How we rate: our writers tend to review music they like within their preferred genres.
We really don't have many living jazz legends walking around these days, but fortunately we're lucky enough to still have Horace Silver going strong (just check out his new release, Jazz Has a Sense of Humor, if you need proof) and maintaining the jazz tradition that he's so intimately tied to. Over the course of 26 years, Silver recorded extensively for Blue Note and during the label's 60th anniversary year it would appear logical that he would receive the "boxed set" treatment. On the one hand, it seems almost an embarrassment to try to contain the vast and varied repertoire of Silver's on a mere four compact discs. However, due to prudent selection Blue Note has largely succeeded in their attempt to blanket the hits and span the years. You'll find 45 selections presented chronologically and taken from 24 of Silver's finest albums, from the years 1952 to 1978.
The first disc presents three trio tracks, to be followed by the first incarnation of the Jazz Messengers and the early classics "The Preacher" and "Doodlin." Several quintets from the late '50s are then heard with further hits such as "Senor Blues," "Cookin' at the Continental," and "Home Cookin.'" Even at this early stage, Silver's knack for writing memorable charts for the basic hard bop line-up puts him in a class unto himself. Of course, such "name" players as Hank Mobley, Art Farmer, Louis Haynes, Blue Mitchell, and Clifford Jordan are on hand to insure quality too.
From 1959 to 1963, Silver was able to keep together a working band that despite a few changes in drummers remained stable and stood him in good steed over the course of several noteworthy albums. Disc two is fully devoted to this unit. While it's hard to choose among the many recorded highlights of this period, one can hardly fault such selections as "Sister Sadie," "Nica's Dream," "Filthy McNasty," and "Strollin.'" Particularly superlative are two cuts from the oft-neglected Tokyo Blues. A singular piece among Silver's discography, his way of crafting oriental-sounding melodies on top of various Latin grooves reaches its pinnacle with the lengthy and incendiary "Sayonara Blues."
Although the middle to the end of the decade would be a time of transition in terms of changing fads and unsteady personnel, the majority of Silver's music was no less valuable than what had proceeded it. In truth, his biggest commercial success would come in the form of a true jazz classic, "Song For My Father." As essential a hit as it was, it also served to overshadow subsequent releases such as the masterful Cape Verdean Blues, represented here by the title track and "Nutville." Woody Shaw had taken over the trumpet chair at this point and it's a delight to hear him during the spring of his career, just sample his delectable solo on "Mexican Hip Dance" for a taste of his genius.
Closing out disc three and filling the last disc are probably the least understood and most obscure pieces from the catalog. With only a few selected titles appearing in Japan, Silver's recordings from the '70s have yet to make it to reissue and that's a shame because there's a lot to admire here and these sets are the only documents we have of Silver's writing being arranged for large ensembles. The six cuts sampled that come from the Silver 'N... series are meaty and chock full of stimulating melodic ideas, choice solos, and well- developed charts. They deserve a much better fate and are arguably some of the better mainstream jazz performances of the '70s.
While the packaging on this set is largely no-frills, two slim-line jewel cases are housed in a box that also includes a 50-page booklet with track-by-track commentary provided by writer Zan Stewart. In addition, a healthy number of Frank Wolff photos from the actual sessions appear, many being published for the first time. Either as a worthy introduction for the novice or as a gap filler for the initiated (especially in terms of disc four), The Horace Silver Retrospective can easily be recommended without reservations, aside from the hope that Blue Note will get around to reissuing Silver's work from the '70s in the near future.
Track Listing: Disc One:Safari; Ecaroh; Opus De Funk; Doodlin'; The Preacher; Cool Eyes; Senor Blues; Home Cookin'; Soulville; The Outlaw; Senor Blues (Vocal Version); Swingin' The Samba; Cookin' At The Continental; Juicy Lucy
Disc Two:Sister Sadie; Peace; Blowin' The Blues Away; Strollin'; Nica's Dream; Filthy McNasty; The Tokyo Blues; Sayonara Blues; Silver's Serenade
Disc Three:Song For My Father; Que Pasa; The Cape Verdean Blues; Nutville; The Jody Grind; Mexican Hip Dance; Serenade To A Soul Sister; Psychedelic Sally; It's Time; The Happy Medium; Peace; Old Mother Nature Calls
Disc Four:How Much Does Matter Really Matter; All; In Pursuit Of The 27th Man; Gregory Is Here; Barbara; Adjustment; The Tranquilizer Suite; The Process Of Creation Suite; All In Time; The Soul And It's Expression.
Personnel: Horace Silver- piano, vocals on "All" with various groups including Hank Mobley, Clifford Jordan, Junior Cook, Joe Henderson, Stanley Turrentine, Harold Vick, Bob Berg, Michael Brecker- tenor sax; James Spaulding- flute; Donald Byrd, Kenny Dorham, Art Farmer, Blue Mitchell, Woody Shaw, Charles Tolliver, Randy Brecker, Cecil Bridgewater, Tom Harrell- trumpet; J.J. Johnson- trombone; Richie Resnicoff- guitar; Doug Watkins, Teddy Kotick, Teddy Smith, Gene Ramey, Larry Ridley, Gene Taylor, Bob Cranshaw, Ron Carter- bass; Art Blakey, Louis Hayes, John Harris Jr., Roger Humphries, Roy Brooks, Mickey Roker, Al Foster- drums; David Friedman- vibes on "In Pursuit of the 27th Man"; Gail Nelson- vocals on "How Much Does Matter Really Matter"