Lou Reed's 1975 release Metal Machine Music
often referred to as "MMM"is one of the most notorious and misunderstood albums in rock history. Its four sides of guitar feedback were not well received by Reed fans used to songs and vocals. The album was critically panned and withdrawn three weeks after release. Many who bought it returned their copies.
In the years that followed, the album gradually acquired cult status, as others listened to the album at length and digested its contents. In 1975, categories such as "noise" and "industrial music" did not exist. MMM spawned them and others, and has exerted a huge effect ever since.
One key player in the increasing influence and rehabilitation of MMM is German-born saxophonist Ulrich Krieger. In 2002 Krieger, then a member of the Berlin-based ensemble Zeitkratzer, transcribed the album for the ten-member grouping. Lou Reed said he thought the task was impossible, but when he heard the results he agreed to appear with Zeitkratzer in a live performance of MMM in Berlin. A CD and DVD of that performance appeared on the Asphodel label in 2007.
Since that concert, Krieger has left Zeitkratzer and moved to California. In 2008, Reed and Krieger formed Metal Machine TrioMM3along with electronics wizard Sarth Calhoun. The trio debuted at REDCAT in Los Angeles in October 2008 and played the New York Blender Theater in April 2009. The recording of the REDCAT concerts was released on a double CD, The Creation of the Universe (Sister Ray, 2008). The trio does not faithfully reproduce MMM, but plays a broad spectrum of improvised music inspired by it. Away from MM3, Krieger also plays with other groupings, notably Text of Light with Lee Ranaldo and Alan Licht, among others.
Metal Machine Trio is currently preparing to tour Europe and Lou Reed is releasing a remastered version of MMM on his Sister Ray label.
All About Jazz: What originally prompted you to start your transcription of Metal Machine Music? How long had you listened to or been aware of MMM?
Ulrich Krieger: When I bought the original album around 1979/80 and listened to it the first time, I thought that it sounded orchestral. I heard a common link between Metal Machine Music and orchestral music by Xenakis and other contemporary classical composers. I also heard it as being connected to free jazz (John Coltrane
, Albert Ayler
, Ornette Coleman
) and industrial music (Throbbing Gristle). This is all music I had been listening to before hearing MMM. So it kind of combined some of my favorite musics in one piece.
The idea of doing an arrangement comes from back then, but it was just an idea. Not until I played with Zeitkratzer in Berlin and we did our first collaboration with noise artists (Merzbow, Karkowski) I realized that this ensemble might be able to play MMM. I listened to it over several weeks doing a rough transcription. Luca Venitucci, accordion player from Rome and Zeitkratzer's accordion player at the time, had also done a rough transcription and we sat down together in Berlin comparing our results. For the most part we had heard the same things, which was very assuring. After that the actual arrangement was done in one week of intense work.
AAJ: Prior to starting the transcription, had you played MMM on saxophone?
UK: No, I didn't play it on saxophone before, and I don't think it would be possible. MMM is a piece which needs an ensemble, especially strings; the larger the ensemble, the better. We did a performance with the Great Learning Orchestra in Stockholm with over thirty players, including sixteen strings. That was great. The last performance was with Fireworks Ensemble in New York and we had ten strings which worked great and was one of the best MMM performances ever, but I wouldn't go below eight to ten string players these days.
You could do something along the lines of MMM with saxophone and electronics, but it never would be MMM, you never could get all the details, melodies, form, etc... I do a lot of noise music on the saxophone, but it is not MMM.
AAJ: When doing your transcription, what problems, if any, did you encounter on the way?
UK: The problem with MMM is that it is so dense. The original transcription/arrangement from 2002 tried to grasp the essential elements and the most important details. Since then I have done three major revisions, adding more material by listening back to the original again and again and adding more details, more precise timings, changing some of the arrangement around to make it sound even closer to the original. And every time a further performance is scheduled I give it another listen and try to add more details and be more precise. Due to its density you always hear new elements, new details.
AAJ: Since Zeitkratzer performed MMM with Lou in 2002, you have left Zeikratzer, relocated to the US and taken up an academic post. Was your departure amicable? Do you envisage playing with Zeitkratzer again in the future?