173

Keith Ganz and Sean Smith: A Wish For A Wish To Come True

By

Sign in to view read count
This recording, with its soft acoustic guitar and bass, reminds me, in mood and tempo, of the recording that Charlie Haden and Pat Metheny made a few years back. The disc opens with guitarist Keith Ganz’s title track, a soft, pretty ballad with a memorable melody and pretty changes. Bill Evans’ "Time Remembered" is similar in tempo and mood, as is Ganz’s "Or, As The French Say...", as is the Dietz/Schwartz standard, "Alone Together", which is played, interestingly enough, without any stating of the melody until the out chorus. Jim Hall is an obvious influence and the version here of his "Waltz New" is competent if unspectacular. The problem - and it’s a big problem, is taking someone’s music, playing it like he did, emulating his sound, and playing a solo in his style. What’s the point? Anybody can copy perfectly something that has already been done. That’s not the idea of jazz, it never has been and it never will be. Since I don’t know anything about these two players, I would be simply venturing a guess to say they are young musicians and it seems their hearts are in the right place. They both have good taste (Evans, Hall, Konitz) and they have a strong musical concept - they play with dynamics, they play melodically and they listen. While I think these two have potential I don’t recommend this disc for the reasons stated above - the "sameness" that permeates the date, and the copycat thing. Both players also lack the improvisational and compositional prowess at this point in their development to sustain interest over a long ballad date. I’ve got a feeling we’ll hear bigger and better things from these two in future.

Track Listing: A Wish For A Wish To Come True, Time Remembered, Or, As The French Say..., Alone Together, A Friendly Voice, Lilacs, Waltz New, Gratitude In The Minor, Quirk, Subconscious Lee, Thanks

Personnel: Keith Ganz, guitar, Sean Smith, Bass

Title: A Wish For A Wish To Come True | Year Released: 2001


Tags

comments powered by Disqus

More Articles

Read Heart Knows CD/LP/Track Review Heart Knows
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: September 22, 2017
Read Jersey CD/LP/Track Review Jersey
by Geno Thackara
Published: September 22, 2017
Read Wobbly Danse Flower CD/LP/Track Review Wobbly Danse Flower
by Mike Jurkovic
Published: September 22, 2017
Read Carry Fire CD/LP/Track Review Carry Fire
by Nenad Georgievski
Published: September 22, 2017
Read A Night Walking Through Mirrors CD/LP/Track Review A Night Walking Through Mirrors
by Barry Witherden
Published: September 21, 2017
Read Jondo CD/LP/Track Review Jondo
by Jack Bowers
Published: September 21, 2017
Read "Looking Forward" CD/LP/Track Review Looking Forward
by Geannine Reid
Published: September 6, 2017
Read "Infinitude" CD/LP/Track Review Infinitude
by John Kelman
Published: January 20, 2017
Read "Steeped" CD/LP/Track Review Steeped
by John Eyles
Published: October 20, 2016
Read "Ripple" CD/LP/Track Review Ripple
by Bob Kenselaar
Published: November 29, 2016
Read "Inland Sea" CD/LP/Track Review Inland Sea
by Geno Thackara
Published: July 16, 2017
Read "On A Monday Evening" CD/LP/Track Review On A Monday Evening
by Dan McClenaghan
Published: April 22, 2017

Join the staff. Writers Wanted!

Develop a column, write album reviews, cover live shows, or conduct interviews.