How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
Does the world really need another John Coltrane compilation album? Yes, most certainly. The world needs as many Coltrane albums, of any description, as can be thrown at it. Even the tackiest, most opportunistic Coltrane compilationstake a bow Coltrane For Lovers (Impulse!, 2001) and Plays For Lovers (Prestige, 2003)are redeemed by the presence of their subject, perhaps the greatest tenor saxophonist who ever lived, and certainly the most influential and enduring.
The Very Best Of The Atlantic Years is, in any case, a fine selection of material from Coltrane's first purple period as a bandleaderearly 1959 through summer 1961, before the final, crowning glories of his time with Impulse! (from 1961 until his passing in 1967).
For Atlantic, Coltrane recorded seven, extraordinary own-name albums, five of them in 1960 aloneGiant Steps (1959), Coltrane Jazz (1960), The Avant-Garde (1960), My Favorite Things (1960), Coltrane's Sound (1960), Coltrane Plays The Blues (1960) and Ole Coltrane (1961). In addition, as co-leader with vibraphonist Milt Jackson, he recorded Bags Meets Trane (1959).
If you stuck pins in the track listings of these discs, selecting fifteen tracks entirely by chance, you'd be guaranteed of coming up with something pretty much as special as this collectionfor there simply isn't one bum tune on any of the original albums. But actually, The Very Best Of The Atlantic Years has been more thoughtfully selected than that.
Personal preferences aside, most Coltrane fans would rate The Avant-Garde, Ole Coltrane and Bags Meets Trane as, relatively speaking, the least well-realized of the Atlantic sets. The compiler of The Very Best Of The Atlantic Years shares this view, and accordingly has selected four tracks from Giant Steps (including, of course, the iconic title track), three from Coltrane Jazz, one from My Favorite Things (the heartrendingly beautiful "Every Time We Say Goodbye") plus an edit of the title track made for 45rpm single release, three from Coltrane's Sound, one from Coltrane Plays The Blues (arguably under-represented vis-a-vis the other original albums), one from Ole Coltrane and one from Bags Meets Trane. The Avant-Garde is ignored completely.
Quite who this latest Coltrane compilation is aimed at is unclear, but whoever they are they're almost bound to love it. As a single CD introduction to Coltrane's Atlantic years it could hardly be bettered; and as a program for existing connoisseurs to whack in the deck and enjoy it won't fail to deliver either.
Track Listing: Giant Steps; Cousin Mary; Naima; Stairway To The Stars; My Favourite Things, Part 1; Mr P.C.; Little Old Lady; Like Sonny; Every Time We Say Goodbye; Central Park West; My Shining Hour; Mr Syms; Equinox; Body And Soul; Aisha.
Personnel: John Coltrane: tenor (1-4, 6-8, 11, 13-15) and soprano (5, 9, 10, 12) saxophone; Tommy Flanagan (1, 2, 6), Wynton Kelly (3, 7, 8, 11), Hank Jones (4), McCoy Tyner (5,9,10,12-15): piano; Paul Chambers (1-4, 6-8, 11), Steve Davis (5, 9, 10, 12-14), Reggie Workman (15): bass; Art Taylor (1, 2, 6), Jimmy Cobb (3, 7, 11), Connie Kay (4), Elvin Jones (5, 9, 10, 12-15): drums; Milt Jackson (4): vibraphone; George Lane (15): alto saxophone; Freddie Hubbard (15): trumpet.