Sometimes an idea seems great on paper, but in execution doesn't exactly work out as planned. Other times, that same idea doesn't just look great, it actually exceeds already high expectations. When saxophonist Tommy Smith
almost single-handedly responsible for rebuilding a modern jazz scene in his home country of Scotland, where he returned after studying at Boston's Berklee College of Music in the 1980s and releasing a couple of well-regarded albums on Blue Notebrought his Scottish National Jazz Orchestra to the United States in the summer of 2013 for a short tour, he came up with the idea of hitting Avatar Studios in New York City to record a number of well-known jazz tunes, largely arranged by a collection of American composers/arrangers and featuring a cherry-picked collection of A-list American players.
The result, American Adventure
, might be considered a pleasant surprise, if it weren't for the consistent excellence Smith and the SNJO have already demonstrated on albums like Torah
(Spartacus, 2010), an ambitious suite of music originally written by the Scottish saxophonist to feature Joe Lovano
(who delivered the piece with SJNO in 1999) but, on the recording, featured Smith in one of the best performances of his career to date.
Smith didn't just choose a roster of well-picked players, known for their impressive virtuosity, sheer musicality and appreciation of the tradition; he also matched them perfectly to the project's commissioned music. Fred Sturm's brassy, funkified arrangement of Marcus Miller
's "Splatch," first heard on Miles Davis
' electro-centric 1986 Warner Bros. debut, Tutu
, features a Davis alum from earlier in the '80s, electric guitarist Mike Stern
, who turns in a solo of characteristically high octane, bop-centric phrases and visceral bends, leading to an incendiary duo with SNJO drummer Alyn Cosker
And speaking of incendiary, Jim McNeely
's arrangement of pianist Richie Beirach
's "Pendulum"the title track to the live recording Pendulum
(Artist House, 1978), reissued in expanded form by Mosaic in 2008 as Mosaic Select 32: Pendulum Live at the Village Vanguard
becomes a ten-minute tour de force
that, beyond McNeely's expansion of the tune's basic premise into something more appropriately epic, features positively nuclear solos from tenor saxophonist Donny McCaslin
, pianist Dave Kikoski
(the only artist to feature on more than one track) and saxophonist Dave Liebman
, Beirach's longtime musical cohort who played on the original, continues to play it with the pianist in the reformed Quest
, and here rips it up with a searing soprano solo that may well provide the album's most thrilling moment.
And that's saying something. Vibraphonist Joe Locke
turns in a powerhouse performance on Sturm's energetic rework of Wayne Shorter
's "Yes or No," originally from the saxophone legend's JuJu
(Blue Note, 1964), but here swinging so hard it just about bursts off the page, with Cosker taking very little solo space but listed as "featured," no doubt, for his potent performance throughout. Saxophonist Bill Evans
manages to evoke memories of Michael Brecker
without being at all imitative on Smith's reverent but expansive arrangement of Chick Corea
's "Quartet No. 1 (part 2)," from the pianist's classic Three Quartets
(Stretch, 1981), while another Shorter composition, "Pinocchio," first heard on Miles Davis' Nefertiti
(Columbia, 1967) and here, arranged by Jacob Mann to swing in a more traditional space, closes the set on a high note with impressive turns by trombonist Michael Dease
, saxophonist Joel Frahm
and drummer Clarence Penn
. Geoffrey Keezer
's arrangement of John Coltrane
's balladic "Dear Lord" (featuring the consistently excellent Kikoski, as well as a lyrically searching solo from trumpeter Randy Brecker
) and Smith's lush arrangement of Charles Mingus
' "Duke Ellington's Sound of Love" (sung by Kurt Elling
and with the arranger featured on an elegant solo) add much-needed respite from the rest of American Adventure
's thrill-a-minute energy, a Scottish-born but undeniably credible and deep tribute to the tradition that succeeds on many levels.
Intelligent, contemporary big band arrangements for Smith's clearly talented and broadly capable Scottish National Jazz Orchestra combine, on American Adventure
, with its collection of a baker's dozen of top-drawer American musicianswell, twelve Americans plus one Scotfor an hour-long set that, in the very capable hands of Smith and his stellar 14-piece big band, prove the tradition is alive, well...and taking place on a global scale.
Track Listing: Splatch; Duke Ellington's Sound of Love; Yes or No; Pendulum; Dear Lord; Quartet No. 1 (part 2); Pinocchio.
Personnel: Ru Pattison: alto and soprano saxophones; Martin Kershaws: clarinet, alto axophone; Konrad Wiszniewski: tenor saxophone; Bill Fleming: baritone saxophone; Ryan Quigley: trumpet, flugelhorn; Cameron Jay: trumpet, flugelhorn; Tom MacNiven: trumpet, flugelhorn; James Marr: trumpet, flugelhorn; Chris Greive: trombone; Phil O'Malley: trombone; Michael Owers: bass trombone; Brian Kellock: piano (1-3, 7); Calum Gourlay: acoustic bass; Alyn Cosker; drums (1-6); Mike Stern: guitar (1); Kurt Elling: vocals (2); Tommy Smith: director/conductor, tenor saxophone (2); Joe Locke: vibraphone (3), Donny McCaslin: tenor saxophone (4); Dave Kikosi: piano (4-6); Dave Liebman: soprano saxophone (4); Randy Brecker: trumpet (5); Bill Evans: tenor saxophone (6); Michael Dease: trombone (7); Joel Frahm: tenor saxophone (7); Clarence Penn: drums (7).