Since emerging in the early 1970s with Henry Cow, multi-instrumentalist Fred Frith has created a large, stylistically diverse body of work and a reputation for being both a fearless improviser and
composerfearless because he has steadfastly avoided any trappings that might lead to predictability, stylistic or otherwise. When he played at the 2008 Festival International de Musique Actuelle Victoriaville with his marvelous new Cosa Brava
band and the eagerly anticipated Art Bears Songbook
, an almost unbelievable criticism of Cosa Brava was that it was too
melodic. As incredible as such an observation might seem, the same might be said of The Happy End Problem
, though it would be no less superficial and just as woeful a misrepresentation.
If anything, The Happy End Problemtwo pieces written for Amanda Miller's Pretty Ugly Dance Companyis a fine summation of Frith's career to date: enigmatic beauty juxtaposed with near-minimalist tendencies; occasional passages of jagged but strangely appealing edges and unapologetic free play blending with cued compositional sections; and a confluence of cultural references that are unmistakable, even as they join together for a new, unified whole.
The nine-part, thirty-minute "Imitation" brings together the ancient and the new in its combination of Kikutsubo Day's shakuhachi, Frith's laptop instruments and Patrice Scanlon's electronic treatments. It marries pentatonic Oriental melodies with denser Western harmony, and oftentimes provides, through Frith's knotty but never over-considered writing, sharp contrasts in very short spaces. That the varied fragments of "Ukon" not only work individually but together as a slowly evolving landscape is demonstrative of Frith's unfettered mindset. Violinist Carla Kihlstedt's idiosyncratic, serpentine themes are separated by open passages where Day's shakuhachi is as textural as it is melodic; a repetitive, minimalist groove slowly emerging in ever-lengthening chunks, divided by obliquely encyclopedic classical references that make "Ukon" and the balance of "Imitation" a compellingand, yes, oftentimes very melodiclisten.
The 21-minute "The Happy End Problem" manages to comfortably marry Igor Stravinsky's "Firebird Suite" (1919) with Frith's curious blend of gentle melodies, farmyard noises and still more Oriental references, with Wu Fei's delicate zither-like gu Zheng meshing with flautist Sheela Bringi, Scanlon's clarinet and cellist Heather Vorwerck. Somewhat less accessible than "Imitation," it remains an appropriate companion piece for its intrepid marriage of seemingly incompatible musical approaches. Still, there are passages of unembellished beauty, as fifteen minutes in Kihlstedt's Eastern European folk inflections combine with Fei's haunting arpeggios to dissolve borders of culture and style, leading into a closing passage of greater dramatic import.
The Happy End Problem may be more about the music and less about specific performances, but it's hard to deny Kihlstedt's charismatic presence throughout. Few can keep up with Frith's demanding, multidisciplinary writing, but Kihlstedt brings a personal presence to music that defies those who believe serious music must inherently be obscure and impenetrable. Though there's nothing lightweight about The Happy End Problem, it's equally about direct and, at times, unadorned lyricism. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Personnel: Fred Frith: guitar, bass, laptop instruments; Carla Kihlstedt: violin; Patrice Scanlon: electronic treatments, clarinet (10); William Winant: percussion; Kikutsubo Day: shakuhachi (1-9); Theresa Wong: cello (1-9); Heather Vorwerck: cello (10); Wu Fei: gu Zheng (10); Sheela Bringi: flute (10).