerts to support our jazz musician friends. This is a significant but neccesary effort that will help musicians now, and in the future. You can help offset the cost of this essential undertaking by making a donation today. In return, we'll deliver an ad-free experience (which includes hiding the bottom right video ad). Thank you.

Get more of a good thing

Our weekly newsletter highlights our top stories and includes your local jazz events calendar.